Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Robz888]

I'm highly tempted to vote for Arch. His explanation for that lie makes no sense whatsoever. It wasn't going to catch anyone, it was just going to cause confusion. Which is exactly what it did. Look way more like he said something he thought was smart, and then got caught in a lie.

But... well, I guess I'm just slightly more persuaded that Axxle is scum. The way he pounced on Jimm just a few posts ago actually seals it for me. He was scrambling.

[Archetype]

I'm warming up to the idea of lynching one of the cops tomorrow. I agree that we don't have enough information to start lynching our may-be cops left and right. It's just hard knowing that one of the two must be scum.

Other possible lynch canidates? Any ideas from the masons?

[Jimmmmm]

do you think scumJimm would be that brash though? His opinions are kind of controversial, and he isn't afraid of continuing to push the point even though he isn't getting much support.

Do you disagree that it's unlikely that we have two Orc-Cops?

Also, Arch's lie was weird. You can't argue with that. Obviously the two of you have to defend him since if either of you are Town you know that Arch is Town. And yeah, the fact that if Arch is scum then all three of you have to be scum makes it less likely. But it was weird.

I do think it's weird, although Axxle is/would be "just" a one-shot. I think one of them is likely to be scum, but do we have to decide today? If we do it tomorrow, we'll have more information we know to come from town (whether we lynch the right person or not).

I agree Arche's lie was weird, and I don't think it was good. But it wasn't the mafia-y kind of weird, what's your narrative for why he would have done it as scum? This is obviously completely redundant to me because I know Arche is town. He generally is the kind of guy who just always seems scummmy.

The narrative is he gets to lynch Axxle and no one's going to investigate him any more since they know he's going to investigate scum anyway. But you're right, it's still weird. I may have been a little over-excited before when I thought the game was solved, and I didn't want to let Arch wiggle his way out of his lie by just saying it was a Town lie. For the record, I wouldn't support an Arch lynch unless we knew both Axxle and Eevee were scum.

[Eevee]

Yeah, Robz. I think I just know Archetype is town and he is more valuable than me. If you want to lynch someone for not believing Archetype, vote for me. But I don't think you want to do that if you are town and actually take the time to think this through.

[Robz888]

Remember that the lesson of M-XIX is that there are always more cum players than you think.

[Robz888]

Remember that the lesson of M-XIX is that there are always more cum players than you think.

... and my new keyboard turns me into a smut writer....

[Robz888]

Yeah, Robz. I think I just know Archetype is town and he is more valuable than me. If you want to lynch someone for not believing Archetype, vote for me. But I don't think you want to do that if you are town and actually take the time to think this through.

Well, I did take the time to think it through, and yeah, you're right. His explanation just isn't good. That can happen--town can have bad explanations for their actions. It happens to me all the time.

So I would vote for Axxle at this point. I just don't know what the count is.

Unvote, though, because I'm voting for you right now.

[sudgy]

Remember that the lesson of M-XIX is that there are always more cum players than you think.

I don't know if ash would make that however...

[Eevee]

Players:
1.  Robz888 - Unknown, I could consider this lynch.
2.  Eevee - Archetype's guard. If I'm town, so is Arche. If Arche is scum, so am I.
3.  Mail-mi - Claimed half doctor.
4.  Jimmmmm - Unknown, I could consider this lynch.
5.  Jorbles - Claimed mason. I trust this claim.
6.  Archetype - Beloved elven princess.
7.  Morgrim7 - Orcish Hammerer - Devoured N1 - Dead mafia.
8.  WinterSpartan  - Unclaimed. Could be scum, but I like other unclaimants better.
9.  sudgy - Unclaimed, stuff with raerae.
10.  Kooshie - Masons with Jorbles.
11.  Destierro - Entish Faith Healer - Lynched D1
12.  raerae - claimed cop.
13.  Axxle - claimed town joat.


So, if we want to go for an alternate lynch, we could go sudgy like raerae wants us to, Robz or Jimmm (well, those are the ones I'd like).

[Jorbles]

G'night y'all. Bedtime 4 me.

Ditto, please don't lynch tonight. I mean I can't stop you, but I'd like things to calm down before the lynch.

[ashersky]

Vote Count 2.6:

Axxle (3): raerae, mail-mi, sudgy

Not Voting (8 ): Jorbles, Kooshie, WinterSpartan, Eevee, Archetype, Jimmmmm, Axxle, Robz888

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

D2 ends on march 31 at 10 p.m. forum time.

Check this to be sure you are recorded correctly.

You have 16 total days in the bank.  You will start using your banked time on March 22 at 10 p.m. Forum time.

[Eevee]

Yeah, no lynching anyone yet! Especially no acci-lynching Axxle. I'll be assuming it was a faked derphammer and thinking that person is scum.. unless the lynch hits scum. But yeah, no hammering, accidental or not! Need to work this out.

