Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Eevee]

I don't get the argument? Wouldn't a partner of Calamatis' be careful not to say something like that?

levels and levels

Space is smart and concious enough to make this post being Calamitas' partner

Hey, you (and maybe faust, but definitely you!) should know me well enough to understand that me addressing a point or two to Calamitas about something setuppy when he and I are both clearly struggling to engage with the wild reads party of D1 is not unusual in the slightest. I think if I'd been part of a scum faction, the smart thing would have been to keep my inferences quiet.

This is real scummy.

Hmm. I assert that it isn't, because I'm not scum. Why do you think I'd be more inclined to say something like that as scum than as town, especially given the context in which I said it?

You have started the "if i was scum, i would have.." analysis multiple times this game, which seems like an uncharacteristic frame of mind to be in for a town player.

Vote: space even. Being scum being top of mind is scummy!

[faust]

Also @spaceanemone I think my explaination of banter was quite acceptable for the context of a mafia game, I would appreciate if you tried not to get too RSP about terminology in thread.

I would rather have everyone be able to express their feelings in a civil manner. Follow-ups can then be moved to RSP.

[mcmcsalot]

Woah I just found out how to ctrl-find on an iPhone!!!! Mcmc's game is about to step it up a few notches. For those curious just open the page you want to find and then type what you want to find up in the URL search bar then scroll down below the suggested pages and there is an "on this page" button. Life has changed as we know it.

[O]

I don't get the argument? Wouldn't a partner of Calamatis' be careful not to say something like that?

levels and levels

Space is smart and concious enough to make this post being Calamitas' partner

Hey, you (and maybe faust, but definitely you!) should know me well enough to understand that me addressing a point or two to Calamitas about something setuppy when he and I are both clearly struggling to engage with the wild reads party of D1 is not unusual in the slightest. I think if I'd been part of a scum faction, the smart thing would have been to keep my inferences quiet.

This is real scummy.

Hmm. I assert that it isn't, because I'm not scum. Why do you think I'd be more inclined to say something like that as scum than as town, especially given the context in which I said it?

You have started the "if i was scum, i would have.." analysis multiple times this game, which seems like an uncharacteristic frame of mind to be in for a town player.

Vote: space even. Being scum being top of mind is scummy!

Did you always wagon this hard Eevee?

[Eevee]

I'm not a fan of the way Eevee abandoned the J Reggie wagon. Scum would definitely want the Reggie wagon to die after the claim.

hey I said this first

So it would have been townier to keep voting for the town player?

The question is: did you know he's town back there?

To be fair to me, I didn't even proclaim him to
be town. People seemed very trigger happy, Jimmm had asked us to wait over the weekend, it wasn't so much that I thought Reggie to look towny than that I didn't think he was so scummy to warrant a premature lynch.

Now that we had such a fortunate night, having lynched a VT with no other claims day 1 doesn't seem like the worst thing ever, but I maintain that after the claim rushing to lynch reggie was maybe not necessary.

If that's scummy to you, so be it. Basically for me the end of day decision is a function of time left and how superior to the alternatives the lynch candidate is. Reggie didn't seem like a good lynch for that time for me.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Cuzz's attempts to discredit me and anyone who might suspect him by suggesting there's no evidence that he is scum is convincing me further that he is in fact scum.

[LaLight]

I'm not a fan of the way Eevee abandoned the J Reggie wagon. Scum would definitely want the Reggie wagon to die after the claim.

hey I said this first

So it would have been townier to keep voting for the town player?

The question is: did you know he's town back there?

To be fair to me, I didn't even proclaim him to
be town. People seemed very trigger happy, Jimmm had asked us to wait over the weekend, it wasn't so much that I thought Reggie to look towny than that I didn't think he was so scummy to warrant a premature lynch.

Now that we had such a fortunate night, having lynched a VT with no other claims day 1 doesn't seem like the worst thing ever, but I maintain that after the claim rushing to lynch reggie was maybe not necessary.

If that's scummy to you, so be it. Basically for me the end of day decision is a function of time left and how superior to the alternatives the lynch candidate is. Reggie didn't seem like a good lynch for that time for me.

This is a surprisingly townie post. Okay, I believe you

[Eevee]

What do you mean by "wagon this hard"? I spoke against all the bigger wagons yesterday, and even scummily abandoned the wagon of our lynched VT.

[O]

Cuzz's attempts to discredit me and anyone who might suspect him by suggesting there's no evidence that he is scum is convincing me further that he is in fact scum.

circles are very lame shapes.

What do you mean by "wagon this hard"? I spoke against all the bigger wagons yesterday, and even scummily abandoned the wagon of our lynched VT.

I'd say you quickly joined them without much reasoning before speaking against them, but I might be misremembering outside of J Reggie?

But abandoning wagons doesn't mean you didn't wagon in the first place

[O]

blegh I have absolutely no substantial reads whatsoever. I usually like to be more committal than this but I just keep poking people and seeing their responses and nothing stands out.

[mcmcsalot]

Vote Count 1.12

mcmcsalot (1): RoadRunner7671
J Reggie (10): 2.7128...., Dylan32, gkrieg13, LaLight, JaketheBaseballGod22, sudgy, iguanaiguana, SpaceAnemone, The_Wine_Merchant, mcmcsalot
The_Wine_Merchant (1): ashersky
O (1): Awaclus
gkrieg13 (1): AndrewisFTTW
RoadRunner7671 (1): Cuzz
LaLight (2): Galzria, pingpongsam
Galzria (2): J Reggie, faust
Awaclus (2): O, Eevee

Not Voting (2): Calamitas, Jimmmmm

With 23 alive it took just 10 to lynch.

