Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[WestCoastDidds]

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

[Joseph2302]

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Well maybe they don't want it to count
Fake votes and fake hammers are all the rage

[MiX]

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Well maybe they don't want it to count
Fake votes and fake hammers are all the rage

Joth and Joseph are scum.

This game's kinda funny when you realize you're good at reading some people and they happen to get scum.

I suggest lynching joth now, unless there's some people who haven't done their version of gathering info for their PR shenanigans.

[skip wooznum]

Wagons, wagon.... scum jumping around on wagons

Vote: Joseph

Nope, town reading the thing to do with mafia powers in previous games, and preferring alternate wagon to leaving joth on L2

town reading whom?

[scolapasta]

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Thanks. Here it is, third time's the charm:

Vote: joseph

[Joseph2302]

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Well maybe they don't want it to count
Fake votes and fake hammers are all the rage

Joth and Joseph are scum.

This game's kinda funny when you realize you're good at reading some people and they happen to get scum.

I suggest lynching joth now, unless there's some people who haven't done their version of gathering info for their PR shenanigans.

Yh that just isn't true, I'm not scum
Joth perhaps is

[Joseph2302]

Wagons, wagon.... scum jumping around on wagons

Vote: Joseph

Nope, town reading the thing to do with mafia powers in previous games, and preferring alternate wagon to leaving joth on L2

town reading whom?

Poor phrasing
Meant I'm town, and I was reading it

[MiX]

Wagons, wagon.... scum jumping around on wagons

Vote: Joseph

Nope, town reading the thing to do with mafia powers in previous games, and preferring alternate wagon to leaving joth on L2

town reading whom?

Poor phrasing
Meant I'm town, and I was reading it

What does the thing that has to do with mafia powers in previous games have to do with your vote??

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Well maybe they don't want it to count
Fake votes and fake hammers are all the rage

Joth and Joseph are scum.

This game's kinda funny when you realize you're good at reading some people and they happen to get scum.

I suggest lynching joth now, unless there's some people who haven't done their version of gathering info for their PR shenanigans.

Yh that just isn't true, I'm not scum
Joth perhaps is

But like, this is your scumtell. I can't just back away now!

You can also be third-party, last time I thought you were off you were third-party. But, like, meh. And I'm voting for scum so yeah.

[Joseph2302]

Wagons, wagon.... scum jumping around on wagons

Vote: Joseph

Nope, town reading the thing to do with mafia powers in previous games, and preferring alternate wagon to leaving joth on L2

town reading whom?

Poor phrasing
Meant I'm town, and I was reading it

What does the thing that has to do with mafia powers in previous games have to do with your vote??

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Well maybe they don't want it to count
Fake votes and fake hammers are all the rage

Joth and Joseph are scum.

This game's kinda funny when you realize you're good at reading some people and they happen to get scum.

I suggest lynching joth now, unless there's some people who haven't done their version of gathering info for their PR shenanigans.

Yh that just isn't true, I'm not scum
Joth perhaps is

But like, this is your scumtell. I can't just back away now!

You can also be third-party, last time I thought you were off you were third-party. But, like, meh. And I'm voting for scum so yeah.

There was a mention of game(s) where scum had some day lynch power where they could turn L1 into a hammer. Thus, my L2 vote would be an L1 vote if scum had that power. And the fact people were mentioning it made me think it could be relevant to this game. Better to get more wagons, get more info and then we can always still lynch joth later on if people want to. But D1 for me is about options not just everyone tunnelling one persob

I don't remember being third party very often, maybe I was and just don't remember

[MiX]

You overestimate the games we've played together.

Also you're literally using a scumtell sudgy said existed. Literally. And I think that's scum!Joseph behavior.

Why is scola scum?

[Glooble]

I knew I needed to get some sleep. Between the jetlag and the Russian with the gone, it already felt like I hadn't slept in a week. Some vacation this was turning out to be. But I just couldn't stop thinking about the clues I'd already found. Something just didn't add up.

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline is April 29th at noon ET.

Vote Count 1.4:

MiX (1): sudgy
jotheonah (5): MiX, faust, A Drowned Kernel, Eevee, LaLight
sudgy (1): skip wooznum
skip wooznum (1): Awaclus
Scolapasta (3): jotheonah, mail-mi, Joseph2302
Joseph2302 (2): WestCoastDidds, scolapasta
Not voting (2): Galzria, DatSwan

[Galzria]

You overestimate the games we've played together.

Also you're literally using a scumtell sudgy said existed. Literally. And I think that's scum!Joseph behavior.

Why is scola scum?

If players were told that X was a scum tell, wouldn't scum not do X? Doesn't that, by default, make X now more a town tell?

[MiX]

I knew I needed to get some sleep. Between the jetlag and the Russian with the gone, it already felt like I hadn't slept in a week. Some vacation this was turning out to be. But I just couldn't stop thinking about the clues I'd already found. Something just didn't add up.

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline is April 29th at noon ET.

Vote Count 1.4:

MiX (1): sudgy
jotheonah (5): MiX, faust, A Drowned Kernel, Eevee, LaLight
sudgy (1): skip wooznum
skip wooznum (1): Awaclus
Scolapasta (3): jotheonah, mail-mi, Joseph2302
Joseph2302 (2): WestCoastDidds, scolapasta
Not voting (2): Galzria, DatSwan

Either everyone that is new to my meta is briefed by scum to vote for me early D1, or sudgy is town.

