This is my current reads list. Some are gut reads, some are reads from stuff in the game. Most of this is just off the top of my head and from moments that I remember in the game. This is my first one that I've ever done so here goes:
EFHW: Seems town to me. The only incriminating thing that I can remember is that she switched off the e wagon to lynch XP, but I believe that she had a good reason to switch and that she didn't want 3rd parties around later in the game so I don't find this very incriminating.
hockeysemlan:slightly towny. I don't have anything to go off of for this one. Just my gut.
silverspawn: slightly towny. This is mainly just a gut read. (thanks for answering many of my questions!)
UmbrageOfSnow: slightly scummy. There is the whole argument with Faust on page 12. I don't want this to take up the entire conversation today because I think there are other people that need to talk other than TA and UoS. He was also on Faust's original want to lynch list with e. (548)
2.7: null. Partly because of faust's reads on him, which I understand can be framing. One reason I don't think he is scum is that scum would not have wanted it to come down to a coin flip and with how the end of the day panned out, I feel like the two candidates were town, or else all of the scum team was on XP. (This read might be from inexperience). So basically I'm confused on him.
Seprix: null. I believe that he overreacted on day 1 when his wagon became the plurality wagon, but he has seemed townier to me since. I think this could go either way, but would be fine if we lynched him as well. This might also be personal reasons just because he was the first one to vote for me
chairs: town, I believe his town slip was genuine, especially after seeing XP's role say survivor-aligned. Maybe not the most solid thing, but I have a general town read on him.
WW: scummy. The timing of jumping on the XP train seems scummy to me. Weird coordination of votes.
IG: slightly scummy. Has been super lurky and seems to just sheep people. That might just be because he is busy though. He also switches his vote from Seprix to WW and then unvotes. This looks to me like it was just a clever way to get off of the Seprix wagon and wait for another big wagon to appear that wasn't scum.
Ghacob: null. The timing of his jumping on the XP wagon seems scummy to me, I think he had already voted XP earlier in the day so this makes sense.
Hydrad: slightly scummy. Nothing really sticks out except that he hammered XP.
EgorK: null. Says that the Seprix wagon is moving too smoothly for his liking (557). Has been lurky, but I understand that this is a sickness problem IRL so I'll not count the lurkiness. get well soon!
TA:null. I originally gave him town cred for the long post analyzing the game, but the towniness has now washed away with all of the arguments. Seems very defensive. He gains it back a little bit because he wants everyone to focus on some of the lurkers instead of just him and UoS. Which I agree we need to do. He also makes a list of lynches in 489 where he says he won't lynch XP or Faust.
mail-mi:null. Has been V/LA but we definitely need to hear more from him before we make any decisions. I don't feel like he has contributed much to the game.
After doing all of this
vote: WW
Author
Topic: RMM26: Mistborn Mafia (Game Over!) (Read 222990 times)