Summary analysis of Eevee (typed in the order of appearance, that is no, refining as I discover new stuff in the reading)(I read using the print feature and searching the player so no post numbers or quotes):
-D1, totally rickrolled by the ashersky gambit. Post after post wringing his hands over it. I thought the play was clear so maybe if eevee is scum that explains why they fell for it hook line and sinker N1.
-Looks pretty active D1 once he gets past ashersky. Clearly reading players and making analysis for whatever it was worth.
-He makes a comment about not having many town reads on D1 and that it is worrisome. While this exactly opposite of my experience (I start everyone as likely scum) I don't think scum wants to do this, they need to start polarizing the group and getting some potential buddies.
-When eevee starts townreading mcmc shortly thereafter schadd wants to lynch him.
-He accurately reads me which many don't do. My playstyle is is purposely designed for scum to misconstrue it so no spidey tingles here.
-Interactions with schadd post D1 hammerpalooza really make me feel like they are NOT partners.
-Very present in D1 twilight. Interactions looks entirely unscripted and very towny as he particiaptes very candidly and without careful wording.
-Did I mention he was on the Joseph wagon, well just about everyone alive today was on that wagon so I'm not seeing that helping anyone's case at all (TWM excepted).
Moving onto D2
-the early reactions surrounding the ashersky flip are somewhat telling. I think Eevee's look town and dandy.
-note here that Robz immediately positions for some lynch pool that contains known town and TWM, mcmc goes for it which is a critical point for D2
-eevee sheeps the Dylan vote with Robz and mcmc
-catches heat for being certain on mcmc, at this point in time I am also certain on mcmc although i haven't tipped my hand yet. the thing about certainty is only scum can afford it.
-Already ready to lynch andrew D2. this was sound thinking and not something scum needs to do at this stage in the game. I don't recall eevee being that kind of scum to setup the early bus to spring it two days later for the critical cred. Gotta read this as a strong town signal for fuzzy. Takes him to L-2. Wonder how the game shakes out in the alternate univers where we did the right thing here?
-Consistently uneasy on Robz and a wavering townread on schadd. this guy is super linear for the game progression so far. Not driving any wagons so if he is scum he is both the sheep and the jester which could be possible if it weren't for the high degree of consistency. The sheep can't be consistent when he is following the leader.
-right around here schadd defends Robz in a very partnery way.
-Dylan goes down in favor of known scum andrew who only me and eevee are left voting. In my opinion this is the crowning moment for eevee. He's town right here. The rest of the people alive today are on the wagoin which is a bitch for us to work out. I will have to reread the whol thing that happened while I was sleep where scum clearly derailed the andrew wagon and convinced some fools to get on dylan.
D3 dum dum dum
-playing like a town superstar, scum read on schadd has reached epic proportions. correctly withholds votes and assigns passes based on claims. no scumminess at all here today.
-to be fair, andrew pretty well hangs himself throughout the day but eevee never lets the guy make an argument in his own favor. if eevee is scum here he is the most machiavellian bus master we have ever seen.
-correctly nails my town meta which always about living long enough to really get the feel and be the lynchpin in the late game. high five eevee, for someone who is confused by most you sure do read me right consistently.
-was voting schadd because his gut but switches to andrew because sound logic from people not me (although I'm definitely running the andrew wagon hard all day) no confirmation bias in my reading of this.
So there we have it. I feel confident Eevee is not the scumz but if he is holy hell that is one impressive performance and MVP to you. Like, really, that's impossible to play like thet you're town so let's move on.
I threw in my notices near the eevee posts of the Robz schadd interactions and reading eevee strengthened my suspicion on both of them