Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[raerae]

What's the case on TwistedArcher?

[Eevee]

Went back, it was just like I thought. I don't understand how it implies there must be scum in lovers, can you explain that?

It doesn't. But what's the utility of the role if there's NOT scum in them. I guess a role to confirm townies, but it seems like a really, really, really weak role unless there's scum in those lover pairs.

How does there being or not being scum in the lover pairs have any bearing with that role's utility? Heck, isn't the role actually SIGNIFICANTLY stronger if all the lovers are town and each investigation has a chance at creating two ic's?

[raerae]

You couldn't pay me to claim.

[Twistedarcher]

What's the case on TwistedArcher?

I want to lynch Sudgy.

Same as the case on you, or EFHW.

Basically, the case is, I'm the person they could get Eevee to support.

[Eevee]

So Eevee, you realize you are risking the game here, right?

I'm extremely confident, and you can all blame me if I'm drawing the wrong conclusions from what I know.

[Twistedarcher]

So Eevee, you realize you are risking the game here, right?

I'm extremely confident, and you can all blame me if I'm drawing the wrong conclusions from what I know.

I feel the same -- at least we see eye to eye on something!

[raerae]

I appreciate the assistance but somebody on wagon needs to spell this out for me.

[raerae]

WAIT A SECOND!!  Voting TA over voting me???  Who's scummy now.  Why is one of us, both of whom have been pushing damn hard for sudgy's lynch, more scummy than the other.  Analyzing the shit out of this wagon right now.

It's mail-mi, Eevee, and sudgy, otherwise known as the possible partner, the recently claimed lover, and the scummy lover.

Are we in a legitimate stalemate?

One more time, kids, why is TA the scummiest of us all? 

[Eevee]

TA, the thing is, as long as sudgy is town, you can't be, and I'm super eager to bet the game on that.

The problem with massclaiming is that most of the town are lovers so just identifying the scum team might not be enough. Lets not massclaim.

[EFHW]

WAIT A SECOND!!  Voting TA over voting me???  Who's scummy now.  Why is one of us, both of whom have been pushing damn hard for sudgy's lynch, more scummy than the other.  Analyzing the shit out of this wagon right now.

It's mail-mi, Eevee, and sudgy, otherwise known as the possible partner, the recently claimed lover, and the scummy lover.

Are we in a legitimate stalemate?

One more time, kids, why is TA the scummiest of us all?

I'm not on the wagon, but the main thing that has seemed scummy to me has been the cases he made on nkirbit, lio and me.

[Twistedarcher]

TA, the thing is, as long as sudgy is town, you can't be, and I'm super eager to bet the game on that.

The problem with massclaiming is that most of the town are lovers so just identifying the scum team might not be enough. Lets not massclaim.

Why couldn't the team be EFHW/raerae?

[Eevee]

WAIT A SECOND!!  Voting TA over voting me???  Who's scummy now.  Why is one of us, both of whom have been pushing damn hard for sudgy's lynch, more scummy than the other.  Analyzing the shit out of this wagon right now.

It's mail-mi, Eevee, and sudgy, otherwise known as the possible partner, the recently claimed lover, and the scummy lover.

Are we in a legitimate stalemate?

One more time, kids, why is TA the scummiest of us all?

If he was town, the team would have to be raerae-ehfw and either of you would have hammered him for the win long ago.

[Twistedarcher]

WAIT A SECOND!!  Voting TA over voting me???  Who's scummy now.  Why is one of us, both of whom have been pushing damn hard for sudgy's lynch, more scummy than the other.  Analyzing the shit out of this wagon right now.

It's mail-mi, Eevee, and sudgy, otherwise known as the possible partner, the recently claimed lover, and the scummy lover.

Are we in a legitimate stalemate?

One more time, kids, why is TA the scummiest of us all?

I'm not on the wagon, but the main thing that has seemed scummy to me has been the cases he made on nkirbit, lio and me.

0/3, I'm thinking

[Eevee]

TA, the thing is, as long as sudgy is town, you can't be, and I'm super eager to bet the game on that.

The problem with massclaiming is that most of the town are lovers so just identifying the scum team might not be enough. Lets not massclaim.

Why couldn't the team be EFHW/raerae?

Because you are still alive.

