Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Seprix]

Yes, it very well could be. That would be the perfect way to do some shenanigan voting tricks with PRs, though I also voted Awaclus first, so I don't see how Jan would be affected along with everyone else I would vote for without the game becoming broken as a result. I mean, it is closed set-up, who knows. Doesn't hurt to keep track of that.

The tin-foil-hat part of me is thinking you were going to vote Jan before me (he was on your mind, did you draft a vote for Jan...? Nevermind) - some reachy-associations BS on my part - but at this stage null on it.

I mistook you for Jan. Too many new people with different avatars. Jan has fox, you have Frodo Baggins clone.

Define tone and interpretation?

Tone in the sense of:
- do you think my tone is sincere (am I throwing out questions for the sake of it to appear like a try-hard townie [I believe that is the crux of your scum-read of me]) or do you think I genuinely trying to sort players?
- do you think I am scum-flailing and reacting badly to your 'pressure'/vote?
- do you think any of my reactions and defence of my opinion is scum/null/town-indicative?

No, I don't think your tone is quite sincere, though your explanation is excellent, and what I would except from a good player. I do not think you a reacting badly to my vote at all. You are reacting well enough for me to be satisfied with your original post. You are also possibly British.

Right now, your paranoia of me ended with 'too-bad-to-be-scum' - which I think is a cheap cop out of a scum-read :/

If it is any consolation to you, I don't think you're playing too poorly to be scum anymore. I know, such a great consolation prize to be labeled possible scum instead of poor town player.

Drawing up a scum-team fueled some OMGUS in my veins too.

Hey, a reaction!

[Melisandre]

[I think you have to post somewhere with Dominion. Go make an introductions post or something, I think that would work?]

[Cheers, it worked.]

I mistook you for Jan. Too many new people with different avatars. Jan has fox, you have Frodo Baggins clone.

I can believe this.

No, I don't think your tone is quite sincere

Insincere scum I can buy. But I strongly object to the 'omg-a-readslist-of-every-player-on-page-one-during-RVS?! Try-hard-scum-lord!'. That reaction disturbed me. 

You are also possibly British.

If it is any consolation to you, I don't think you're playing too poorly to be scum anymore. I know, such a great consolation prize to be labeled possible scum instead of poor town player.

Yes, I can see you seeing me as "possible scum" (no problems with that), but you viewing me as "bad scum" was the LAMIST part of my defence/attack on you. I could not comprehend how you could defend the try-hard-scum angle based on the game at that stage. Perhaps maybe a few pages in... I could see town-Seprix being suspicious of someone forcing out unsupported reads.

Hey, a reaction!

I am happy it was just a reaction test, as the timing was scandalous.

[Roadrunner7671]

This is crazy. Seorix, you need to chillllllllllllllll

[A Drowned Kernel]

This is crazy. Seorix, you need to chillllllllllllllll

No, this is good.

[Roadrunner7671]

This is crazy. Seorix, you need to chillllllllllllllll

No, this is good.

Man, is it though?

I'll just go back to lurking. This is a bit ugly to watch.

[J Reggie]

This is crazy. Seorix, you need to chillllllllllllllll

No, this is good.

Yeah, I agree Seprix is looking super townie and moving the game forward. I was probably off with my scum read on you.

[J Reggie]

This is crazy. Seorix, you need to chillllllllllllllll

No, this is good.

Man, is it though?

I'll just go back to lurking. This is a bit ugly to watch.

Wow, I'm here thinking this is really fun. To each their own.

[Melisandre]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

[J Reggie]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

I'm sort of feeling that, but from his meta it seems like a bad idea.

[gkrieg13]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

I'm sort of feeling that, but from his meta it seems like a bad idea.

I agree with this here.  He seems very well within his meta here.

[Roadrunner7671]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

This isn't scum Roadrunner. Scum RR is good at Mafia. Town RR gets lynched D1 and causes everyone to win.

[Roadrunner7671]

Who's fontisian?

