I think we should mass-claim. I believe that most PRs we have are easily confirmable, and we already have an idea which PRs scum has, so they can't really claim a real role and have to claim VT. We can coordinate ourselves and win this.
I targeted Xerxes tonight.
I reread Voltaire during the night, these are the results:
#79 votes Hydrad for not having played with him. He does that always, so null.
#196 Town read on XP, unclear on ash. Doesn't want to lynch PPS. Town read on ash.
#199 Ichi suggests Voltaire is town
#220 Scum read on WW and Ichi. Town read on BA BA is entirely possible as a partner.
#226 mail-mi votes Voltaire.
#229 mail-mi pushes Voltaire further. mail-mi is probably town from that interaction.
#232 Voltaire votes Ichi
#235 Voltaire leans town on mail-mi. Looks like buddying.
#237 Ichi wants people to suspect Voltaire. Would he do that as his partner? Probably not.
#245 Witherweaver doesn't want to lynch Voltaire for rolling low. All people defending low rolls are actually more scummy now.
#310 pushes liopoil.
#316 feels "really good" about his liopoil vote. lio is definitely less likely scum by this.
#344 wants to rethink BA.
#354 suspects Box, liopoil, BA. 1 scum among these three?
#536 Ichi thinks Voltaire is scum.
#548 Hydrad votes Voltaire
#551 Ichi votes Voltaire
#552 Xerxes votes Voltaire
#580 BA does a reread, ends up voting Voltaire Scummiest Voltaire vote so far.
#590 Voltaire thinks BA is town
#594 Voltaire is back on Ichi Ichi is getting more and more unlikely to be Volt's partner.
#609 Witherweaver "I don't see how this isn't town Volt" Super scummy, trying to save his mate
#623 liopoil thinks Voltaire is scummy, but votes for mail-mi. Could be scum tactis.
#644 yuma defends low-rolling and thinks people pressuring Ichi/Volt are scummy. This sure doesn't look good.
#661 PPS put Voltaire to L-1
#667 ash's hammer Really likely town. I think ash has had enough of such gambits in Philosopher's Mafia.
#671 Ichi attacks ash's hammer. Townie. Scum wouldn't do that, knowing that the flip would incriminate them.
#674 liopoil: "Stupid move, Voltaire better be scum" This looks more scummy.
Summary:
townish interactions: mail-mi, Ichi, ashersky, PPS, Hydrad
scummish interactions: WW, yuma, BA
nullish interactions: Box, chairs, liopoil, Xerxes
I really want to lynch off-wagon today though, I think there's at least one scum to be found there. Vote: yuma