Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[liopoil]

I'm getting worried that eevee is scum and I'm horribly wrong.

This is a thing that could be a thing but is a thing for tomorrow if needed, in my view.

Fair, but joth said that yesterday about XP, sort of.

When?

last post of the day

[liopoil]

Why is robz a good lynch? because he's lurking? if so, that's lame.

That was version 1.0 of the case. I'm now on version 2.1c, which includes fake defeatist attitude, lack of a defense, and appeal to "but that's not how I'd play as scum."

he does have a defeatist attitude, lack of defense, and appeal to "but that's not how I'd play as scum". As far as I know, that's what he does as town, not scum. What makes you think it is fake? I think it could be fake too, but I really can't tell.

Because the timing of everything, along with D1, is just too damn perfect this time. It's different, and I can't explain it better than that.

Well you're going to have to explain it better than that to get my vote, sorry.

[liopoil]

Eevee I have less time for mafia now than I used to. I suspect that plays a large part in all the creeping "hmmm Volt" posts I'm seeing.

joth is a bad lynch. Robz is a good lynch!

That's fine. But you must understand  you'll be suspect to PoE unless you convince others you are town. No one is seeming scummy, I have to turn to look at the people I have a townier read for generally making sense and agreeing with me, because scum has to be somewhere.

I don't get this... Voltaire is plenty towny. Plenty of other people are seeming scummy.

[liopoil]

Deadline is in 28 hours. Robz and Hydrad, move your vote somewhere?

[Eevee]

Yeah, I just made like 20 catch up posts. Respond people!

[Eevee]

I'll be MIA for the next 16 hours, but back until the deadline after that.

[Witherweaver]

The scummiest thing about Eevee here is that he's actually involved in this game.  Never seen town Eevee involved in scum hunting~

[liopoil]

The scummiest thing about Eevee here is that he's actually involved in this game.  Never seen town Eevee involved in scum hunting~

somewhat fair, but I don't really want to discourage contributing...

[Eevee]

The scummiest thing about Eevee here is that he's actually involved in this game.  Never seen town Eevee involved in scum hunting~

My last game,newbie mafia. Or like half of my other games.

[Witherweaver]

The scummiest thing about Eevee here is that he's actually involved in this game.  Never seen town Eevee involved in scum hunting~

My last game,newbie mafia. Or like half of my other games.

I thought you were scum in your last game?

[Eevee]

The scummiest thing about Eevee here is that he's actually involved in this game.  Never seen town Eevee involved in scum hunting~

My last game,newbie mafia. Or like half of my other games.

I thought you were scum in your last game?

Nah. Haven't been scum in ages.

[Hydrad]

Ah I'm here. Sorry I haven't been posting. I'm going to quickly look over to see who to vote

[liopoil]

Ah I'm here. Sorry I haven't been posting. I'm going to quickly look over to see who to vote

Does that mean you're scum?

[Hydrad]

Ah I'm here. Sorry I haven't been posting. I'm going to quickly look over to see who to vote

Does that mean you're scum?

No. Why would it mean I'm scum?

[liopoil]

Ah I'm here. Sorry I haven't been posting. I'm going to quickly look over to see who to vote

Does that mean you're scum?

No. Why would it mean I'm scum?

because you are here and not posting

[Hydrad]

Ah I'm here. Sorry I haven't been posting. I'm going to quickly look over to see who to vote

Does that mean you're scum?

No. Why would it mean I'm scum?

because you are here and not posting

Ah. I actually just woke up 30 minutes ago. Just so happened to be right when I got mentioned.

[Hydrad]

Hmm I think xp is the most likely scum here but want to keep him alive for one more day incase he is the doctor. I think a joth lynch is is good here as if he flips scum that makes me feel better about xp.

Robz I don't really get a scummy feel from. I would say I'm null on robz

[Hydrad]

Vote: joth

[jotheonah]

Well, I am still not entirely sold on XP as scum, but if it's between him and me, vote: XP

Hydrad, FWIW, he's not doing us much good as a doctor even if he is one now. He's too susceptible to roleblocking or just being the nightkill.

I still don't really understand the case against me here. Everyone just seems to be saying "I re-read joth and he seems scummy. Vote." But I don't think my behavior has been scummy at all. In a town full of lurkers I've been breaking my back trying to scumhunt. In fact for most of this game I've been trying harder than I ever try to make cases and really catch scum. Maybe that's why people think I'm playing differently than normal? It's certainly frustrating to see people who have made no real contributions getting town passes for being generally agreeable, while I get vague suspicion from every corner for putting myself out there and pushing reads and cases.

It would help me a lot if someone could actually lay out the so-called case on me.

[Eevee]

Guys! Deadline is looming.

It seems to be between joth and XP, or what do you guys think?

[XerxesPraelor]

Once again scum maneuvers the lynch so that the only viable options are mislynches. This is not good. Can we please lynch Eevee?

[KingZog3]

Once again scum maneuvers the lynch so that the only viable options are mislynches. This is not good. Can we please lynch Eevee?

Then vote Eevee, but as far as I can tell you're still voting Robz.

[Eevee]

I could be swayed, but it'll take a case.

[Eevee]

Not go for Eevee of course, but to go for someone else, surely.

[silverspawn]

I'm back. and plenty of time left before the deadline.

so, my feeling from a simple read of everything that has happened since my last post is, joth is extremely scummy. the case on eevee was terrible. hammering TA without giving us time to discuss his claim didn't jump out to me at that time, but it seems weird in retrospect.

also, voting for XP seems weird. Of course, if he's town, anyone is a better lynch than him, but it seems too early.

that's only after one read though. I think I'll make a collection of all his posts later today, like I did with hydrad, and then decide based on that