Shraeye's assessment.
angrybirds: There's something weird here. I don't like that angrybirds made this vote basically from the start and hasn't changed it since. Even after all the explaining he's done, it's hard to believe that angrybirds actually feels this way. That's a read that I would build up over time, not one I would jump to after about 115 posts, one-fifth of which were confirming role-receiving, one-fifth of which were complete RVS, and then continue to hold until the post count reached 500. Maybe he's scared to peel off of his initial assessment and jump on any bandwagon, since bandwagon lynches sometimes feel scummy. Maybe he's not actively looking for any scumtells, so can't put down solid arguments explaining why A and B were scumtells from player X. On rereading I don't like his response to Robz in #276; his posts and behavior did not speak for themselves, he had hardly any substantiative posts except to vaguely back up his snap-judgement on Galzria. His putting Robz on suspicious list due to Robz "suspecting" him felt less like OMGUS, and more like "when people realize I bring heat when they suspect me, they will be very hesitant to do it. This scum's surviving 'til the end, huzzah!" I can understand you still holding suspicions on Galzria, but move your vote to something that's gonna happen this round, because clearly other people are not behind your Galzria-read.
Axxle: Well Axxle's purposful-ignoring of any accusations/heat really rubbed me the wrong way. I can buy the arguement in #348 if this were day 2 or later and we had things of real substance to analyze/vote on. But frankly, Day 1 townies know nothing, and that makes this start difficult for us. I rely on seeing how people react to get reads, since there is little else, but no reaction=hiding tells=suspicious to me. I'm not asking you to spend the whole day defending yourself, but on day one where suspicion is sprayed around with a fire-hose and evidence is hard to find, you aren't spending your time better by broadcasting your opinion while ignoring any suspicion on you. Buuuut, I'm looking at your softclaim and the list of possible roles (excluding Major Arcana, which I can only guess at). I really hate how softly you put this claim, but it may have been just enough. It's possible that you are town-aligned Vengeful. I feel less gung-ho to lynch you after this claim, so I take back my previous scoff at its effectiveness.
Eevee: Eevee was the first one to suggest lynching someone for being in the "wrong" suit even though this is easily manipulated, that felt like it was bound to give us a town-lynch. Another person who's only made one vote. I don't like people who hone in on one person and keep their vote there forever, that feels like very scum-fident (confident) voting. Also, looking through his posts, I am floored by the lack of content. Check it out for yourself!
ehunt: Really supported getting the conversations started, and helping newer players join in. Firm in his anti-Axxle wagon stance. I read him as townish, but he is also in hardcore lurk mode. No posts in almost 2 days and over 100 posts, this is suspicious enough to remove all townish reads and send him at least down to neutral. Looks like he was content to let Axxle-wagon happen while saying he disagreed instead of pushing his own suspicions of Frisk (convince us, dude! why should we vote for Frisk?). Frisk is his only vote so far, this pushes him down to scum-read.
Frisk: Very neutral read. He seems to be trying hard to lynch correctly, and is moving his suspicions/questions around even though his vote has mostly been on Robz. Can you tell us some more thoughts regarding different people, Frisk?
ftl: I think ftl did the right thing in trying to start a wagon, but he did back off too early. His terribleness at vote-counting gives me a hilarious town-read. So there you go, egregious mistakes=towntell in my eyes I guess. He's been very liberal at moving his vote around, and rereads old posts. Town in my eyes; however, he is in lurk mode now.
Galzria: Galz needs to post more substantiative stuff. He had a unique read on Axxle, that was a legitimate reason for voting Axxle I believe. He is in lurk mode, if not in post-count, then definitely in content.
Insomniac: Insomniac's post that cleared him from previous suspicion was #247. He really seems to disappear for periods of time, but he's almost always returning to us with content-posts instead of witticisms and one-liners. It really irks me that Insomniac hasn't cast his vote for anyone (do it, like, do it now! even if you're the first vote on someone; make a scum-prediction and back it up with a vote). Regardless, I get slight town read from him.
