Let's actually break it down.
Eevee, ashersky, faust, witherweaver, Jimmmmm
Jimmmmm is confirmed town.
For him, it's a 50% chance of hitting a scum player. For the rest of us, 66.6666666% chance.
Only possible scum: {Eevee, ashersky, faust, witherweaver}
For me, only possible scum: {Eevee, faust, witherweaver}
I have a strong town read on WW (so does everyone else, which is scary, and of course an SK can be a town read since they're kind of like a town vig that turns on us), which leaves Eevee and Faust.
I strongly believed Eevee was mafia since the end of D2, given Eevee's role in the Hydrad/Jimmmmm day end.
Faust comes out looking very bad considering the end of D3 and his vehement defense of Ichimaru.
I see arguments for both.
Eevee looks slightly townier after last night, because I do think Silver would have jailed him given his reads. However, we don't know if the strongman came into play or the roleblock came into play. There's the small chance Silver jailed me again, I guess, given the missing kill on N1 theory. I don't see him jailing WW or faust and it wouldn't work on Jimmmmm.
Still, just looking at the players who can be scum and I'm looking at Eevee/faust.
The other non-Jimmmmms can do the same thing.