Disclaimer: Currently 3 in the morning, my post may not be totally sane or correct, and everything I'm about to say is probably at like 70% of my best effort
Firstly: I'm a pessimist, I don't think town's winning this game. Hopefully I'm wrong. At least since everybody's had so different reads, I won't be the number #1 candidate for LVP?
About my being a PR or no, one of Teproc and Galzria is very wrong. I have not claimed once this game what my role is and if you think you know based on my posts, I would recommend dropping that assumption.
Now for reads:
The player who I think is most correct and is making the most sense, other than very significant incorrect accusation, is DatSwan. I agree with him; I think the team is faust/chairs/RR, that's me going on the record. The post where he claims VT in #622 just screams town to me. He's had some mafia experience, according to Galzria, but I have too, and I know that I would make some very bold moves as skum in my first game. But claiming VT halfway through day 2 is not one of them. Plus, the rest of that post feels genuine.
I have to put my faith in Galzria as town. I'm aware he's crafty, I'm aware he's a feared scum player, but I think his points have made a lot of sense. In any event, as DatSwan said, he's a bad lynch today. I don't know if I love his reads, but everybody's screaming different things. If I'm wrong about him, I take solace in knowing I won't be the first sailor he's Sirened to death.
Andrew: I didn't pay too close attention to him, I'll try again later. There's no blaring scum alarms, but he's slipped down on my town radar quite a bit. I'd also put him out of the lynch pool for now, but he could be scum, I won't discount the possibility.
Raptor: Oh boy, I just don't know what to think. One thing is for sure: with all due respect Raptor, your reads have not been good. You've voted for Robz, Jake, and pushed a TWM/Skumpy team pretty hard. That's 0/4 right there. He has not done anything this game to suggest that he's town. TWM said he saw something suspicious Raptor said day 2, I need to go back and look for that at some point. At the end of the day, he hasn't pushed hard a case for or against anyone, besides me, and seems willing to sit back and the let the fireworks show unfold.
But
I don't know the guy. DatSwan and Galzria both say they do, and both say this is very natural for him. I don't know how he would play as scum, but I suspect the scum team would ask him to be more involved. And the vote on Faust is giving me serious pause into thinking there's a team there, and I've already said I believe faust to be scum. The vote on Robz is so strange and undefended that I think as scum, he would rather sit on his vote a little longer. He's not my last choice for a lynch, but I believe it could be a big mistake to lynch him. In addition, if my theory is correct, or even a little off, I think he might have an eventful night if he's alive for it, and I would be very interested to see what transpires then (of course, I [or maybe Andrew?] will be dead instead).
Other 3: Scummy
With my numbers question about faust's status, I kind of went into it thinking anyone who answered 2 would be shady, which is what chairs did, RR similar. They're apparently willing to lynch faust, but they don't want to vote there. I wonder if #902 is faust giving some day instructions. I've said numerous times why I think faust is scum, and chairs and RR have just not contributed and made their feelings very well known. Plus, I'd like to Gkrieg called it correct in the first few minutes.
So there you go. I think that's where we should be focusing, and I think staying on Raptor could have some serious repercussions. Again, I might change my mind in the future, and I could be very wrong about Raptor. I think it's a mistake.
Skumpy out, Roger Roger.