you don't have to feel guilty. Honestly I thought your biggest mistakes were 1) to back down a big before my lynch and 2) not being more upset for being pushed afterwards. I thought you should've been like "Hey wtf I pushed silver treat me as an IC"
I think 2) is pretty arguable. If I'm the first person to being that up it looks a lot like wifom. I was waiting for someone else to bring it up, and lo, e did. It was tight there for a bit but I was actually not around for most of that anyway. But yes this could perhaps have been a mistake but I don't think it's as bad as you make out.
I don't agree that 1) was a mistake at all. Being unconfident and wavery about lynches is firmly within my town meta and I think people paying enough attention would have been expecting it. That's why I did it. I think the one post I made about it struck just the right balance.
Anyhoo. Congrats to reggie. Well deserved. I can't believe this was your first game.
Here's my QT.
http://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/MmGPmd2a7hs9Oh and with regards to the fruit timing. I agree it should never have happened. But there's no way it gave scum an advantage overall: the counterbalancing effect was that town had an easy way to identify fruits based on time received. Which means that scum can't use fruit to sow confusion, ever. Which was kinda annoying actually.