[J Reggie]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

This isn't scum Roadrunner. Scum RR is good at Mafia. Town RR gets lynched D1 and causes everyone to win.

As long as you're not a compulsive gladiator.

[Melisandre]

Also I don't think RR is the most likelyto be lynched on day 1. He's guaranteed to get a wagon though. Most likely to be lynched is probably Seprix, maybe Hydrad.

Nah not today, Seprix isn't getting lynched D1. Seprix is scum-reading/voting me now for better reasons

[J Reggie]

So opinion poll:

J Reggie, gkrieg, Teproc:
Mafia, town, neither
Discuss.

[Roadrunner7671]

So opinion poll:

J Reggie, gkrieg, Teproc:
Mafia, town, neither
Discuss.

Town, neutral, town.

[Seprix]

I forgot to unvote. Melis is playing well enough to keep alive for a day at least.

[Melisandre]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

I'm sort of feeling that, but from his meta it seems like a bad idea.

I agree with this here.  He seems very well within his meta here.

Ok, gkrieg13 and J Reggie didn't like my vote on Roadrunner7671 - could you two guys please point me to some Roadrunner7671 town/scum-meta. Atm, looking at the last few pages, I don't know what Roadrunner7671 is doing It feels like he is floating about.

[Roadrunner7671]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

I'm sort of feeling that, but from his meta it seems like a bad idea.

I agree with this here.  He seems very well within his meta here.

Ok, gkrieg13 and J Reggie didn't like my vote on Roadrunner7671 - could you two guys please point me to some Roadrunner7671 town/scum-meta. Atm, looking at the last few pages, I don't know what Roadrunner7671 is doing It feels like he is floating about.

Someone told me to make a list! It's finally come in handy:
Forum Mafia Metas
Too many generalizations
Misses the point
Short posts
Weird
Votes independently
Voices opinions
Claims to be the worst player ever
Helpful in the thick of things

[A Drowned Kernel]

I don't know what Roadrunner7671 is doing It feels like he is floating about.

Honestly, that pretty much sums up his meta. I'm too lazy to pull it up but there was a game where he argued quiet strongly against lynching because he thought the flavor suggested that there wasn't scum.

[Roadrunner7671]

And I'm floating around because 14 13 of us are still in RVS.

[A Drowned Kernel]

So opinion poll:

J Reggie, gkrieg, Teproc:
Mafia, town, neither
Discuss.

Why's gkrieg on the list? null, null, scum.

[Roadrunner7671]

I don't know what Roadrunner7671 is doing It feels like he is floating about.

Honestly, that pretty much sums up his meta. I'm too lazy to pull it up but there was a game where he argued quiet strongly against lynching because he thought the flavor suggested that there wasn't scum.

That game was different. It was on the fine line between bastard and RMM, and flavor mattered.

[J Reggie]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

I'm sort of feeling that, but from his meta it seems like a bad idea.

I agree with this here.  He seems very well within his meta here.

Ok, gkrieg13 and J Reggie didn't like my vote on Roadrunner7671 - could you two guys please point me to some Roadrunner7671 town/scum-meta. Atm, looking at the last few pages, I don't know what Roadrunner7671 is doing It feels like he is floating about.

That's exactly what he's like as town. As mafia he's a lot more confident; as town he's self-doubting and paranoid. That often reads scummy and people need to learn that for him it's not.

[Roadrunner7671]

Vote: Roadrunner7671

I'm sort of feeling that, but from his meta it seems like a bad idea.

I agree with this here.  He seems very well within his meta here.

Ok, gkrieg13 and J Reggie didn't like my vote on Roadrunner7671 - could you two guys please point me to some Roadrunner7671 town/scum-meta. Atm, looking at the last few pages, I don't know what Roadrunner7671 is doing It feels like he is floating about.

That's exactly what he's like as town. As mafia he's a lot more confident; as town he's self-doubting and paranoid. That often reads scummy and people need to learn that for him it's not.

Have you been stalking me?

That's not true though! EFHW is really good at seeing through that. But you don't have to worry about what I'm like as Mafia this game