Vote: Jotheonah
I really think XP is town who really messed up his night action, than scum who came up with a scummy explanation for his night action fail.
This sentence doesn't really make sense. Why the 180 from your stance at the start of the day?
I did 180, yeah. I mean my initial analysis was fueled by anger that he had done--in my opinion--the manifestly wrong thing. But that really is a town tell. Think of mail-mi missing his RB on Night 2 and then RBing me, a virtual IC, in whatever game that was (Adventure Time, I think). When I thought it through, I knew it was towny, because it was so wrong and so scummy. I think is the case here.
I think of Morgrim in Chocolate Factory on Day 1, too. Basically, whenever I don't believe someone because what they did was so wrong, I later find out they were truthful. Neat explanations are scummy. Baffling, forgetful decisions are townie.
Or he's very cleverly putting one over on me, sure. No, I do think he is town, though.
Joth has a much better chance of being scum, I say.