Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[iguanaiguana]

Poor Joseph is trying to just read a book, and Roadrunner won't leave him alone.

[ced]

unvote

As per faust's logic, because Jimmmm and Seprix were partners and Jimmmm was mafia, Seprix should be IC right?

Are spec chats here spoiler-free as a rule?

I'm kinda with Joseph here.  Why would scum pass up the opportunity to either kill a doctor or kill two townies simultaneously?  Makes it fairly likely to my mind that one of RR and Joseph is scum.  I would guess RR, I think?  But this we can find out.

On play, I'd instinctively say that RR is town and Joseph is scum - RR for reasons I mentioned yesterday, and Joseph because I feel he was scummy to begin with and did end up lurking through the Jimmm lynch. But they did between them basically get the Jimmm lynch going, and Joseph even left his vote on Jimmm right to then end. Is there even a dichotomy here?

But also: gkrieg said some scummy stuff in our QT last night. The main thing is that he asked who I was requesting, which I found odd, but he also said something that I wouldn't exactly call a scumslip but seemed to imply he was speaking from a scum perspective. It's enough to make me want to vote: gkrieg

I did note that gkrieg (in 642), suggests the before-the-fact request claim, but I didn't like the way he framed the suggestion as originally being from me.
What is the other thing he said?

I wrote this amazing long post, but I accidentally closed the window like a complete idiot. I don't want to write all of that stuff again right now, so here's the tl;dr: Basically, I confirmed that Awaclus and Haddock are town, that Silverspawn is likely town, and thus the alternatives are Ced, gkreig and Iguana as scum partners.

I'd like to hear more details on this, if you could. In particular, why did you say you "think you know the next scum" in 807?

[Seprix]

I'd like to hear more details on this, if you could. In particular, why did you say you "think you know the next scum" in 807?

Yes, I guess I'll have to get back to writing that thing all over again.

[A Drowned Kernel]

But also: gkrieg said some scummy stuff in our QT last night. The main thing is that he asked who I was requesting, which I found odd, but he also said something that I wouldn't exactly call a scumslip but seemed to imply he was speaking from a scum perspective. It's enough to make me want to vote: gkrieg

I did note that gkrieg (in 642), suggests the before-the-fact request claim, but I didn't like the way he framed the suggestion as originally being from me.
What is the other thing he said?

The problem is, AFAIK exact quoting is not allowed, and its the specific wording he used that made it seem scummy to me. I said that I didn't see how me telling him who I requested would benefit him as scum but that I didn't want to do it anyway just in case, and he replied that he also didn't see how it would benefit him as scum, except worded in such a way that seemed like a scumslip because it implied that he was in fact scum.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I mean it's not the greatest case and I'm open to other ideas but it was something I thought was worth telling people about.

[Haddock]

I'd also be totally up for a gkrieg lynch. 

The people who I think are lynchable right now, are
gkrieg, Seprix, and Joseph/RR (would have to reread to know which, but my instinct is to think RR is scummier).
I need to reread to see if these change and/or put them in an order. 

Iguana could also be a candidate, maybe.

[gkrieg13]

I still think it would be a good idea to claim who we all requested. 

I don't think the way I said it in the qt constitutesa scum slip at all

[gkrieg13]

I guess it's a theory debate about whether or not it is best to pick your biggest scum read or not

[Joseph2302]

I still think it would be a good idea to claim who we all requested. 

I'm in favour of that.
More information is always a good way to try & catch scum out.

[silverspawn]

vote: gkrieg

[Seprix]

Where is that alleged scumslip again? I'll reread gkrieg soon, he is part of my list of candidates. I'll reread everyone on that list eventually.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Where is that alleged scumslip again? I'll reread gkrieg soon, he is part of my list of candidates. I'll reread everyone on that list eventually.

It is unfortunately in his and my QT from D1 (it happened N1) so it's not available for anyone else to read. My post up there is my attempt to describe it as well as I can without directly quoting.

[A Drowned Kernel]

And I might be ok with after the fact claiming (like, we could do it right now), but asking while the process was still ongoing struck me as odd.

[gkrieg13]

And I might be ok with after the fact claiming (like, we could do it right now), but asking while the process was still ongoing struck me as odd.

Honestly I would've asked earlier, but you weren't very present in our QT.

[Seprix]

I asked for ADK, as he seems the most townie player, just so you all know.

[Roadrunner7671]

I requested Haddock because I thought he'd be fun to talk to.

[Haddock]

I'm fine with claiming who we requested.

I requested Joseph.  I picked someone I thought was towny, for better vote-control.  I'm aware there are arguments to the contrary, but eh.

[ced]

I didn't really know, so I no-requested.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I requested RR because I had a mild scumread on him and thought he would be interesting to talk to.

[gkrieg13]

I requested seprix because I thought he was scummy and would be good to talk to

[Seprix]

I requested seprix because I thought he was scummy and would be good to talk to

lol

[Joseph2302]

I requested Haddock because I thought he'd be fun to talk to.

Wait, you told me you were picking your top scum read.

[Joseph2302]

I'm fine with claiming who we requested.

I requested Joseph.  I picked someone I thought was towny, for better vote-control.  I'm aware there are arguments to the contrary, but eh.

I picked Haddock because I thought he was towny.

[iguanaiguana]

At the very end of the night, EFHW told me, play this game or die. I didn't want to be that guy who gets mod-killed,

so I picked Faust.

Because secretly, I actually like Faust.

Then he got killed at night because of bad meta that I don't understand.

[Awaclus]

I requested faust because I had a scum read on him so it would have been pretty good to become lovers with him, also I didn't want to lose my ability to vote for Seprix who was an even bigger scum read.