Morgrim: I really like the change he's made towards posting a bit more, and stating his analysis. Even if it goes against how he "normally plays" I agree with Eevee that we should encourage good behavior instead of punishing it. He suspects Galz, votes for Insomniac, jumps on Robz bandwagon. But he doesn't jump on the Axxle one, which is a plus, because being part of every bandwagon just seems way too eager to lynch, regardless of correctness (if we find somebody doing this, I'm thinking SK). I'm getting a slight town read, but definitely put him in my no-lynch category.
O: O makes what looks like a gut-reaction vote on Robz after Robz questions angrybirds, but I get a neutral read off this. I don't like your take on ehunt's person-summary; "very town" is a legitimate read without tyring to buddy up to someone. He seems to be trying really hard to make a good lynch; not as many posts as others, but they are usually full of content. I get a slight town-read.
Robz: Robz clearly started the game very lurker-y, but for good reason. He immediately jumps into a spat with angrybirds. I doesn't look like he deserved as much heat as he got, but he reacted to that heat pretty badly. I still get a pretty neutral read on Robz, leaning slight town. His quick jump off Axxle felt weird, but I think he has the right of it.
sharkbait/Grujah: Really hard to read, natually, due to the switch. Grujah, keep posting at your current great rate. I'm not liking how content-less his posts have been, but keep in mind he missed out on the fun RVS phase that we all got to do. Funtime is over, Grujah. We gotta push for a good lynch soon. I'm keeping him at a neutral-to-scum read, but I'd still be ok with a Grujah lynch based on sharky's lurking followed by Grujah's being all over the place.
shraeye: I'm me. I write long posts. I have long thoughts. I get drunk. It doesn't stop me from posting.
sparky: Sparky's vote-count hasn't been as high as some people's, but he is the king of content per post. In his posts, he is clearly not afraid of letting everyone know what he's been thinking and has jumped on multiple suspicious actions, and this reads as town to me. Even if you don't agree with my town-read on sparky, I would still put him in a no-lynch category because we always want people who are willing to provide analysis and information freely. Though I don't like that he precalled me out in case Axxle flips town. If sparky is scum, and is therefore more likely to know that Axxle is town, he is setting himself a nice fall-guy for a day 2 lynch.
Voltgloss: Also very unafraid to put out his opinion. This puts him in a no-lynch category, since if he's scum I feel it will be easier to tell as the game goes on as opposed to a more reticent scum. His call for everyone voting is a super pro-town move, he also appears to be very convincable to jump on different bandwagons. Also, he is pushing pretty hard for a lurker to be lynched, which feels as long as we count lurkers as people lacking content instead of simply people with low post counts.
yuma: I really like the way he will ask questions of people (I think he's done this to Morgrim, Insomniac, maybe others) and doesn't let go. It's much better to push for answers than to throw out questions as accusations and then move on if they don't pick up any momentum among other players. This feels pretty towny to me. I read his stubbornness of keeping his vote on me instead of just jumping on a Robz/Axxle wagon that seemed inevitable as town actually. He doesn't want a lynch of Robz or Axxle because it's convenient, he wants a good lynch. He should reread my posts if he still gets scum vibes from me, but I appreciate his push for a good lynch.
tl;dr
Well then read it! I don't care if it's too long. There are 2 questions there that I want answers to, and I need Insomniac to respond to my demands of him.
Summary
Lynches I would support: angrybirds (scummy/SK?), eevee (scummy), ehunt (not willing to defend/push his convictions on Frisk+slight scum), Galzria (waaay too lurkerish), Grujah(sharkbait lurking+Grujah's late RVSing)
No-lynch: ftl (town), Insomniac (slight town+good content), Morgrim (slight-town+finally giving content), O (slight town+good content), shraeye (town), Voltgloss (town+good content)
Everyone else is in a bit of a neutral category. I don't want to lynch them yet, but I don't think I'd defend them yet.
Axxle (slight town), Frisk (neutral read), Robz (neutral to slight town), sparky (slight town, but I feel suspicioius), yuma (slight town)
Vote: Eevee