Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ashersky]

Actually, I'm happy to leave mail-mi alive to be NKed at this point.

[raerae]

Didn't mail-mi also claim he knew where a key or something special was?  Or was that somebody else?

Also, reading jimmmmm now then on to mcmc.

[mail-mi]

Didn't mail-mi also claim he knew where a key or something special was?  Or was that somebody else?

Also, reading jimmmmm now then on to mcmc.

That was sudgy

[raerae]

Didn't mail-mi also claim he knew where a key or something special was?  Or was that somebody else?

Also, reading jimmmmm now then on to mcmc.

That was sudgy

Ahhhh, thanks.

[yuma]

vote: mail-mi

I still think jimmmm is a good lynch but man that was really really bad.

Obvious play is obvious.

[raerae]

Jimmmmmm Notes:
1. In favor of map claim then backs off it.  This was before everybody got all up in arms about it being a bad idea so I have no scumread here. (early D1)
2. Argues against a no lynch because it doesn't help find scum.  This was basically the most content he's posted all game. (#397)
3. Doesn't address his wagon.  Is this scummy?  Is it just his play?  I can't remember a jimmmmm wagon taking place before...
4. Goes back to talking about map claiming...I don't care for that but since his lynch was gaining speed at that time, it almost seems like he's asking permission?

I'm not buying it and I won't support this lynch.  I think Jimmmmm is a good enough player that if he were scum, I'd expect his play to have done a 180 after Kooshie got lynched for lurking and not posting content.  I'll judge him more when his reads come in but I'm not game for this one as it stands. 

[ashersky]

vote: mail-mi

I still think jimmmm is a good lynch but man that was really really bad.

Obvious play is obvious.

But isn't it obvious bad town play?

[mail-mi]

vote: mail-mi

I still think jimmmm is a good lynch but man that was really really bad.

Obvious play is obvious.

Don't waste your lunch on me. I'm probably gonna get nkd anyway.

[mail-mi]

The following is a test: (If I survive the night, I'll tell you what this test is about.)

Unvote

Vote: liopoil

[mail-mi]

(test still)

Unvote

Vote: sparky

[mail-mi]

(test)

Unvote

Vote: Jimmmmm

[mcmcsalot]

ugh, I don't care is that was stupid on mail-mi's part. Doesn't mean hes scum in any way. Yuma voting for him after saying nothing could make him look at on-wagoners...thats scummy. Raerae, what don't you get about lynching someone who has posted about zero content.

[Jimmmmm]

mail-mi, are you still voting for me intentionally?

[raerae]

Mcmc Thoughts:
1. Nothing noteworthy prior to me replacing in other than his little thing with yuma.  It was interesting but I didn't draw much from either of them based on it.
2. Some potential buddying at #345.
3. He's voiced suspicion of mail-mi since D1 but hasn't put a real case together on that suspicion.
4. He's contributed theory, content, ideas, and tried to move the game along without rushing it.

I can say, with as much certainty as usual and with the normal disclaimer that I reserve the right to change my mind, that we are dealing with town mcmc.  As scum, this man is manipulative and will create and push the hell out of a case until it goes through.  He also doesn't oppose town lynches.  If he were scum, he would have been all over the Kooshie wagon.  One other thing that is going to sound conceited as hell but is true, if mcmc were scum, I would either be set up for a lynch or dead by now. 

Going to bed now, will take a look at mail-mi and maybe eevee tomorrow.

[raerae]

ugh, I don't care is that was stupid on mail-mi's part. Doesn't mean hes scum in any way. Yuma voting for him after saying nothing could make him look at on-wagoners...thats scummy. Raerae, what don't you get about lynching someone who has posted about zero content.

What about my post was unclear?  I won't push this lynch through because I don't believe it's sound.  I think we're getting over excited because we (finally!) caught lurky scum for the first time since...what?  Buffy?  and the lurking was a secondary scum trait in that game...and we're going to make a mistake if we lynch Jimmmmm.  I really don't believe scum would be stupid enough to pull that twice.

That being said, he still does need to produce those promised reads.

[Jorbles]

vote: mail-mi

I still think jimmmm is a good lynch but man that was really really bad.

Obvious play is obvious.

mail-mi's play seems bad enough that it was just terrible town play. If he's still alive tomorrow, then well I might revisit that.

[Robz888]

Vote Count 2.6

Jimm (6) -- Ozle, Jorbles, liopoil, mail-mi, mcmcsalot, sudgy {L-2}
sudgy (1) -- Insomniac
mcmcsalot (2) -- ashersky, Eevee
mail-mi (1) yuma

Not Voting (4) -- sparky5856, Jimm, Lekkit, raerae

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. The game ends on April 29th at 7:00 PM. There are 32 days left.

