Okay, so first the points against me, as far as I can see them:
-Some people are saying they find me scummy for initially arguing in favor of Split Up. I don't think this makes sense- we were given options, and I felt there was an argument in favor of choosing one over the other. CtP has a big downside- people not being able to post and vote loses us a lot of important Day One interactions. I'm not upset that we eventually chose it, but I don't see how wanting to consider the alternative makes me scummy.
-I asked people to stop talking about theory so much and expressed concern over the time we had left. My tone here wasn't the best, but it came from a place of genuine frustration. This game has been a lot of talk and speculation about the setup, which is fine when you have something useful to say or information to give, but I felt like people were talking in a lot of circles and repeating things that had already been said. And when people are doing that, it looks like they're posting just to appear active.
-I've been lurking. This is on me, but it's frustrating to be town and to be pretty much the leading wagon. It demotivates me to play the game, which I'm trying to fight right now.
I'm going to do a reread and sort out my reads:
Witherweaver- Way lurkier than I expect from WW. I'd vote here.
yuma- Seems like town to me, but his claim seems problematic. I don't like the idea of wasting a lynch making sure he lives. It's possible that someone has a role that can save him? I don't want to lynch here today.
2.7- Mostly null here. His reaction to me voting for him was a little eh in my opinion. Doesn't seem like he's interested in pushing any sort of wagon or lynch. I'd almost say he's acti-lurking.
gkrieg13-
This post seems very towny. Not going to put my vote here today.
faust- His claim pretty much means he's off the table for today.
EFHW- Lots and lots of theory posts before she does anything with reads, but eventually she does. I like her vote on chairs, that's a good vote. Null.
Roadrunner7671- Pretty typical RR. Isn't currently voting, I'd like to see him put a vote down and commit to a read or two. Null.
Haddock- His big reread post is towny, though the only game I've played with him I was his scum partner and I can see him being able to make that post as scum. Not going to lynch him today but he's on my radar.
silverspawn- Is very active right off the bat, is engaging in discussion and responding to people in the early game, town read so far.
Hydrad- His vote on me looks super sheepy. Call it OMGUS but it gives me a scum read on him.
Limetime- Pretty much gone. I'd lurker lynch here but there's probably something better.
Ampharos- Lots of very short posts, mostly theory talk, not a lot of content. Null leaning scum.
chairs- scum read here. It's part gut but he also did vote for RR for suggesting Split Up, and I still maintain that that's not scummy.
SirMartin- Super lurky. The only read that he's given so far has been on chairs for not posting in the patrol QT. I don't really know how to read him, so null for now.
That's what I've got. I'm okay with
vote: chairs right now.
PPE: I mean, faust is a town leader in general, but he's capable of filling that role as scum. I mainly don't want to vote for him because of his claim.
Author
Topic: RMM32: The Walking Dead (Game Over.) (Read 158712 times)