I'll take a look at the player field.
ashersky - well, the way he started the game was strange. But there was not much else that caught my suspicion.
chairs - lurking (well, we are only 2 days into the game, so maye this is unfair). I'll wait for more input.
yuma - also waiting for more posts when he's back from VLA.
mail-mi - I think he's more likely town than scum. Im taking him out of my lynch pool assuming that he will roll next. I just don't see scum!mail-mi pulling that kind of gambit.
BoxOfDog - well, nothing, so we have to wait. Considering that scum already took actions, while he never even posted, gives me a slight town read.
Voltaire - gives me a scummy vibe in this game. He rolled quite low, and acted sort of sheepish towards the Ichi wagon. Also, OMGUS.
faust - me
XerxesPraelor - almost certainly town.
Witherweaver - is his usual self. I have no read one way or the other.
Beyond Awesome - has this thing going where he just doesn't get rerolled. If scum really wants us to not defeat the monster, taking out 144 is just a lot better than taking out 121 or 100. I'm not sure they would skip that for WIFOM reasons only. Also, I found his read on PPS strange.
Ichimaru Gin - probably scum. Low roll, defensiveness, weakly explained OMGUS, little effort in scumhunting. A good place for my vote.
liopoil - not sure yet. I get a sort of townie feeling, but nothing solid.
Hydrad - looks townie, see above.
pingpongsam - I don't think he's making all this stuff about dice stealing up. Plus, if scum has that power, they will likely continue to use it, so we can confirm him being targeted.