[Jimmmmm]

vote: mail-mi

I still think jimmmm is a good lynch but man that was really really bad.

Obvious play is obvious.

mail-mi's play seems bad enough that it was just terrible town play. If he's still alive tomorrow, then well I might revisit that.

Dude, don't say that. Let scum believe that you have an undying Townread on mail-mi and that leaving him alive won't present them with a decent mislynch.

[Jorbles]

ugh, I don't care is that was stupid on mail-mi's part. Doesn't mean hes scum in any way. Yuma voting for him after saying nothing could make him look at on-wagoners...thats scummy. Raerae, what don't you get about lynching someone who has posted about zero content.

What about my post was unclear?  I won't push this lynch through because I don't believe it's sound.  I think we're getting over excited because we (finally!) caught lurky scum for the first time since...what?  Buffy?  and the lurking was a secondary scum trait in that game...and we're going to make a mistake if we lynch Jimmmmm.  I really don't believe scum would be stupid enough to pull that twice.

That being said, he still does need to produce those promised reads.

I don't see anything redeeming in Jimmm's play though. Absence of helping town is good for scum, and if it makes him seem town in some people's minds that's a bonus for the scum team. Ugh, this lynch doesn't appear to be going through, but I still support it. I will switch back to this if it looks viable.

sparky has disappeared from this game, but he's also missing from another game and delaying its start. I think he's v/la, not sure if it was a planned v/la or something else. Has he been prodded? If he hasn't can we do that?

I am still okay with lynching Insomniac, so I'm switching back to that. I think there's a good chance his anger was faked and I think he's just playing a lurky scum tactic. I could see him doing this so he can coast in the early parts of a big game so he can wake up later and start participating when it's later in the game and no one will have to hold him accountable for anything but his lurkiness, which he'll be addressing by participating. Vote: Insomniac.

[Jorbles]

vote: mail-mi

I still think jimmmm is a good lynch but man that was really really bad.

Obvious play is obvious.

mail-mi's play seems bad enough that it was just terrible town play. If he's still alive tomorrow, then well I might revisit that.

Dude, don't say that. Let scum believe that you have an undying Townread on mail-mi and that leaving him alive won't present them with a decent mislynch.

Yeah, I guess you're right. Also hey it speaks!

I also didn't realize Jimmmm was actually so close to being lynched. (I thought he was still at L-4) I'm switching back to vote: Jimmmm.

[Robz888]

sparky has disappeared from this game, but he's also missing from another game and delaying its start. I think he's v/la, not sure if it was a planned v/la or something else. Has he been prodded? If he hasn't can we do that?

As best I can recall, he announced this V/LA ahead of time.

[ashersky]

Jimmmmm has until midnight tomorrow to contribute his promised reads, a deadline he himself proposed.  I say we just leave it at that.

Separately, unvote based on raerae's read, as I said I would.  Not that mcmc is free of suspicion now, but he's not D2's lynch.

I think mail-mi is just playing badly as town right now, and not intentionally as scum.

Jorbles seems scummy from recent comments, and could see a Jorbles lynch being a good one.  I don't like the "let's see if he lives through the night" comment at all, and his vote jumping with regards to Jimmmmm seems opportunistic ("oh, he was at L-2?  Gotta keep that chance going!").

vote: jorbles

[liopoil]

I'll actually be somewhat surprised if mail-mi gets NKed. Mail-mi, after your tests votes, do you mean to be voting for jimmmmm?  oh, and jorbles voting jimmmmm because he's close to lynched is scummy...

[mail-mi]

mail-mi, are you still voting for me intentionally?

Yeah, but you are seeming more towny now that your back. Vote: Insomniac

[Jorbles]

Jimmmmm has until midnight tomorrow to contribute his promised reads, a deadline he himself proposed.  I say we just leave it at that.

Separately, unvote based on raerae's read, as I said I would.  Not that mcmc is free of suspicion now, but he's not D2's lynch.

I think mail-mi is just playing badly as town right now, and not intentionally as scum.

Jorbles seems scummy from recent comments, and could see a Jorbles lynch being a good one.  I don't like the "let's see if he lives through the night" comment at all, and his vote jumping with regards to Jimmmmm seems opportunistic ("oh, he was at L-2?  Gotta keep that chance going!").

vote: jorbles

I knew someone was going to jump at that. I just didn't want to derail what I think is a good wagon, and thought it was better to stick it out even if I looked a bit scummy for it.