unvote
After rereading, the case against silver is a lot weaker than I thought it was. His first few (serious) posts are boldly supporting the flavorclaim plan, something that I don't think pushes him either way on the scum radar. From the offset it seems that the scum's first instinct would be to not support the plan, because they 1) don't want to bother thinking of a believable townie flavor to claim, 2) don't want to have to worry about someone else having that flavor, and 3) don't gain too much from the info regarding who has a PR from flavor claims because there are probably a lot of PRs here. However, he probably correctly recognized that this plan was never going to go to fruition, so there was little danger in supporting it as scum and little hope in supporting it as town. Thus, his reaction doesn't give him town points or scum points imo.
Then there is his defense of WCD, which makes a lot of sense to me. The only real case against WCD is that his content was below average near the beginning of the game, for which he gave a pretty legitimate excuse. Aside from that, he has...not supported his own wagon? idek
He has a TR on iguana which I don't think is necessarily far fetched. Iguana had a pretty strange and oddly specific SK plan but has been pretty townish since then? I guess? (ppe: I don't agree with the e votes but iguana isn't that scummy for it imo)
He voted for ashes which I am pretty inclined to do at this point.
He correctly said that EFHW was right about WCD.
yeah maybe a little scummy but not enough to warrant a wagon like this