I'm still quite torn. I thought I'd drop some useful stuff in-thread while I deliberate. Re-reading is hard and long :-(
Voting history for Dylan
Day 1: Jake (#292), TWM (#436), JR (#883)
Day 2: Space (#1765), sudgy (#2054), Andrew (#2303), Not Voting (#2305), sudgy (#2359), Cuzz (#2422)
Day 3: sudgy (#2915)
Day 4: No votes
Day 5: iguana (#3747)
Day 6: sudgy (#3793), LL (#3996)
Day 7: sudgy (#4050), Not Voting (#4057), Galz (#4064), sudgy (#4102)
Voting history for sudgy
Day 1: TWM (#508), JR (#979), TWM (#1055), JR (#1186)
Day 2: TWM (#1584), Not Voting (#1950), Andrew (#2287), Cuzz (#2405)
Day 3: ash (#2795), e (#3244)
Day 4: ash (#3441)
Day 5: Space (#3765)
Day 6: faust (#3877)
Day 7: Dylan (#4069)
Voting history for RR
Day 1: mcmc (#1298)
Day 2: Andrew (#2478), Not Voting (#2486), Andrew (#2522), Not Voting (#2528)
Day 3: iguana (#2637), Jimmmmm (#2894), Not Voting (#2939), e (#3005)
Day 4: No votes
Day 5: iguana (#3740)
Day 6: faust (#3921), Not Voting (#3969), LL (#3985)
Day 7: O (#4059), Dylan (#4107)
Voting history for O
Day 1: Not Voting (#260), RR (#358), Awaclus (#678), LL (#1221), Not Voting (#1256), Awaclus (#1345)
Day 2: faust (#1539), Space (#1600), faust (#1931), ash (#2151), Andrew (#2286), faust (#2445), Andrew (#2477), Not Voting (#2567)
Day 3: faust (#2664), Not Voting (#2668), ash (#2721)
Day 4: ash (#3412), Not Voting (#3473)
Day 5: Space (#3612), faust (#3684), Space (#3691)
Day 6: Space (#3861), faust (#3966), LL (#4020)
Day 7: sudgy (#4099), Dylan (#4117)
Voting history for Galz
Day 1: JR (#571), Not Voting (#1140), LL (#1207)
Day 2: Dylan (#1755), Andrew (#2557), Not Voting (#2568)
Day 3: ash (#2794), Not Voting (#3085), e (#3119)
Day 4: Not Voting (#3555)
Day 5: No votes
Day 6: sudgy (#3783)
Day 7: sudgy (#4091)
Voting history for Space
Day 1: LL (#144), mcmc (#974), JR (#1382)
Day 2: Cuzz (#2432)
Day 3: e (#3315)
Day 4: iguana (#3475), ash (#3549)
Day 5: iguana (#3617)
Day 6: LL (#3860)
Day 7: No votes
Voting history for Awaclus
Day 1: e (#461), O (#698)
Day 2: O (#1545)
Day 3: No votes
Day 4: No votes
Day 5: O (#3682), iguana (#3768)
Day 6: sudgy (#3870)
Day 7: O (#4065)