Let's do some Voltaire-style premature PoEing.
iguanaiguana: Towniest player, easily. Off the table.
RR: Sure. Didn't really respond to prods as much as I think town!RR does. Could lynch.
e: Nonchalant, which is town!e, but not overwhelmingly so... enough for day 1 though, I think. Tentatively off the table.
TWM: Vaguely scummy, but I'm not sure why. Could lynch.
Joseph: No idea, as he just always seems scummy to me. Would lynch over no lynch.
Robz: See above, conforming to his town!meta when it's not that profitable because he recently had a strong town-ish performance, off the table.
Eevee: Eh. I always think he's scum, but really I have no idea. Would lynch over no lynch.
gkrieg13: No clue. Don't remember his meta well either. Don't find the votes against him particularly convincing. Would lynch over no lynch.
J Reggie: Scummy. Would lynch.
Jake: Scum. Lynch !
faust: town!faust annoys me a lot more than scum!faust, so... off the table.
ashersky. Kinda scummy actually, because he has done nothing I remember aside from a half-hearted fakehammer. Would lynch.
Well, that was unhelpful. Turns out Voltaire-style PoE only works if you have a bunch of town reads.
PPE: It is ? Ugh. The impression I got from reading... M90 I think it was ? was of an active townie who didn't think too much about what he posts, not a lurker.