Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Axxle]

Then lynch me, Jimmmmm.

That's rather unhelpful. I haven't suggested lynching you, I've suggested lynching Eevee. Worst case he flips Town and we know that you're Town who just made a silly gambit. I'm open to hearing reasons why it was pro-Town or something that a Townie would do.

He's pretty obviously town to me.  So he's town if I'm town.

[mail-mi]

If we have two scummy cops, then lynching the one-shot is better. Vote: Axxle

[Eevee]

Seriously, we get results from their night actions if we give them more time. I think I'd actually prefer someone who hasn't claimed yet.

I don't know what to make of Jimmm.

[Axxle]

Seriously, we get results from their night actions if we give them more time. I think I'd actually prefer someone who hasn't claimed yet.

I don't know what to make of Jimmm.

Unvote
Sure.
Vote: Jimmm
Jimmm seems most likely to be raeraes partner since he's pushing me and Arch so hard.

[Eevee]

do you think scumJimm would be that brash though? His opinions are kind of controversial, and he isn't afraid of continuing to push the point even though he isn't getting much support.

[Jorbles]

Whoa, so much has happened. Axxle's unpressured claim strikes me as far more likely to be true. raerae's claimed something a scum player would know to be true, and something that didn't give town any more info.

However, Axxle's lynch would let us know immediately if Archetype was telling the truth. Even though I'm more inclined to think raerae is scummy, Axxle's lynch might give us more useful info.

Personally I'd rather lynch raerae, though I understand the argument for lynching Axxle.

Can we get a vote count? It's been awhile.

[Axxle]

do you think scumJimm would be that brash though? His opinions are kind of controversial, and he isn't afraid of continuing to push the point even though he isn't getting much support.

They've already lost one member, so it's likely down to 2 of them + 1 sk, I think he'd do what he can to save his partner and then just use what you just said as a defense.  I don't really see an alternative at the moment.

[raerae]

How would I know we'd have a full Orc cop?

[Archetype]

Vote: Axxle

I think this is the right move, regardless of alignment.

If he flips Town, then Raerae most likely scum.
If he flips Scum, then Raerae is going to be Town.

I can't quite decide if Axxle's scum or not. I had that wagon going on him D1, but he came off Towny from it. But JOAT seems like a convenient claim way to wiggle out of any situation, and an obscure Dwarf claim is scummy too.

But yet he seems SO Towny, but I think his lynch would be the most informational. It'll probably make me worse off if he flips scum, but I don't really care.

[Archetype]

Has someone checked Morgrim's interactions D1? IIRC, there aren't any notable ones.

[mail-mi]

do you think scumJimm would be that brash though? His opinions are kind of controversial, and he isn't afraid of continuing to push the point even though he isn't getting much support.

Maybe. She could be his only partner (left or total, take ur pick)

But she and Axxle are still scummier. And Acxle has said he's already used his one-shot, so yeah.

[Eevee]

Why don't we want our potential power roles working for one more night?

I generally think scum is a bit too afraid to strongly defend their partner the way jimm is defending raerae now.

[sudgy]

Actually, I'm going to Vote: Axxle too.  While I think raerae is more likely to be scum, if she's town she is more valuable than Axxle.

[Jorbles]

Has someone checked Morgrim's interactions D1? IIRC, there aren't any notable ones.

I checked them and that's the conclusion I came to.

[Jimmmmm]

do you think scumJimm would be that brash though? His opinions are kind of controversial, and he isn't afraid of continuing to push the point even though he isn't getting much support.

Do you disagree that it's unlikely that we have two Orc-Cops?

Also, Arch's lie was weird. You can't argue with that. Obviously the two of you have to defend him since if either of you are Town you know that Arch is Town. And yeah, the fact that if Arch is scum then all three of you have to be scum makes it less likely. But it was weird.

[Eevee]

axxle still has other one-shots we could really use.

[Archetype]

If Axxle's Town.

[Axxle]

How would I know we'd have a full Orc cop?

This is a good point
Unvote

[Jorbles]

Seriously can we get a vote count? Or at least work out what Axxle is at before any more votes happen?

[Axxle]

axxle still has other one-shots we could really use.

This. I some might be even more useful than a cop.

[Archetype]

I'll unvote for now.

Good night all, will need to review this with fresh eyes.

[Eevee]

do you think scumJimm would be that brash though? His opinions are kind of controversial, and he isn't afraid of continuing to push the point even though he isn't getting much support.

Do you disagree that it's unlikely that we have two Orc-Cops?

Also, Arch's lie was weird. You can't argue with that. Obviously the two of you have to defend him since if either of you are Town you know that Arch is Town. And yeah, the fact that if Arch is scum then all three of you have to be scum makes it less likely. But it was weird.

I do think it's weird, although Axxle is/would be "just" a one-shot. I think one of them is likely to be scum, but do we have to decide today? If we do it tomorrow, we'll have more information we know to come from town (whether we lynch the right person or not).

I agree Arche's lie was weird, and I don't think it was good. But it wasn't the mafia-y kind of weird, what's your narrative for why he would have done it as scum? This is obviously completely redundant to me because I know Arche is town. He generally is the kind of guy who just always seems scummmy.

[Robz888]

Just caught up, this is all insanity.

[mail-mi]

G'night y'all. Bedtime 4 me.

[Eevee]

Just caught up, this is all insanity.

Opinions! I'm still up.