Ok. I have finished rereading the thread. Yay for not having any work to do this afternoon. (well, at least nothing that couldn't be put off until Tuesday after the holiday).
Reads post (post counts are through
1098, when I started writing this post):
ashersky- 56 posts. Had a great response to the hammer in
960. I am getting a towny feeling from him right now. I like the hammer gambit that he played, and don't think he would have done that as scum. Maybe on a later day if scum were doing well, but on D1 after town had just defeated the monster? I don't think so.
chairs- 25 posts all game. So fairly inactive. His overall play has seemed towny to me, but we need more interaction. The biggest things about him right now: He is
against claiming and he had a
semi-suspicious post about Voltaire. I don't think either of these are reasons to suspect that he is scum.
e- town thief. Kind of like a Robin Hood. I steal from the rich for the benefit of the poor. Well, the people I steal from don't necessarily have to be rich, but it really is for the benefit of the group. And Faust,
that is all I really feel like expanding on my role right now.mail-mi- 29 posts. Not very active.
Votes Voltaire for not rolling a 5. Had this super-secret power that made him not want to roll D1, then gets 2 plays D2. Seems like a useful power, but if it had cumulative effect I think he should have waited as long as possible before playing so long as the monster was already defeated. (like if he were able to play 3 dice tomorrow) But he rolled today and played and his dice didn't count presumably because of the attack on him. I could see this as a very clever scum ploy or town who made a mistake. Right now I lean town on mail-mi.
faust- 146 posts. Very active. Very bossy too. But I like bossy, take charge kind of players. They make the game more fun. It is a total null read on town/scum, but it makes the game more enjoyable for everyone. Overall, I am slightly suspicious of him, but nothing actionable and I also have a soft spot for people who are super active.
XerxesPraelor- 48 posts. He had what I view as a suspicious vote for Voltaire, but upon rereading his posts I get a pretty decent town vibe from him.
Witherweaver- 169 posts. So very active. No one has brought any super serious cases against him, and he has been scum in like every single game, so while the Law of Averages is crap, as Faust and WW both mentioned, I do think he is town.
Beyond Awesome- 99 posts. I get a scummy feeling from him. Throws out a nice 12 for some good town cred D1. He does put Voltaire at L-3, but that is a middle-of-the-wagon spot and is a null tell. Has some dice lost/stolen/destroyed N1. I did not steal dice from BA. As yuma posted in the claim, I stole from Box both N0 and N1. So either there is another person who can steal/destroy dice, or BA is lying. However, since PPS and Box lost dice from N0, I tend to think there are multiple dice thieves/destroyers. I still get a scummy feeling from BA though.
Ichimaru Gin- 101 posts. I was leaning town, then he claimed. I totally believe the claim. I also think he is town.
If you couldn't already tell.
liopoil- 64 posts. towny. Because of
this,
this,
this,
this,
this, and
this.
Hydrad- 73 posts. New town. I like that he started the wagon on Voltaire, and I have liked his play so far and think he is town.
pingpongsam- 102 posts.
Has an "anti-town" power and claims to be the
Swindler.
Had half of his dice stolen D1. With all of that said, he is town. He spotted
Voltaire as possible scum very early. His vote was a
confirmation of that earlier read. And while I am not so sure that his
method (whatever it is) is actually flawless and
I disagree with him about Ash, I do think he is town.
Summary:
Scummy: BA
null/scum: chairs, mail-mi, Faust
null/town: Liopoil, WW, XP, Ash
town: PPS, Ichi, Hydrad, and clearly e
Author
Topic: RMM16: Dice Mafia (Town wins!) (Read 547613 times)