and then you used it after that and now it doesn't have a 100% success rate anymore.
RMM31 is my latest finished game.
I don't agree with Awaclus. Just in principle, people don't have to do a million towny things to be town. They just need to not do lots of scummy things.
In particular, this:
they are innocent and that all the evidence suggests that to be the case.
is just false. It is not always the case that all the evidence points to townies being town. Sometimes towny people do stupid things and it makes them look scummy.
It's not about individual things. It's about a consistent narrative throughout the entire game.
Also, the moment you decide to do something stupid as town, you implicitly accept that it's probably going to cause you to lose the game. Therefore, it's good to assume that people don't do anything stupid because that way we can maximize our odds of winning in the cases where any significant odds at all still exist. To put it another way, we need to be able to have faith that town plays well, and town also needs to play well.