Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Archetype]

BAM! First.

[Archetype]

13 seconds!

[Archetype]

Suuuuper pumped for this game even though I have zero knowledge of the flavor (but my friend tells me the books are great)!

[Jimmmmm]

Vote: Arch

[Archetype]

13 seconds!

I'm dumb. 16 seconds!

Vote: Arch

Vote: Jimmmmm

[ashersky]

vote: yuma

[Twistedarcher]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

[Jimmmmm]

13 seconds!

I'm dumb. 16 seconds!

Lynch all Liars!

[ashersky]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

[Jimmmmm]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

...what? No plan??

[ashersky]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

...what? No plan??

Says who?

[Jimmmmm]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

...what? No plan??

Says who?

Says you.

[Witherweaver]

Okay guys some ground rules.

If you're ever upset or exasperated, the proper response is "Blood and ashes!" or, if you're really upset, "Blood and bloody ashes!".  You can also go with something shorter like "Light!"  I feel that's pretty important for this.

Oh, yeah, I'm also a newbie.  So forgive me if I ask dumb questions.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Okay guys some ground rules.

If you're ever upset or exasperated, the proper response is "Blood and ashes!" or, if you're really upset, "Blood and bloody ashes!".  You can also go with something shorter like "Light!"  I feel that's pretty important for this.

Oh, yeah, I'm also a newbie.  So forgive me if I ask dumb questions.

Watch your mouth!

[Witherweaver]

Okay guys some ground rules.

If you're ever upset or exasperated, the proper response is "Blood and ashes!" or, if you're really upset, "Blood and bloody ashes!".  You can also go with something shorter like "Light!"  I feel that's pretty important for this.

Oh, yeah, I'm also a newbie.  So forgive me if I ask dumb questions.

Watch your mouth!

I was just trying to help!  Blood and ashes!

[AndrewisFTTW]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

Why wouldn't you want to play it after 5-6 days? Sorry, I'm confused by this.

[Twistedarcher]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

Why wouldn't you want to play it after 5-6 days? Sorry, I'm confused by this.

From what I've heard, the series was really good but should have ended 10 books ago.

[AndrewisFTTW]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

Why wouldn't you want to play it after 5-6 days? Sorry, I'm confused by this.

From what I've heard, the series was really good but should have ended 10 books ago.

Oh duh. I'm near the end of book 5 and it's still pretty good. I've heard that the series slows down at 6 and gets pretty awful at 9 and 10 before it starts getting good again. I'm looking forward to it.

[Witherweaver]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

So what is closed, and why treat it as a vanilla game?

[A Drowned Kernel]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

Vote: TA

I was going to make that joke. Also, mail-mi's probably going to die near the end and have to be replaced with a different mod.

[AndrewisFTTW]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

Vote: TA

I was going to make that joke. Also, mail-mi's probably going to die near the end and have to be replaced with a different mod.

Ouch. That's not right.

Vote: ADK

[A Drowned Kernel]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

So what is closed, and why treat it as a vanilla game?

Closed means the players have no information about what PR's there are, or even what factions there are. As I understand it, the only bit we have is that everyone has some sort of non-vanilla ability. Ash is saying that since we have no info, we shouldn't discuss things like claiming at all.

[Witherweaver]

So do we play a mafia game for about 5-6 days, it'll be great and fun, then get forced to play another 10 days that no one wants to play when it should have been over months ago?

Why wouldn't you want to play it after 5-6 days? Sorry, I'm confused by this.

From what I've heard, the series was really good but should have ended 10 books ago.

Oh duh. I'm near the end of book 5 and it's still pretty good. I've heard that the series slows down at 6 and gets pretty awful at 9 and 10 before it starts getting good again. I'm looking forward to it.

Erroneous!  Yes it gets slower after book 6 or 7, and yes you meet a lot of characters that you don't really care about and have trouble keeping track of.  But I like slow burns. I liked reading all the books, and I think they all have something to offer.

[yuma]

Been awhile since we've had a true closed setup.  My first thought is treat D1 as a vanilla game.

Well I already have something to say:

I am a DayVig. I might be mandatory, I might not be. I'll probably say whether I am or not at a later juncture. But regardless, if/when I use this power I will fully be taking in town's consideration on who I might kill but I will not be bound to it because ultimately I trust my own reads more so than town as a collective whole as there is manipulation afoot here.

I am claiming 1. for this reason, to get input, but 2. I think it WIFOMs mafia enough to make them think about killing me--assuming I don't use my shot(s) today--(because I could be dangerous to them in taking out a mafia member during the day or I could be helpful to them in taking out a towie PR more beneficial to town than me)

But regardless of all of this I don't think we have ever seen a mafia dayvig before and I don't think we will ever see one. So while I won't say I am an IC I would hope that from your perspective you can increase your trust of me and my reads (but take them with a grain of salt because they are horribly bad).

[yuma]

In general I am kinda against claiming. RMM less so, but obviously I felt there was a good reason for my doing so today with my given role. I won't necessarily say no one else should claim, but rather just caution that just because I claimed doesn't mean all other players should as well until we analyze the merits of claiming or not. Individuals may want to as they see fit, to them I would just say to make sure it is the right thing to do. I believe my claiming now was the right thing to do.