Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

Does anyone think Faust is scummy?

[A Drowned Kernel]

Silverspawn being super tunnel-y and stubborn doesn't look too much like scum!SS to me. Silverspawn, if you're town, just switch to Hydrad, it's a good lynch.

What does scum!silver look like?

I'll admit that I'm not very up on people's metas, but I don't imagine scum!silver would be pushing this hard on a lynch, he'd be more opportunistic (unless the other major wagon was his partner). This is more of a generic read on him I guess but I'm not super hot on meta-based reads anyway. The way people say things is going to be pretty consistent between scum and town, it's who and how and when they vote that's the real info. silverspawn is being himself personality-wise, whatever. He's also pushing a wagon super hard, against various resistances, attracting (and responding to) negative attention, and not switching to a more convenient and more popular wagon. I think a Hydrad lynch would be very informative at this point, regardless of whether or not silver is on it.

PPE: I would like to reiterate that I am against making reads on QTs. If scum!RR is 100% likely to have a fake QT ready scum!SS is like 110% likely.

PPE 2: Not particularly.

[silverspawn]

Take care not to be "horrifically anti town"...

once again we have a matter of reading something into something that's not there.

You asked me if I like to share my QT. I don't like to, it's honestly a bit shameful. It's not as if I asked RR if he liked to share his QT and he said no and I called him anti town.

I said I will share it if it's necessary (which includes if people request it) so where is the problem? no-one requested it.

you're implying that there is a double standard, when that's absolutely not the case.

[silverspawn]

I'm no longer sharing my QT.

Please note that you called me discriminating for implying that RR changes his mind a lot

[Haddock]

Vote Count 1.8

All you need is love.  But a little chocolate now and then doesn't hurt.

2.7 (1): EgorK
Awaclus (1): Ampharos
Ampharos (1): Lekkit.
RR (3): WW, SS, Awaclus
Hydrad (2): ADK, 2.7
silverspawn (4): chairs, gkrieg, faust, RR.
WW (1): Hydrad

Not Voting (0):

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 will end on Tuesday, February 9, at 1 pm forum time.

That's in ~24 hours - note Voting Rule 6.

[Roadrunner7671]

Oh, yes. Someone's getting lynched today probably.

[faust]

Take care not to be "horrifically anti town"...

once again we have a matter of reading something into something that's not there.

You asked me if I like to share my QT. I don't like to, it's honestly a bit shameful. It's not as if I asked RR if he liked to share his QT and he said no and I called him anti town.

I said I will share it if it's necessary (which includes if people request it) so where is the problem? no-one requested it.

you're implying that there is a double standard, when that's absolutely not the case.

 

I request that you share your QT.

[faust]

I'm no longer sharing my QT.

Please note that you called me discriminating for implying that RR changes his mind a lot

No, I called you discriminating for implying that all 13-year olds change their mind a lot.

[silverspawn]

No, I called you discriminating for implying that all 13-year olds change their mind a lot.

okay, true.

yeah, I think most of them do. I certainly did. I don't think that's discriminating, but whatever.

[2.71828.....]

So are most people voting silverspawn because he is being mildly irritating right now or because they think he is scum?  I still like my Hydrad case.  Plenty of time to go.  Will obviously switch for a lynch though

[faust]

So are most people voting silverspawn because he is being mildly irritating right now or because they think he is scum?  I still like my Hydrad case.  Plenty of time to go.  Will obviously switch for a lynch though

What kind of answer do you expect to get here?

[Awaclus]

So are most people voting silverspawn because he is being mildly irritating right now or because they think he is scum?

No, most people are not voting silverspawn. 

[faust]

So are most people voting silverspawn because he is being mildly irritating right now or because they think he is scum?

No, most people are not voting silverspawn. 

Would be pretty hard to get 3.5 billion people to vote silverspawn.

[Roadrunner7671]

So are most people voting silverspawn because he is being mildly irritating right now or because they think he is scum?

No, most people are not voting silverspawn. 

Would be pretty hard to get 3.5 billion people to vote silverspawn.

I'm itching to vote faust now, this really seems blatantly unhelpful and not faust-like.

[silverspawn]

I request that you share your QT.

*sad sigh*... fine

I see fit

But what if I don't have any thoughts?

Post 4: well, here we already see how stupid this rule is. I made a joke that quotes a part of my role PM. if I explained what that joke was, that would probably make me an IC immediately, but that would most likely be violating the rules... although why would it? It isn't communication with the mod. Taking the rules literally, it should be allowed. ehhhh.

okay let's get serious (us = the QT & me). time to read the setup.

Matrix setup. I see. well, let's see what I need to know.

It can be multibball and it can have SK. I don't like either of those things. Meh.

Okay that's enough, I have stuff to do. Bye QT ♥

Post 8: here I am confirming my role, that's certainly illegal to quote

Uh. Look.

There is a reason why I disallowed this in my games.

And it puts me in an odd spot. On the one hand, I know that this is an enormous advantage for town which you probably underestimate greatly. On the other hand, the knowledge that everything I write into this QT will eventually be relevant for determining my alignment and will be judged is, well, dumb. It should theoretically make me post more, since the most I post, the harder would it be for hypothetical!scum!me to replicate all that, but then again, hypothetical!scum!me would probably right now start a separate QT for replicating that exact process, and now I am thinking about how, if this gets quoted sometime at the end of the game, people are going to think about whether or not this is ALREADY that fake QT and everyone will have to have 2 QTs if he wants to play this properly and can't you see how much this shifts the game into a direction that has nothing to do with mafia?

Please rethink that rule decision. If nothing else, it will make your game unbalanced. This is a huge deal.

Post 10/11: probably disallowed

QTQTQTTQTTQTEREdingdingdingding

I'm currently debating whether or not I should make a joke about involving the QT into this discussion when it had nothing to do with it

well now that I said that I can't make it anymore.

post 15 is Haddock's response. Should not be legal
post 16 is my response to haddock's response. Also not legal.

well then. now that the issue is settled, what are my thoughts about the game? ... I don't have any. er... yeah, I don't.

Oh, but now stuff is happening. "can I counterclaim?" that's a cute question. I'm pretty sure he does have a PR.

Okay, he thought it was a joke. I see. Meh. Nothing exciting, then. Except now ADK is an IC.

NOOOO FAUST IS VOTING FOR ME!!!

:c

So much for not thinking and everything works out by itself

this response has to be a beacon of towniness.

I think I dislike the QT thing even more than initially. I like to let my silly side dictate my personality when being in QT's but still the constant thought of this actually having any sort of purpose seems to ruin the point :/

Let's not quote the rest.

god I hate this rule more with every passing day.

[Ampharos]

M75: Cupcake Mafia Discussion of Quick Topics

[Witherweaver]

Well if anything this makes me more okay with lynching Silverspawn. 

[Awaclus]

For the record, that was 16 minutes and 22 seconds while he was online the whole time.

[silverspawn]

For the record, that was 16 minutes and 22 seconds while he was online the whole time.

yea, it's even worse than just being unbalanced and inherently causing rule edge cases, it's also a pain to copy all quotes over and make sure the numbering is accurate.

[silverspawn]

not to mention that it takes all the fun out of using QTs

[Awaclus]

it's also a pain to change all quotes over and make sure the numbering is accurate.

[gkrieg13]

unvote

[gkrieg13]

vote: Hydrad

[silverspawn]

it's also a pain to change all quotes over and make sure the numbering is accurate.

I'm not sure what you're saying. If you think that I wrote this in 15 minutes (which is insane, but not required because like ADK said, scum!me would have prepared something), then why aren't you voting for me?

[chairs]

vote: Hydrad.