[Twistedarcher]

TA, the thing is, as long as sudgy is town, you can't be, and I'm super eager to bet the game on that.

The problem with massclaiming is that most of the town are lovers so just identifying the scum team might not be enough. Lets not massclaim.

Why couldn't the team be EFHW/raerae?

Because you are still alive.

This is a great point. And this has confirmed the sudgy-mail mi team for me.

[raerae]

WAIT A SECOND!!  Voting TA over voting me???  Who's scummy now.  Why is one of us, both of whom have been pushing damn hard for sudgy's lynch, more scummy than the other.  Analyzing the shit out of this wagon right now.

It's mail-mi, Eevee, and sudgy, otherwise known as the possible partner, the recently claimed lover, and the scummy lover.

Are we in a legitimate stalemate?

One more time, kids, why is TA the scummiest of us all?

If he was town, the team would have to be raerae-ehfw and either of you would have hammered him for the win long ago.

I still want to know the case on TA.  Like the reason you voted.  That thing.  I mean, our side has a case, yes we do, our side has a case, how 'bout you!?

[Eevee]

Ehfw, I'm increasingly certain you are the townie. Read through the last page and see how painfully obvious it is that ta must be scum.

Ta, suddenly no interest in continuing the "lio's role means there must be scum" argument now that I pointed out it makes no sense?

[Twistedarcher]

We know there's 2 scum, 3 town voting correctly, and 1 misguided town. This is true for either side.

Eevee, don't you think you fit into that role of misguided town perfectly?

[Twistedarcher]

Ehfw, I'm increasingly certain you are the townie. Read through the last page and see how painfully obvious it is that ta must be scum.

Ta, suddenly no interest in continuing the "lio's role means there must be scum" argument now that I pointed out it makes no sense?

So, Raerae is the scum?

I concede that you may be correct on Lio's role, even though I disagree with you.  But I guess there's no way to confirm it either way. I think it only has utility catching scum. Creating ICs is useless if you're not 100% sure you're actually creating ICs!

[Eevee]

WAIT A SECOND!!  Voting TA over voting me???  Who's scummy now.  Why is one of us, both of whom have been pushing damn hard for sudgy's lynch, more scummy than the other.  Analyzing the shit out of this wagon right now.

It's mail-mi, Eevee, and sudgy, otherwise known as the possible partner, the recently claimed lover, and the scummy lover.

Are we in a legitimate stalemate?

One more time, kids, why is TA the scummiest of us all?

If he was town, the team would have to be raerae-ehfw and either of you would have hammered him for the win long ago.

I still want to know the case on TA.  Like the reason you voted.  That thing.  I mean, our side has a case, yes we do, our side has a case, how 'bout you!?

It doesn't even matter anymore, scum has painted themselves in the corner. Despite, wasn't the cornerstone of your case liopoil's role meaning there must be scum in lovers? I've refuted that and I've explained why sudgy doesn't necessarily die in the night in a rmm game and why the people responsible wouldn't want to claim. Why is your side dodging my questions? Do you accept me for an ic?

[Eevee]

How does confirming lover pairs, something that a townie would be 100% able to do anyways, make lio's role any stronger?

I think it's point was to make him able to whiteknight lovers under a lynch threat. A protective role of sorts, just like his lover xeiron.

[Twistedarcher]

I accept you for a misguided IC!

Sorry, why would Sudgy be alive?

I hate to ask you to claim more, but did you prevent Sudgy from being killed last night?

If no one can claim any reason why Sudgy would be alive, then that means it's more likely he's scum.

[Eevee]

Ehfw, I'm increasingly certain you are the townie. Read through the last page and see how painfully obvious it is that ta must be scum.

Ta, suddenly no interest in continuing the "lio's role means there must be scum" argument now that I pointed out it makes no sense?

So, Raerae is the scum?

I concede that you may be correct on Lio's role, even though I disagree with you.  But I guess there's no way to confirm it either way. I think it only has utility catching scum. Creating ICs is useless if you're not 100% sure you're actually creating ICs!

Yes, I think raerae is scum.

And no, I don't think I'm a misguided townie as my narrative makes 100% sense while yours is full of holes.

[EFHW]

Ok, Eevee, I hope you are right.  Intent to hammer.

[Twistedarcher]

I will not lose without claiming.