Thought I try a quick re-read on everyone.
Roadrunner7671 -- townish, though if I were going to vote to lynch based on how much I got his joke funny, then he's definitely scum.
SpaceAnemone -- Spaaaaaaace :-)
gkrieg13 -- mild scum, maybe. I don't like that he was engaging with the length but not content of Ghacob's post. He's been casting suspicion on me already, and he said in Ghibli that I'm too easy a mislynch for him, so that worries me. Also surprisingly confident of JR's innocence.
J Reggie -- Mild town, though he's yet to declare himself IC :-P
silverspawn -- Null through dearth of content.
chairs -- a bit scummy.. generally has a sort of offhand disengaged feel, and I really didn't like his plan to rig the bidding, even though I'd probably have done quite well compared to some other poor towns.
Ghacob -- town for now because my expereince is well-mirrored in the metametadiscussion post.
2.71828 -- mild scum, becuase a lot of his content is quite acti-lurky in nature.
mail-mi -- null, or possibly mild scum for which I'm overcompensating because I recognise there could in theory still be some residual omgus from previously.
Dylan32 -- mild scum, but probably going with a newbie pass.
schadd -- aaargh. Can't help but read him as scummy, but I did that in Ghibli and turned out to be wrong. Wish I understood where his Beatles reference was trying to go.
EFHW -- Almost as quiet as Silver, so still pretty null. I think she's less engaged than she was in D1 of BSG, though.
I feel like I think way too many people are mildly scummy, but I don't want to second-guess myself just now by re-doing it. (Also, laziness).