Not super helpful

[SpaceAnemone]

Also @spaceanemone I think my explaination of banter was quite acceptable for the context of a mafia game, I would appreciate if you tried not to get too RSP about terminology in thread.

Point taken. I was in the frame of mind of trying to help LL, as a non-native speaker, avoid using it in conversation inappropriately, rather than trying to make a political point. (LL and I have become friends through here to the point where he's visited me in the UK once already, so IRL English coaching seems quite relevant and natural to me).

I would rather have everyone be able to express their feelings in a civil manner. Follow-ups can then be moved to RSP.

Sure, sorry if I came across as too critical in the way I expanding on mcmc's definition; being uncivil was certainly not my intention.

[O]

i very much think this is a non issue and nobody did anything wrong

[mcmcsalot]

I quickly scanned the vote counts and what stood out is that the twm wagon, created by myself(town) and jreggie(conf!town) had some steam and was decimated by galzria's expert case on jreggie. A wagon he later abandoned and managed to not be on. I guess important to note if twm is scum galz looks pretty darn scummy.

[Eevee]

I'm pretty sure I never voted for mcmc or gkrieg. I was trying to start awaclus or andrew wagons, but didn't get much support, and i joined the reggie train for a bit and then abandoned it after the claim.

[faust]

Cuzz's attempts to discredit me and anyone who might suspect him by suggesting there's no evidence that he is scum is convincing me further that he is in fact scum.

circles are very lame shapes.

Pretty ironic considering your username.

[Eevee]

I'm pretty sure I never voted for mcmc or gkrieg. I was trying to start awaclus or andrew wagons, but didn't get much support, and i joined the reggie train for a bit and then abandoned it after the claim.

*or tmw

[mcmcsalot]

i very much think this is a non issue and nobody did anything wrong

Totally agree and totally understood space's very harmeless intentions.

[O]

Cuzz's attempts to discredit me and anyone who might suspect him by suggesting there's no evidence that he is scum is convincing me further that he is in fact scum.

circles are very lame shapes.

Pretty ironic considering your username.

I have the credibility to make the claim.

[faust]

I would rather have everyone be able to express their feelings in a civil manner. Follow-ups can then be moved to RSP.

Sure, sorry if I came across as too critical in the way I expanding on mcmc's definition; being uncivil was certainly not my intention.

I did not intend to imply that you were uncivil.

[mcmcsalot]

I'm pretty sure I never voted for mcmc or gkrieg. I was trying to start awaclus or andrew wagons, but didn't get much support, and i joined the reggie train for a bit and then abandoned it after the claim.

*or tmw

This would be more helpful if you did this while also having solid reads on gkrieg/myself/twm. Did you and if so can you quote? Because without those reads it feels more like you are saying "I avoided all the wagons except the one on a townie which I supported then ditched before it got hammered"

[mcmcsalot]

gkrieg is making sense, and being helpful.

I don't like lynching TWM.

Psa for those using my new find on iPhone...it doesn't hold your search when you open a quote in a new tab

Anyway this is what I first found from eevee talking about gkrieg and twm. He also mentioned a town read on me due to my post about people not discussing setup stuff.

The urge to call a galzria/eevee/twm scum team is rising.

[Eevee]

I was against lynching anyone at the top of the post count charts in general.

I was about type something about how premature it is to call scum teams (dude, just try to get one right), but then I remembered I've said the same thing to mcmc many times before. Probably not an alignment-tell for him, although I don't remember his alignments from previous times (people are usually town, so probably town though).

I guess I'll bite anyways, why me+galzria+twm?

[LaLight]

I'll bite

[pingpongsam]

Today's reads (without looking at player list or anything, off the head from the heart):

PPS - love that guy can't even question the potential for him not to be town
Eevee - town reading all day long
Glazria - super town to the rescue
Big mcmc - still town reading this one
E - see nothing other than he was first on Regina. Lots of people were on Regina, as in more than I think can be scum in this game.
O - looks towny enough, should keep him around for comic relief if nothing else
Awaclus - if O is town so is he, need somebody around here to piss people off, it's excellent stuff, need more Awaclus

Faust/cuzz - two people I want most to be town but fear may not be. Can't be arsed to vote them today though barring a cop result or something crazy like that.
Spaceace - nullicious, means they AR eprobably town won't lynch today
Jimmmmm - ready to see some Logan sleuthing, not lynching here
Sudgy - no idea if this is a silly town with low activity or a scum stooge but the activity around this one sets off the scum tingles. Somebody interacting about him is scum regardless of his own alignment.

TWM - I don't know but I think we get this most information in this flip from any other to date. Can always hope he's scum.
LaLight- the scumz, lynch plox
Andrew - teh scumz, lynch plox
Ashersky - The plan was for scum to sit quiet D1-? And let town off the,sleeves. The Calamitas flip spoiled the surprise. Ashersky is still holding fast to the plan.

Okay, now I look to see who I forgot was even playing the game anymore:
Dylan, Jake, iguana, RR.

All but RR are clearly playing along to ashersky's plan lynch the lot of them.