Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Lekkit]

So.

I ended up not filling my QT with reread posts. I'll hopefully have some time to continue with that tomorrow.

[Witherweaver]

Or do we not want to counterclaim, as that gives scum more info?

Unvote

We absolutely want the counterclaim if there is one. No PR is as good as catching scum.

No, I mean would we rather counterclaim or lynch Hydrad without a counterclaim?

This is highly suspicious.

[Witherweaver]

But sure, let's do Faust's thing.

Vote: Silverspawn

[faust]

Or do we not want to counterclaim, as that gives scum more info?

Unvote

We absolutely want the counterclaim if there is one. No PR is as good as catching scum.

No, I mean would we rather counterclaim or lynch Hydrad without a counterclaim?

This is highly suspicious.

It is certainly weird, and I would think it suspicious had Hydrad flipped town. But as it is, I don't see why scum posts that.

[Witherweaver]

Or do we not want to counterclaim, as that gives scum more info?

Unvote

We absolutely want the counterclaim if there is one. No PR is as good as catching scum.

No, I mean would we rather counterclaim or lynch Hydrad without a counterclaim?

This is highly suspicious.

It is certainly weird, and I would think it suspicious had Hydrad flipped town. But as it is, I don't see why scum posts that.

I don't see why town posts that.  It sounds like he knows there is a counterclaim.

[Ampharos]

I'm with WW on this one.

[Lekkit]

I think it's possible for scum to say that. It's certainly not very good, though. But imagine this: You know Hydrad is lying. You know he'll get lynched after a counterclaim that you know will end up happening. You try to get town points from trying to make the PR stay hidden.

PPE: Yeah...

[Lekkit]

Actually. Vote: Roadrunner7671

[Witherweaver]

I think it's possible for scum to say that. It's certainly not very good, though. But imagine this: You know Hydrad is lying. You know he'll get lynched after a counterclaim that you know will end up happening. You try to get town points from trying to make the PR stay hidden.

PPE: Yeah...

Yeah, this was my thought.

[Awaclus]

The Roadrunner point is a very good one. Vote: RR

[silverspawn]

yay I'm alive

now vote: faust

this is completely and uttrerly ridiculous and I refuse to believe that it comes from town!faust.

I was advocating a hydrad lynch THE ENTIRE DAY. The only reason I was not voting for him is because I liked the RR lynch a bit more. I would have lynched him without hesitation had you not done it before I came back.

Now, while I was pursuing the lynch of SCUM the entire time, FAUST was pursuing a MISYLNCH the entire time - me.

It is absolutely out of character for faust to ignore all that and simply call my positino bad because I wasn't on the final wagon. town!faust doesn't do that.

[silverspawn]

what kind of game is this were a person who was pursuing a mislynch is telling town that a person who was advocating one of the two scum lynches is looking bad? ridiculous.

[silverspawn]

Hydrad
Uh Hydrad. Dunno. Not townie the way he is sometimes. But he can also be town and not be like that. He's voting for Awaclus I see. Meh. Could lynch.

[Witherweaver]

Wait I thought you weren't pushing Hydrad.

[silverspawn]

yeah, Hydrad or RR are the to-go lynches today. e is towny for this case.

Vote: silverspawn

Oh, I'm doing that already? Dang.

[Witherweaver]

I'll have to reread.

[silverspawn]

well, Hydrad is good. Even though the lack of motivation for an RR lynch makes me want to do him more

still vote: Hydrad

I think Hydrad is like hillary here. Not great, but popular, and probably the second best option.

[silverspawn]

upon rereading a bit I'll admit that I didn't push Hydrad consistently, but that was only because I was pushing RR over him. At no point did I suggest that I preferred anyone other than RR over Hydrad. And then not pushing him - what kind of partner play is that?

[Roadrunner7671]

Let's not lynch RR today.

[2.71828.....]

Some of faust's posts mid-early about hydrad yesterday does have me agreeing with silverspawn some.

But.....

I would be very suspicious of faust had he unvoted and been off wagon before the fake claim. As it is, sticking to hydrad is pretty strong town!faust evidence. Votes don't lie, and I am probably going to look much more off-wagon today (pre fake claim) than on wagon

[Roadrunner7671]

I think I come off as towny because of the Hydrad thing, honestly.

Lekkit and SS and Awaclus just have it out for me.

[Lekkit]

I think I come off as towny because of the Hydrad thing, honestly.

Lekkit and SS and Awaclus just have it out for me.

Wow. A read. Oh, wait, you had a read on yourself...

[faust]

yay I'm alive

now vote: faust

this is completely and uttrerly ridiculous and I refuse to believe that it comes from town!faust.

I was advocating a hydrad lynch THE ENTIRE DAY. The only reason I was not voting for him is because I liked the RR lynch a bit more. I would have lynched him without hesitation had you not done it before I came back.

Now, while I was pursuing the lynch of SCUM the entire time, FAUST was pursuing a MISYLNCH the entire time - me.

It is absolutely out of character for faust to ignore all that and simply call my positino bad because I wasn't on the final wagon. town!faust doesn't do that.

Haha. You were not pushing a Hydrad lynch. You were hedging on Hydrad while pushing an RR lynch. If you look for a player who pushed Hydrad hard, that would be e.

[faust]

Here is silverspawn's vote history:

1 Feb Awaclus
2 Feb ADK
2 Feb Hydrad

These were all mostly RVS.

2 Feb RR
3 Feb Hydrad
4 Feb yuma
4 Feb RR
5 Feb gkrieg
5 Feb RR
7 Feb Hydrad
8 Feb RR
9 Feb day ends

This is not "pushing Hydrad all day".

[chairs]

Was anybody defensive of Hydrad early?