I don't intend to hammer Joseph, I still think he's probably town.
I don't agree with Awaclus. Just in principle, people don't have to do a million towny things to be town. They just need to not do lots of scummy things.
In particular, this:
they are innocent and that all the evidence suggests that to be the case.
is just false. It is not always the case that all the evidence points to townies being town. Sometimes towny people do stupid things and it makes them look scummy.
Anyhow, Joseph hasn't done that many outright scummy things. He's done crazy stuff but nothing outright scummy. I really don't think scum ever claims scum.
So yeah, summary, there has to be a better lynch than Joseph today. I like my vote where it is.
Quit being pathetic and take a useful position.
Glad to know it's not just me you like to randomly insult.
(just kidding, worry not)
But I do agree that II's despair was not helpful, glad you got him out of it.
So yeah I think town on PPS for that. Scum would have been happy to encourage the desperation - even if II was his partner.