Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[iguanaiguana]

Yesterday, Robz said this:

Not true, I'm caught up and paying attention.  I want to see what mafia does with the list thing, so I'm eager for a hammer.

Today, these are his only comments on the list.

Lot of people assuming mafia wants to kill werewolves. Is this true right now? If both WWs died, then, um, there's no nightkill at all, right? Mafia can't kill. I don't think mafia want this to happen so quickly.

Pretty generic. Hm.

[Eevee]

Only got home now, too tired to read up before bed. I'll catch up when I get up.

[2.71828.....]

I think the exact opposite of E.

I mean, clearly he's wrong. WW's shot TWM, who was very obviously townie. Most townie, in fact. So clearly they want to work with Mafia at least for a while.

Mafia clearly guessed (if you can call it that) right that WWs would shoot the townie.

I actually think this makes RR look like a Mafia who was added to the list with the expectation that very townie TWM or ig would get shot.

Vote: RR

@iguana

Robz also said this, which is clearly related to what mafia did with the list. Not sure what you are trying to prove there with those selective quotes. It looks more like conformation bias hunting than scum hunting

[2.71828.....]

Confirmation*

[Robz888]

Thank you, E.

[iguanaiguana]

I think the exact opposite of E.

I mean, clearly he's wrong. WW's shot TWM, who was very obviously townie. Most townie, in fact. So clearly they want to work with Mafia at least for a while.

Mafia clearly guessed (if you can call it that) right that WWs would shoot the townie.

I actually think this makes RR look like a Mafia who was added to the list with the expectation that very townie TWM or ig would get shot.

Vote: RR

@iguana

Robz also said this, which is clearly related to what mafia did with the list. Not sure what you are trying to prove there with those selective quotes. It looks more like conformation bias hunting than scum hunting

Yeah, I missed that. I was looking for something like that but didn't see it. Def not confirmation bias. Just trying to open discussion and get reactions.

Thanks for another insult on my play though. Not appreciated.

[Robz888]

At the time I posted my "eager for flip, wanna see the list in action" post, I have convinced myself that it might be in mafia's best interests to not submit a list at all.

Later I realized this was stupid.

[Robz888]

I had* convinced myself.

And was particularly eager to see if I was right.

[iguanaiguana]

Seems pretty legit

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

I like a Vote: ash.
town!ash is always more engaged in the game. The lack of posting and lack of crazy game theory like usual seems somewhat scummy.

Catching up right now

Agree with this.

[2.71828.....]

#discredittheIC

Not that we have an IC, more like iguana is just universally town read.

And iguana, it's a critique, not an insult. Constructive criticism. It was never my intent to insult you, and I apologize if I have offended you

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

I think ashersky's lower than usual activity in this game means he is town.

I like what robz did, even if I agree with a few of his reads.
My thoughts (in no particular order):
Town:
e
Iguana
Ashersky
Robz
RR
Eevee

Scum:
Jake
J Reggie
Teproc
Gkrieg
Joseph

Worst list ever

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Joseph is town.

I think this is an opinion that needs to be reevaluated.

Why ? I mean why is Joseph scum ? After Smallville, I just have no idea with him... I guess he's more in the background this game ?

Not necessarily in the background. I am not a fan of his voting history D1, but there is a lot of PoE related to placing him as scum

Stop with the mega early POE

[gkrieg13]

I think ashersky's lower than usual activity in this game means he is town.

I like what robz did, even if I agree with a few of his reads.
My thoughts (in no particular order):
Town:
e
Iguana
Ashersky
Robz
RR
Eevee

Scum:
Jake
J Reggie
Teproc
Gkrieg
Joseph

Worst list ever

Is it just the worst because it includes you?

[2.71828.....]

Joseph is town.

I think this is an opinion that needs to be reevaluated.

Why ? I mean why is Joseph scum ? After Smallville, I just have no idea with him... I guess he's more in the background this game ?

Not necessarily in the background. I am not a fan of his voting history D1, but there is a lot of PoE related to placing him as scum

Stop with the mega early POE

5/11 scum.

1) not mega early

2) no

this post receives an official +1 from player: Robz888

[Robz888]

I wish I could +1 the above.

hmmmmm

[ashersky]

vote: jake

Queue crazy OMGUS in 3....2....1....

[Joseph2302]

vote: jake

Queue crazy OMGUS in 3....2....1....

Really? Jake strongly opposed what turned out to be a bad lynch

[ashersky]

vote: jake

Queue crazy OMGUS in 3....2....1....

Really? Jake strongly opposed what turned out to be a bad lynch

Why does that make anyone Town?  Strongly opposing a scum lynch isn't even useful info due to multiball.

I just think his play is scummy and not matching his town style.

[Eevee]

Reads:

Town:
Iguana
RR
e
Teproc?

Going back and forth:
e
Robz

Scum:
J Reggie
Joseph
Ashersky
Jake
Gkrieg

[Eevee]

Definitely not too early for PoE!

@Iguana
I think you are playing the best game out of anyone thisfar. Being so universally townread is strong play, regardless of your alignment even, so hats off.

[gkrieg13]

Can we please lynch Eevee already?  He just seems sooooo off.

[Eevee]

Do you have anything concrete you'd like my response to? I feel I'm on!

Hmm. Unrelated: Is convincing your scumreads you are town a fruitful exercise in this setup?

[gkrieg13]

Do you have anything concrete you'd like my response to? I feel I'm on!

Hmm. Unrelated: Is convincing your scumreads you are town a fruitful exercise in this setup?

Why wouldn't it be?

[gkrieg13]

vote: jake

Queue crazy OMGUS in 3....2....1....

Really? Jake strongly opposed what turned out to be a bad lynch

Why does that make anyone Town?  Strongly opposing a scum lynch isn't even useful info due to multiball.

I just think his play is scummy and not matching his town style.

I agree with this. I think I'm more likely to oppose the D1 lynch as scum than as town. We all know that town will lynch itself anyway, so it is easier to stay out of it and even oppose it slightly. I think it was UoS that said that you should choose someone to white knight when you are scum, in order to win.