Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LaLight]

I don't know what to think of faust here. Definitely not the obv!scumslip everyone should jump onto though bad. Being town he's like has smth like "you are X" in the pm, and it's hard not to remember that you don't have flavor name regardless the flavor..

Were the votes in your madness post actual reads or just part of the madness?

Partly both. I don't want to vote yet.

[LaLight]

Actually I'd vote RR. He looks like he isn't into speculating on the setup which is bad and his posts are far from usefulness.

Maybe I have one conf!town here, but I need to think and don't really want to share this, cause it's powerful piece of info.

[LaLight]

I have quite strong gut feelings for some reason I don't know yet.

[faust]

So here's what's what:

Everyone who has ever been scum with me - in fact, everyone who has ever read a mafia QT with me in it - knows I always spend N0 analyzing the setup, preparing fakeclaims. In a small game such as this, that would be even more important. There is not a lot of setup information to go around, and you can bet I would have read everything carefully. Meaning that as scum I would be more likely to remember that town does not have flavor names.

The second thing is obviously Eevee had some sort of purpose with his question. Don't you think I'd double-check as scum? Now I know I was mildly drunk and that was why Eevee thought he could slip me up, but does that fit with the scum play that you know from me?

The third thing is ongoing game stuff.

[Roadrunner7671]

Actually I'd vote RR. He looks like he isn't into speculating on the setup which is bad

Speculating would be purely speculating. I have no additional information at this time, and I really have no idea what we might see.

[gkrieg13]

I honestly do t know what to think of this game yet.

I don't think Faust is scummy for not checking g his QT when deciding to not claim when he is drunk

[Eevee]

I honestly do t know what to think of this game yet.

I don't think Faust is scummy for not checking g his QT when deciding to not claim when he is drunk

It's more that he didn't remember from the initial reading that he had no flavor name.

Which is by no means a slam dunk, but I do think it elevates the possibility of him being scum.

As in, at least sometimes townfaust! would have remembered "Hey, I have no flavor name!" when specifically asked for it  (it's an unusual request, especially coming from me), either from an earlier readthrough of the role pm or from checking when I asked.

[faust]

As in, at least sometimes townfaust! would have remembered "Hey, I have no flavor name!" when specifically asked for it  (it's an unusual request, especially coming from me), either from an earlier readthrough of the role pm or from checking when I asked.

I posit that scum!faust would have remembered this in more cases than town!faust.

[gkrieg13]

I honestly do t know what to think of this game yet.

I don't think Faust is scummy for not checking g his QT when deciding to not claim when he is drunk

It's more that he didn't remember from the initial reading that he had no flavor name.

Which is by no means a slam dunk, but I do think it elevates the possibility of him being scum.

As in, at least sometimes townfaust! would have remembered "Hey, I have no flavor name!" when specifically asked for it  (it's an unusual request, especially coming from me), either from an earlier readthrough of the role pm or from checking when I asked.

I guess I'm not sure I would've remembered honestly.

[Eevee]

As in, at least sometimes townfaust! would have remembered "Hey, I have no flavor name!" when specifically asked for it  (it's an unusual request, especially coming from me), either from an earlier readthrough of the role pm or from checking when I asked.

I posit that scum!faust would have remembered this in more cases than town!faust.

That's fair. And I get it, it's just that we have so little to go from, got to try something!

If other people have any opinions on this, or anything, speak your piece. We need something to kickstart solving this puzzle. I know as an IC I should lead, but I really have no idea.

[Axxle]

@faust: can you answer my questions?

[Archetype]

As in, at least sometimes townfaust! would have remembered "Hey, I have no flavor name!" when specifically asked for it  (it's an unusual request, especially coming from me), either from an earlier readthrough of the role pm or from checking when I asked.

I posit that scum!faust would have remembered this in more cases than town!faust.

That's fair. And I get it, it's just that we have so little to go from, got to try something!

If other people have any opinions on this, or anything, speak your piece. We need something to kickstart solving this puzzle. I know as an IC I should lead, but I really have no idea.

I don't think its too unreasonable to think that scum didn't read the setup/read it quickly, saw that they themselves had a flavor name, and thus thought everyone else did too. The way he answered it also made it appear as if he definitely had a flavor name, but just didn't quite understand it - something a scum who was put on the spot that hadn't devised a fake claim yet would do.

[LaLight]

We don't have much time left.

[Archetype]

We don't have much time left.

Oh thats right. This is semi-blitz.

I don't have too good of reads on anybody yet...towny on Axxle and scummy on faust are really the only hunches Ive gotten.

[gkrieg13]

I think we should definitely try to lynch someone today. But I think a no lynch isn't too bad either.

[LaLight]

I think we should definitely try to lynch someone today. But I think a no lynch isn't too bad either.

This.

[Axxle]

I also agree we should either lynch or no lynch 

[LaLight]

I also agree we should either lynch or no lynch 

The point is that we must not think that the lynch is the only possible way.

[faust]

Did not actually look up my PM you know.

Do you at least know your alignment?

Yes.

[faust]

Does this look very bad for faust?

No, why would you even think that? Let me detail you tomorrow when I'm less tired how this is not a scum tell. In the meantime, it will be fun to see who jumps on this.

What does "fun" mean in this context?

Means we get stuff to analyze.

[faust]

@faust: can you answer my questions?

These were the questions, right?

[faust]

I'll Vote: faust.

Can you explain this vote?

[faust]

So reads. These we need.

LaLight is towny. All that weirdness in the beginning? I don't see that from scum!LaLight.
RR seems townish too. That's more of a gut feel I suppose.

WW is not doing anything, which sucks. I would lynch him for lurking since we can't have that in a semi-blitz.

Axxle is so far the nullest of nulls.

Archetype I'm reserving my judgment until I get a response.

Then there's gkrieg. Well we have this:

I didn't realize the whole eevee is kubo thing.

Which is a (possibly fake) townslip, because for sure scum would have paid attention to this, and certainly their roles are crafted in a way that reflects the special position Eevee has in this game. I dunno, gkrieg doesn't strike me as the type to fake townslips. But then his read on LaLight is very off. Scum signaling to their partners? No way, because that would always be more subtle. I don't see how you would get there.

[Witherweaver]

Would you prefer I

Vote: Faust ?

[gkrieg13]

So reads. These we need.

LaLight is towny. All that weirdness in the beginning? I don't see that from scum!LaLight.
RR seems townish too. That's more of a gut feel I suppose.

WW is not doing anything, which sucks. I would lynch him for lurking since we can't have that in a semi-blitz.

Axxle is so far the nullest of nulls.

Archetype I'm reserving my judgment until I get a response.

Then there's gkrieg. Well we have this:

I didn't realize the whole eevee is kubo thing.

Which is a (possibly fake) townslip, because for sure scum would have paid attention to this, and certainly their roles are crafted in a way that reflects the special position Eevee has in this game. I dunno, gkrieg doesn't strike me as the type to fake townslips. But then his read on LaLight is very off. Scum signaling to their partners? No way, because that would always be more subtle. I don't see how you would get there.

Scum is not always subtle by the way. Sometimes being flashy is the easiest way for people to not lynch you. Especially because they potentially just have to get 2lynches through