Robz, Archetype has been mislynched in EVERY GAME he has been town in. He just plays in a way that looks scummy to a lot of us. Seriously, ignoring the "feels scummy" vibe you always get from Arche, does it really make any sense?

[Robz888]

Yeah, no lynching anyone yet! Especially no acci-lynching Axxle. I'll be assuming it was a faked derphammer and thinking that person is scum.. unless the lynch hits scum. But yeah, no hammering, accidental or not! Need to work this out.

Robz, Archetype has been mislynched in EVERY GAME he has been town in. He just plays in a way that looks scummy to a lot of us. Seriously, ignoring the "feels scummy" vibe you always get from Arche, does it really make any sense?

Eevee! You and I are actually not disagreeing here. Yes, Archetype plays in a way that looks scummy, yes he does zany things that I always happen to find scummy. One of those, I do believe, was this little Miller fake out stunt he pulled, that was very stupid, and very suspicious, and his explanation is unconvincing. Am I willing to chalk it up to just being Archetype? Yes. So stop pushing me, you just make me think you two are scum and you're jumpy.

[Robz888]

Now that I've said it, it's harder to shake. Eevee and Archetype for scum?

[Eevee]

I'm not really concerned how I look to others at this point, really. Too excited trying to figure out who is lying and who is not!

We clearly don't see eye to eye though, as you are inclined to vote for Axxle. I don't want Axxle lynched today.

[Robz888]

It's this post I find scummy:

Seriously, we get results from their night actions if we give them more time. I think I'd actually prefer someone who hasn't claimed yet.

I don't know what to make of Jimmm.

Unvote
Sure.
Vote: Jimmm
Jimmm seems most likely to be raeraes partner since he's pushing me and Arch so hard.

Mostly because, I think Jimm's deductive process over the last few pages was pretty intuitive, like nothing earth shattering or weird about it. So this was a highly opportunistic vote that I find pretty baseless.

[Eevee]

I don't agree really, but I do think it's a good possibility Axxle is scum. It's just, if he is town, he probably has pretty good powers. If we decide between raerae and Axxle later (say tomorrow) ((is it ok to assume one of them likely is scum?)), we get TWO sets of night action results from confirmed townies after the lynch. Town is in pretty great shape at this point, as we've lost one player from both factions (and the sk is still out there, ofc).

Oh right, just in case people are forgetting. What explains last night's missing mafia kill better than me protecting Archetype? Robz, if you seriously think us both being scum is the most likely explanation for this (with Axxle too?), wow..

[Archetype]

What is your full role name, Eevee?

[sudgy]

I don't agree really, but I do think it's a good possibility Axxle is scum. It's just, if he is town, he probably has pretty good powers. If we decide between raerae and Axxle later (say tomorrow) ((is it ok to assume one of them likely is scum?)), we get TWO sets of night action results from confirmed townies after the lynch. Town is in pretty great shape at this point, as we've lost one player from both factions (and the sk is still out there, ofc).

Don't be certain that there's an sk.  We could be multiballing.

[Eevee]

What is your full role name, Eevee?

The Human Guard. I spent a lot of time in the militia, but I wouldnt have it any other way. You are the Beloved Elven Princess. I've only seen you once, in the woods. You were singing in the river, washing your her that sparkled like the sunlight, all that stuff. I swore my life to you. Bummed you still don't even know I exist!

[Robz888]

I don't agree really, but I do think it's a good possibility Axxle is scum. It's just, if he is town, he probably has pretty good powers. If we decide between raerae and Axxle later (say tomorrow) ((is it ok to assume one of them likely is scum?)), we get TWO sets of night action results from confirmed townies after the lynch. Town is in pretty great shape at this point, as we've lost one player from both factions (and the sk is still out there, ofc).

Oh right, just in case people are forgetting. What explains last night's missing mafia kill better than me protecting Archetype? Robz, if you seriously think us both being scum is the most likely explanation for this (with Axxle too?), wow..

Now is probably a good time to mention that I am, among other thing, a roleblocker. I roleblocked Axxle last night, based on my suspicion of him throughout Day 1.

[Eevee]

Two full scum teams would be really harsh with 13 players. Possible, but combined with the fact devouring just sounds so serial killery (two devourers!?), I'm just going to go with assuming it's a SK.

[Archetype]

Vote: Axxle

Eevee, that was paraphrased, right? 

[Eevee]

Oh, goody! I guess Axxle is scum then.. he claims he got an investigation result, when someone roleblocked would get "no result". So, either he is scum, you are scum, or you were in jail and couldnt roleblock?

[Eevee]

Vote: Axxle

Eevee, that was paraphrased, right? 

Yyeah (if I know what that word means). I don't know if flavor could come into play in this game (say someone else was present when I creeped you from the shadows too!), so I thought I'd tell some of the stuff I was told about you. Maybe I should have checked from the mods first, really sorry if that was too much.