Wowowow this is going to end up being as long as Mafia III, isn't it?
First of all a big thanks to Voltgloss for changing the timeframes just to accommodate me! I totally wasn't expecting that and appreciate it.
I've been reading through for a while (the forum was super slow for me for a while too) and my thoughts so far:
Well, in that case.
Ahem.
Pick me! I'm scum!
But seriously, Galz, I am at work and I shouldn't even BE posting right now. But rest assured that when I get home this evening I will put on my scumhunting hat and get to work.
I don't like this. I don't think it's necessarily "scummy" but I think it's silly statements like this that can really get people in trouble. There are new people playing, we don't all know each others' playstyle, it's just risky. And like...why would you even say that? I don't agree that all humor is anti-town (I mean ultimately we're here to have fun, right?) but that kind of self-deprecating humor is just not smart play
In terms of the lynch vs no lynch on day 1 argument, I already stated what I think in Mafia III:
Positive:
Real information
Extra inferred information (who voted, when, etc)
Chance of lynching mafia
Negative:
Chance of lynching town (possibly higher chance than lynching mafia)
I'm not sure??
Can anyone add to that list?
By no means a complete list, still asking for any good additions.
Pre-post edit: 7 new replies. Oh dear.