What's so bad about L-1? Do you really think someone's going to derphammer?What's so good about L-1? And yes, i think that could happen (i derphammered someone myself in M54) or someone could lynch him on purpose because that person is somehow convinced that it's a good decision.
I do mean my vote. It was just random at first, but you are my "#1 scum-read" right now (even if it still is a weak read) and i think the vote is a good way of indicating that to the other players. What i meant was that i wouldn't want you to be lynched right now, beacuse 1. My read isn't strong enough right now to justify lynching you and 2. the day has just started and not too much happend so far (-> we would start day2 with almost no information if we lynch you right now).Pit, if your vote wasn't serious, why are you keeping it there?Why should i change it? If he would be at L-1 for some reason that i don't agree with or if i find someone scummy enough to vote for him i will change my vote, but for now it's just fine.
This.
I disagree. I don't think your vote should ever be on anyone if you don't mean it, it just makes the game harder to read. Right now I'm really at one vote, but it looks like I'm at two. If I get wagonned, I might getto L-2 at a point when I'd really be at L-3.
What's the upside in leaving your vote exactly ? Well I know it's not yours but you seem to agree with pit.
Pit, if your vote wasn't serious, why are you keeping it there?Why should i change it? If he would be at L-1 for some reason that i don't agree with or if i find someone scummy enough to vote for him i will change my vote, but for now it's just fine.
It's about as good (propably worse) than for scum to gain towncred.I would have treated it as a Governor and not claimed it until I wanted to use it. Claiming it now reads like an attempt to gain towncred.Yeah I'll Vote: Teproc as the power itself does not seem to have much Town utility and the only reason to claim it seems to be so that he can say he has a power.
So... what would you have done ? Not claim and never use the power ? Because using the power = claiming, since I have to type the orders in thread.
Vote: Archetype
Isn't it good for townies to gain towncred?
vote: pit if he's being serious about voting for teproc. I don't think that a) scum has that power and b) scum claims that power right away if they have it.My vote wasn't serious... I just chose a random "reason" to vote for someone and my second post wasn't meant to imply we should get rid of him and his power, only to give an approximation of the usefulness of it.
I'm not sure how Teproc effectively uses his power, though. In theory, a larger lynch is good, because it gives us more information (I think), but most likely it just means whoever he uses it on doesn't get lynched.
I wouldn't really call that OP if he is town :Alright.
I'm a Town Protector
During the day, I can type protect : CalignoBot (or whomever) and that player becomes loved, meaning you'd need one more vote to lynch them. It's like a vote, in that I can change it whenever I want, I can even not protect at all. I can do it on myself, but if I do I lose my power at the start of the next day.
Thoughts ?
Can you use it at LyLo? Sounds pretty OP if you can.
Not really. Well it's good if I have perfect reads, but that's pretty conditional. I also need to be alive by then, which is not super likely either.
So you can? I would think that targeting yourself is pretty good since it gives the other townies a good chance to hit scum that day (well, unless Pit is right). And especially if you're actually scum, it's pretty OP at LyLo.
Yeah...I definitely could remove the button from the game, but...Nice plan, i would've propably pushed the button instead of captaining you.
Anyone pushing at the time would have died.
The goal was to be the only player left alive, thereby winning for all town.
I was not even close to confident yet that it was going to work, and the game ended without us getting to further discuss it.
Roleblocking wasn't the worst thing ever, as at least no one would have died.
If BA is lynched, I'LLC push the button, but I don't think he should be. He might as well use the self-sacrificing thing and not waste our lynch.I agree with this, we should try to lynch scum today and let BA suicide.
I'm fine with ash's plan. It'd suck if he died tonight, but maybe he won't. I'm just wondering if any protective PR's shouldn't push the button maybe? Because otherwise, it seems like scum is just going to kill ash.If we follow the plan we should definitely let the protective PRs keep ash alive, otherwise he will most likely die -> whatever his power is will propably be useless -> we give scum a free kill, while our PRs can't use their powers because they all push the button
Also, was there any discussion surrounding the whole "ashes have been spread" thing that happened last night? Is this related to the flavor? And does anyone have any idea what it might mean in terms of a game mechanic?
If i would be mod of a game i wouldn't put two players of the same faction in it. I think that reinoe being scum also makes robz a lot less likely to be scum (why put 2 scum players in a neighbourhood if they have a qt anyway?)Vote: reinoe
I don't like his angry-agressive-raging playstyle + i think one of the neighbours is propably scum + TA/robz seems more towny to me
For why?
Plan update:Why do you think i'm lynchworthy? I disagreed with your plans, but i told you the reasons and nobody seemed to know how the plan benefits us. The only benefit i can image is if you have a PR that activates when someone is at L-1 (you could be told what their powers are or something like that). But a role like that could also be scum (not as likely, but still possible), which would be a huge disaster for us if we follow the plan.
All that really matters is tomorrow, I guess. I suspect I'll be slammed by a few of you for the idea, but it's worth discussing (and doing, in the end), regardless of the risk.
For today, lynch, no-lynch, whatever. I think it's been a pretty good day 1 so far, and not so crazy long yet.
We should try to do some lynch POE...1. Teproc
2. Hydrad
3. XerxesPraelor4. Witherweaver
5. silverspawn6. Beyond Awesome7. ashersky
8. Ichimaru Gin
9. xeiron
10. chairs
11. Awaclus
12. 2.71828...
13. xxpittip
14. Twistedarcher15. A Drowned Kernel
16. reinoe
Strikethroughs are not options for today, bolds are preferred, regular are meh.
XP and xeiron are a pair -- I'd lynch one just so we only have one x-name in the game since I confuse them with each other all the time.
TA and reinoe are a pair -- as you know.
xxpittip is the only player that sticks out as both active and lynchworthy.
Stop it guys. THis is making the game confusing and lets scum be there without doing useful stuff. We'renot doing the L-1 thing.+
So we should just no lynch every day and wait for scum to kill everyone because they might have strong twilight powers? I don't expect anyone's power to be valid only on day1...Can ash say anything about no-lynch besides that he thinks it's a good idea?
Well, as mentioned previously, I think we should neutralize twilight powers if possible. Why? I think they could do more harm than good. Here's an example:
Imagine a power that allows you to redirect the lynch. We spend all day decided as a town who to lynch, then it's moved. Could be by town who disagree, could be by scum saving a partner, could be by scum causing issues.
I am guessing twilight power orders are done by PM, so we won't know who did what. That's also bad.
Plus, really, Twilight was a terrible book.
I don't understand how no lynching helps in eliminating twilight powers though.
If someone can change the lynch, and there's no lynch, maybe it doesn't work?
I'll go to sleep soon, since i don't expect to live when i wake up, my final reads list:
Town <-------------------------------------------------------> Scum
ADK, Eevee, IG, Hugo, WW, Teproc, Hydrad, chairs, Awaclus
If you want to know anything else from me, ask in the next ~20min (or don't lynch me)
Any reasons for the reads?
)
