Ash reread (including mentions of him, darn PPS' signature that quotes him):
In
#346 he says that O is towny and gkrieg, mcmc, TWM, and faust are all scummy. Then town on Cuzz in the next post.
Lalight is willing to lynch RR, mcmc, and ash in
#483.
He calls faust scummy again in
#498, but later says he was joking.
Then, in
#549, faust says he wants to take ash out of the lynch pool. Interesting.
In
#556 LaLight says that ash, mcmc, RR, gkrieg, and TWM have all done something scummy and is fine lynching any of them.
O gives several reads in
#654, putting Awaclus, faust, gkrieg, RR, and ash in his scum camp.
In
#896 faust keeps ash out of the lynch pool, along with RR, LaLight, TWM, iguana, O, mcmc, and Andrew.
Ash in
#914 says that Galzria, gkrieg, and faust have done a few towny things.
Ash in
#1093 says faust is town, and says Galzria's read on faust is towny.
In
#1819 (man that's a big jump) RR does his scumpoints thing, and ash is very slightly towny, with basically no points.
In
#1946 O has a big would lynch list (9 players) which includes ash.
Then mcmc's claim and the plan came. At this point ash is becoming increasingly obviously scum. People scumreading ash here aren't as suspicious now.
After the HH claim and plan, in
#2143 O says that the biggest whiners (which he lists as ash, faust, and Galzria) are most likely to be scum. He then votes for him in #2151. Continues saying he's scum in #2178.
Galzria in
#2198 posts his preferred lynch order, and ash is in the middle (iguana's also in the middle, too).
Dylan puts ash in "lean town" in his preferred lynch order in
#2243. And in #2263 he says "I think Ash is most likely town, but recognize he could be scum."
Galzria claims to have jailed ash in
#2669, and kind of votes for him in #2682. He says he probably blocked ash N2.
O keeps on saying ash is scum.
Faust says that ash in nowhere near confiremd scum in
#2693.
O finally votes for ash in
#2721.
Ash that Galzria reads as town but his play seems like scum in
#2740.
In
#2791, ash suggest Awaclus should lead the massclaim. In another reread that I'm taking a break from, I realized that there is a possibility that Awaclus and RR were bus driven when TWM tried to hide (not too likely, but possible), so this could ring alarm bells.
In
#2794, galzria finally votes for ash.
In Awaclus' claim order in
#2847, ash and iguana are on the lower end of the list.
In
#2915, Dylan is leaning scum on ash.
Ash starts ridiculous claiming in
#3041. Faust likes it, O doesn't, LaLight doesn't.
Ash seems to suggest that faust is scum in
#3262, but at this point I don't think we can trust ash anymore.
Lalight votes ash in
#3295.
In
#3302, Space says she wants to vote for ash but seems unsure.
Faust says RR and ash are scum in
#3334.
Fuast votes ash in
#3374. However, ash is even more obvscum than he was already before.
LaLight also votes ash in
#3397.
RR says ash is scummy in
#3408.
So, faust and ash are having a huge fight here.
Space says she could vote ash. I'm not sure where the first post that she says this is.
Galzria claims to have jailed ash in
#3472RR seems to want to lynch faust more than ash.
Galzria wants to lynch in
#3529, but is uncertain if he would rather lynch faust because of the consequences. He switches to definitely ash a couple posts later.
Space puts in tons of evidence towards ash being scum in
#3549, bring his chances of being scum from 200% to 300%.
I'm sorry, I'm really tired now after doing that whole thing. I'll come back later.
Author
Topic: Mafia 100: Forum All-Stars -- GAME OVER (Read 423501 times)