OOC: People seem to be doing it differently. So could I have some clarification. Is the -2 on both rolls (meaning -4) or just the total (-2)?
I think maybe the wild die is confusing you? You get the highest of the wild die and skill die, they don't add. So -2 on both is still just -2. Really you're getting the highest of notice die or wild die, then -2 on the result, but this is equivalent to rolling each die with a -2 and taking the highest. So Galzria and spiritbears rolled correctly, but I'm not sure who all is perceiving it correctly.
So, Notice Rolls so far are:
Jimmy(Jorbles): 1 (Notice: (3-2) 1, Wild: (2-2) 0, 1 is higher)
Amanda(Jack Rudd): 1 (Notice: (3-2) 1, Wild: (2-2) 0, 1 is higher)
Grant(Galzria): 3 (Notice: (5-2) 3, Wild (5-2) 3, 3 is "higher")
Bob (spiritbears): 0 (I'm going to stop explaining now, it should be clear)
Other results are:
Grant's Stealth: 7
Bob's Stealth: 2 (pending...)
Genji's Boost: 4 (success)
Jimmy's Persuasion: 11 (wild die was 6 then 3 for 9, +2 for charisma)
If a die aces, you don't apply the -2 again.
It's going to take more time than I have tonight to word Bass/others' response/notice results.
One last thing: @spiritbears: you aced the d4 on your stealth check, so you need to reroll the d4 (adding 2 from the acing die)