Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[jotheonah]

That's a good point, but you can use some version of that against literally any case against scum. When I'm hunting for scum, I'm looking for quick, visceral reactions that don't make sense coming from town but make sense coming from scared scum. And reacting to a barely prompted IC claim with "OMG scum ploy" fits that bill for me.

[Voltaire]

I guess the reason nobody realized mine was a joke right away is that Masons actually can be in this setup.  I wasn't aware of that at the time.

I am inclined to believe this and get a town read on WW as a result. I don't think I've been bitten in the butt yet by scum!town!slips*

*I probably have

[Voltaire]

well at least this game is starting up now. One thing I'm thinking. if SK and sudgy are masons does that make eevee scum for pointing it out to see if hes right? If hes town would he try and keep quiet if he thought they were masons?

No, definitely not for sure. I mean yes he could have tried that, but it usually never works like that (ie we get close to lynching one of them anyway, Eevee goes "geez guys they're masons!", they claim masons, and we all turn on Eevee for not pointing it out sooner. It happens)

[Voltaire]

Whoops, I missed a lot more thread than I thought!

[Voltaire]

Hydrad, I don't get it. In your hypothesis, I would already know who to kill, I caught the slip. It's better that everyone knows, if scum is going to know anyways, no?

It's not just a hunch. I mean, they haven't said anything, and literally everyone here is convinced anyways.

Hmm i guess your just more confident then me. Personally I'm still not 100% sure that they are masons. Is there also a chance that SK and sudgy are a scum team and  made a big mistake? Anyways if I was scum I wouldn't of assumed they were masons and still am not fully convinced. It would probably take me a claim or some more information for me to be 100% sure if they are who I should kill. So I guess thats why I sort of see it as scummy from you just because I'm not as sure if they are masons as you seem to be.

Hydrad seems to be fighting realllllllllllllllly hard against the creation of two ICs here.

[Voltaire]

i think we shouldn't ignore the possibility that they are a scum team who carefully planed the mason slip. of course, if we were to lynch any one of them, we would probably lynch the other one too, so it's very risky, but even still.

Paranoia is good but just no.

[Voltaire]

sounds like someone's getting a little hot under the collar at the prospect of two ICs.

But that's Hydrad, not Silver.

[Voltaire]

Um.. you anticipated having Masons?  That's not really the most likely scenario.

it's not?

Depends.  How much information did you have coming into today?

NO

[Witherweaver]

Um.. you anticipated having Masons?  That's not really the most likely scenario.

it's not?

Depends.  How much information did you have coming into today?

NO

This was me 'subtly' saying "hey, if you're scum and know how many PRs town have, you might think getting Masons was more likely".

[Witherweaver]

sounds like someone's getting a little hot under the collar at the prospect of two ICs.

But that's Hydrad, not Silver.

This was my first reaction, too.

[Voltaire]

OK, caught up.

Town read on Eevee for how everything went down. Also, I honestly did not catch that SK's posts were a Mason slip (it looks like chairs didn't as well). But everything worked out fine.

joth, why Silver as the scummy player and not Hydrad?

[Witherweaver]

I mean the thing with Hydrad is that the phrase "If I was scum..." is said much more often by Scum than by Town.  E.g., my first scum game (WoT).

[Voltaire]

I mean the thing with Hydrad is that the phrase "If I was scum..." is said much more often by Scum than by Town.  E.g., my first scum game (WoT).

Has Hydrad been scum before though?

[silverspawn]

I don't get why you are fighting against the fact that they could be a scum team. your reaction is proof that it might be a good move.

[Voltaire]

I don't get why you are fighting against the fact that they could be a scum team. your reaction is proof that it might be a good move.

Might? Sure. Likely? Hell no. I won't be considering it today, probably not tomorrow, I know that much for sure.

[SK]

I think it is just too easy for one of us to get killed. A smart scum team would leave us alive to blame us, yes? So yeah, kill one of us if you want proof. Preferably me, I suck at this game and Sudgy is a better player.

[silverspawn]

I don't get why you are fighting against the fact that they could be a scum team. your reaction is proof that it might be a good move.

Might? Sure. Likely? Hell no. I won't be considering it today, probably not tomorrow, I know that much for sure.

And I never said it was likely.

[Witherweaver]

I mean the thing with Hydrad is that the phrase "If I was scum..." is said much more often by Scum than by Town.  E.g., my first scum game (WoT).

Has Hydrad been scum before though?

Nope.

[Voltaire]

I don't get why you are fighting against the fact that they could be a scum team. your reaction is proof that it might be a good move.

Might? Sure. Likely? Hell no. I won't be considering it today, probably not tomorrow, I know that much for sure.

And I never said it was likely.

Then we are on the same page.

I mean the thing with Hydrad is that the phrase "If I was scum..." is said much more often by Scum than by Town.  E.g., my first scum game (WoT).

Has Hydrad been scum before though?

Nope.

vote: Hydrad

[Witherweaver]

W-w-w-w-w-wagon!

[KingZog3]

W-w-w-w-w-wagon!

Who's jumping on a bandwagon? Isn't that the first vote for Hydrad?

[KingZog3]

Nvm, just looked up the previous vote count.

Also, just so everyone knows I'll be gone camping for the weekend, Friday till Monday. I'll be back monday night before the deadline, so I'll catch up then.

[Eevee]

Has Hydrad ever been scum? He feels different.

[Voltaire]

Has Hydrad ever been scum? He feels different.

Has Hydrad been scum before though?

Nope.

[Voltaire]

I do not like the joth wagon. He is getting votes for a reaction that can come from scum or town (it was my reaction too!). I think we definitely have something better.