You overestimate the games we've played together.

Also you're literally using a scumtell sudgy said existed. Literally. And I think that's scum!Joseph behavior.

Why is scola scum?

If players were told that X was a scum tell, wouldn't scum not do X? Doesn't that, by default, make X now more a town tell?

It's not because it's a scumtell, it's because Joseph did something that sudgy said it was a scumtell. For me, that's a scumtell for Joseph.

[jotheonah]

Scola, if you want the vote to count, put a space between the colon and the name.

Well maybe they don't want it to count
Fake votes and fake hammers are all the rage

Joth and Joseph are scum.

This game's kinda funny when you realize you're good at reading some people and they happen to get scum.

I suggest lynching joth now, unless there's some people who haven't done their version of gathering info for their PR shenanigans.

Hilarious.

[skip wooznum]

It's not because it's a scumtell, it's because Joseph did something that sudgy said it was a scumtell. For me, that's a scumtell for Joseph.

Are you suggesting that Joseph did it because sudgy said it was a scumtell? That is quite the theory.

[MiX]

It's not because it's a scumtell, it's because Joseph did something that sudgy said it was a scumtell. For me, that's a scumtell for Joseph.

Are you suggesting that Joseph did it because sudgy said it was a scumtell? That is quite the theory.

Yeah, scum!Joseph does that I think.

Actually you're right I'm wrong about Joseph he's actually town. Sorry I got my tells mixed up. Ha, get it.

Joth's still scum so, there's that.

[Swowl]

You overestimate the games we've played together.

Also you're literally using a scumtell sudgy said existed. Literally. And I think that's scum!Joseph behavior.

Why is scola scum?

If players were told that X was a scum tell, wouldn't scum not do X? Doesn't that, by default, make X now more a town tell?

Why is it important to have competing wagons?

Why is it unimportant?

wtf is going on? are you like trying to take Awaclus' punch lines from him?

[skip wooznum]

Ok, I've been sitting on some information and I should probably start divulging it.

The item I need has appeared in another player's list of 5.

The way I see it, there are 3 possibilities:
A)The player in question really needs a different item on their list, and totally by chance happened to put the item I need on their list.
B)The player needs the same item I need, and is town.
C)The player needs the same item I need, and is scum.

I have personal opinions on the relative likelihood of these possibilities, but I'd first like to hear from others, especially the people who have provided lists.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Ok, I've been sitting on some information and I should probably start divulging it.

The item I need has appeared in another player's list of 5.

The way I see it, there are 3 possibilities:
A)The player in question really needs a different item on their list, and totally by chance happened to put the item I need on their list.
B)The player needs the same item I need, and is town.
C)The player needs the same item I need, and is scum.

I have personal opinions on the relative likelihood of these possibilities, but I'd first like to hear from others, especially the people who have provided lists.

Interesting. But I don't think I could answer A without knowing what the item name is (which isn't me asking you to claim it)

[scolapasta]

Ok, I've been sitting on some information and I should probably start divulging it.

The item I need has appeared in another player's list of 5.

The way I see it, there are 3 possibilities:
A)The player in question really needs a different item on their list, and totally by chance happened to put the item I need on their list.
B)The player needs the same item I need, and is town.
C)The player needs the same item I need, and is scum.

I have personal opinions on the relative likelihood of these possibilities, but I'd first like to hear from others, especially the people who have provided lists.

Option D) The player has the item and included in their list to get this kind of reaction (I think that's possibly NAI)

[skip wooznum]

Ok, I've been sitting on some information and I should probably start divulging it.

The item I need has appeared in another player's list of 5.

The way I see it, there are 3 possibilities:
A)The player in question really needs a different item on their list, and totally by chance happened to put the item I need on their list.
B)The player needs the same item I need, and is town.
C)The player needs the same item I need, and is scum.

I have personal opinions on the relative likelihood of these possibilities, but I'd first like to hear from others, especially the people who have provided lists.

Option D) The player has the item and included in their list to get this kind of reaction (I think that's possibly NAI)

Ok that hadn't occurred to me. Though it seems like a bad idea as either alignment.

[skip wooznum]

Ok, I've been sitting on some information and I should probably start divulging it.

The item I need has appeared in another player's list of 5.

The way I see it, there are 3 possibilities:
A)The player in question really needs a different item on their list, and totally by chance happened to put the item I need on their list.
B)The player needs the same item I need, and is town.
C)The player needs the same item I need, and is scum.

I have personal opinions on the relative likelihood of these possibilities, but I'd first like to hear from others, especially the people who have provided lists.

Interesting. But I don't think I could answer A without knowing what the item name is (which isn't me asking you to claim it)

To be honest, this is a pretty strange situation and I'm unsure where to go from here. Should I claim more? Should I wait for the other list posters to say more? The thing is, I want the person who posted my item to say more stuff before he's sure he's the one who posted my item. On the other hand it's probably bad for the other list posters to start saying things, because they're not really involved and should not be forced to claim anything further. So I'm more or less at a loss and have been for some time.

[skip wooznum]

What are people's thoughts on option B versus C (ignoring option A)?

[scolapasta]

What are people's thoughts on option B versus C (ignoring option A)?

Probably depends on what you are.

[skip wooznum]

Yeah I'm town.

Who's scum, do we think?