So, reads:
e: I think he's town. Decent (though incorrect) case against me Day 1, which was like the first real thing that happened to get off of theory talk. Good case against Ichi (sorry Ichi, even if you are town, e made good points) today. Looks like real scumhunting to me.
ADK: I waver back and forth.. was my top scum read Day 1 after Hydrad. It lessened a bit towards the end of Day 1... I still think scum. I get the same gut feeling when I reread, and he was off the Hydrad lynch. He's generally a little more present scumhunting.. here he's kind of just sat on my convenient wagon. He did say something about feeling disengaged, and that did happen I think last game I played with him, where I thought he was scum but ended up town.
Ashersky: I'm pretty in the middle here. He's showing a lot of town!Ash traits.. like a lot. Those can be faked, but I'm not sure they are here. Honestly it feels like it's town!Ash trying to emulate town!Ash, if that makes sense. He seems to be only responding to disjoint pieces of the game. For instance, he (as far as I recall) never weighed in on Ichi's strange piecemeal claim, which I would have expected him to jump on. (Especially after that previous game where Ichi fake claimed.. Sure Ash knew for certain Ichi was wrong there, but he did make a big deal about analyzing the claim, and I think in other games he's been big on arguing if a claim is real or not.)
Awaclus: Wow.. I don't remember much from him. Someone reported strong town vibes. Actually I think being sort of background is more of a town trait for him than a scum trait, so there's that. But I may have it the other way around. He was nice enough to explain it to us one game, but I've forgotten.
Faust: I'm, like, 95% sure he's town. Reminds me of town!Faust in Dice Mafia.
Joseph: I'm wavering a bit there. I like the scenario Ash paints, and it makes perfect sense. On the other hand, I'm reminded of PPS in Dice Mafia, where everything about how he claimed and what his role did was wrong, but he was town. Joseph's actions outside of the role thing have not really been scummy. And I really really don't like him choosing XP last night, and especially the reason for choosing XP (afraid of his role's scum utility?) I don't know.. will support the lynch, but not my top choice.
Silverspawn: I've gotten no scum vibe.. I've gotten a few townie vibes.
Chairs: I've gotten zero vibes. I don't like when he voted me.
Ichimaru: Most likely scum. In addition to the trying-to-look-really-townie Day 1, the thing that pushes me is the cut-and-paste reaction to people's reads on him. It just doesn't feel genuine. Well, okay, I think I've felt this way before, and I think I was wrong there. So, grain of salt, but I still think he's scum.
Top choices are ADK, Ichimaru.. less so Joseph.
Would not lynch e, Faust, and Silver and Ash are close to this area.
Others (Chairs, Awaclus) are open game.
I feel like there's a decent chance that someone coming out in my defense is scum. For white knighting purposes. I don't remember who they were. Oh, another point against Joseph: I don't think he's really come out and taken any stances today on anything. I recall a lot of neutral comments about anything that didn't concern his role.
PPE: Not that Chairs vote for me. I thought he already did earlier.
Author
Topic: RMM23: Deus Ex Machina (Town Wins!) (Read 192591 times)