Finally getting to some of the criticism of me that came so quickly that I didn't have time to respond to it all when it was happening:
First, here's a general response to what I remember of people criticizing me and calling me scummy:
The whole point of my plan was to put something out there that I considered to be fairly low risk, with a very very small potential for a good reward. In fact, after I thought about it a bit, I wasn't even convinced that my plan was worth doing. BUT just because it wasn't worth doing, I didn't think it wasn't worth proposing.
Here's why: by proposing the plan, everyone in the game starts to talk about the pros and cons of it. Town is just gunna say what they think, but scum has to manufacture some sort of response, and they have to look at what their partners said, and maybe they don't want all scum against the plan if town likes it, or all scum for it when town hates it. So later on down the line, people can look for the scum team based on flips and how different people reacted. So that's value.
Also there's value in the fact that I am town and scum had to decide how to respond to all the people starting to scumread me. With the number of people who stated weak scumreads on me, there's gauranteed to be scum in there. Not helpful now but at some point, that could PoE someone.
Also Bart is probably in this game and had to decide how to react to all this, and could be caught out by that at some point.
Also just starting conversation in general has a lot of value when we are only a few pages into D1.
I'm also going to respond to people more specifically in a different post or series of posts.