Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Ozle]

So, been meaning to do this for a while...

The plan.

Nominate Categories in the thread below.
Then once they are sorted this thread gets locked.
People can then send me nominations for options in all the categories, I will pick the most popular ones and put them up as votes.
Polls will close at Christmas.

Potential Cats:

Best Overall Player
Best Mod
Best Game
Best Mafia
Best Townie
Most Effective Use of a Power Role
Most like to Lynch
Funniest Player
Best made up Role Claim
Best Role
Worst Role
Worst Made up Role
Best Non-Mafia Game
Best In-Game Moment
Best Third-Party Player (SK, Cult Variant, etc.)
Best Bastard Game
Best Set of Night Actions
Biggest Scumslip
Funniest QT topic
Best Flavour
Most Balanced Game
Most Fun Game
Most Intense Game
Best Newbie performance
Scumhunter of the Year

[Captain_Frisk]

Nominate self for all.

[Ozle]

Nominate self for all.

Nominating Cat's at the moment....duuuh

[Captain_Frisk]

Except for best in game moment, which is a close one between eHunt kickball and something that can't be discussed yet.

[Captain_Frisk]

I make my own rules Ozle.  You know this.

[Ozle]

I make my own rules Ozle.  You know this.

I know this, but you should also know I ignore your rules with disdain!

[Eevee]

Really nice idea.

[Captain_Frisk]

Additional categories:

Worst made up role claim
Worst Role


Most of the other "razzies" would be offensive.

[Dsell]

This is so cool!

[Galzria]

Worst made up role claim

Dayvig: Cayvie

Done.

[Voltgloss]

Best Third-Party Player (SK, Cult Variant, etc.)
Best Bastard Game
Best Set of Night Actions
Most Effective Use of a Vanilla Role
"Best" Scumslip

(that last one is a razzie but is offered more for mutual hilarity purposes than to be offensive)

[Robz888]

Excellent idea, Ozle!

[Voltgloss]

Also, "Best Set of Night Actions" means something like, "most ironic set of dueling actions on Night X in Game Y."  Example:  the first no-kill night in M-IV.

[Galzria]

CF wins in a landslide for best scumslip.

"I promise if you lynch me, I have 0% chance of flipping town".

[Voltgloss]

CF wins in a landslide for best scumslip.

"I promise if you lynch me, I have 0% chance of flipping town".

Well, yes, that was the one I had in mind but surely there are SOME competing slips in our collective history 

[Robz888]

Also, "Best Set of Night Actions" means something like, "most ironic set of dueling actions on Night X in Game Y."  Example:  the first no-kill night in M-IV.

I think MVI's Mafia Roleblocker eHalcyon (whose power fails against Werewolves) roleblocking Werewolf Jack-of-All-Trades Robz, who investigates eHalcyon, and dooms them both upon the reveal, is a contender there.

[SwitchedFromStarcraft]

Funniest comment in Mafia QT
Funniest comment in Spectator QT

[Voltgloss]

Funniest comment in Third-Party QT
Funniest comment in Modchat QT

[Ozle]

Save the actual instances for the actual polling side, just keep it to Categories here please!

[Voltgloss]

Best Flavour
Most Balanced Game
Most Fun Game
Most Intense Game

[Galzria]

Save the actual instances for the actual polling side, just keep it to Categories here please!

Well, but wouldn't help if in the categories of "events", people had reminders to choose from when casting their votes?

Edit: Nevermind. I missed a step in your process.

[Ozle]

Im trying to condense a few here otherwise we'll have hundreds of spamming posts (And we'd need yet another seperate forum!)

Planning to have the cats done in a week or so.

All nominations in by end of November, and then actual voting in December with the results announced at the end of the year

[Captain_Frisk]

Worst made up role claim

Dayvig: Cayvie

Done.

No talking about active games!

[Ozle]

Save the actual instances for the actual polling side, just keep it to Categories here please!

Well, but wouldn't help if in the categories of "events", people had reminders to choose from when casting their votes?

It would, but I think its a bit uneeded, we got hundreds already.

plus I would rather it didnt bias peoples thinking when it comes to nominations!

[Ozle]

Best Newbie performance

[Insomniac]

Best Mafia Pair
Best Mafia Triple
Best PR (Player and the game it was)

[Voltgloss]

Funniest Comment in PM to Mod
Best Trolling

[Ozle]

As I guide I think we want Cats than can produce about 8 different GOOD options, but obviously not set in stone

[Voltgloss]

Most Impressive Self-Destruction

(this is on the razzie side too - again, the idea here is humor value, nothing mean-spirited)

[Insomniac]

Most Impressive Self-Destruction

(this is on the razzie side too - again, the idea here is humor value, nothing mean-spirited)

 

[Voltgloss]

Most Impressive Self-Destruction

(this is on the razzie side too - again, the idea here is humor value, nothing mean-spirited)

 

Actually, my personal #1 pick here isn't from any ongoing games.

[Robz888]

Category: Worst Use of Power Role by a Robz888

Entries: Self-Incriminating Roleblocking in MVI; No effect Jailkeeping in MVII; Useless, untrustworthy, and outright incorrect Tracking in M-XII; Unused Investigation in M-XIV; Doctor Death in Blitz3.

[Glooble]

Most Bastardly role in a setup has a lot of good contenders:

The seer in a game with no werewolves, even-night doctor/ odd-night SK, a cult called the Serial Killers, etc.

[Young Nick]

Best/Funniest Twilight (Trolling).

[cayvie]

are the awards like Best Mafia, Best Townie etc supposed to be for an individual performance in a single game, or for a player's overall performance across possibly multiple games?

[Morgrim7]

Great idea, Ozle!

[ehunt]

Most Inexplicable Hammer Behavior

[jotheonah]

Best Self-vote

Best Coincidence (for any awesomely ironic action that the person taking it could not have realized would be ironic at the time)

[jotheonah]

Best unrealized setup idea

[Grujah]

Best Drunk Post.

Best Newbie/Rookie.

[jotheonah]

Best Accurate Tunneling
Best Erroneous Tunneling

[Ozle]

Haha, a lotof niche suggestions!

[Grujah]

Best replacement.

[Axxle]

Worst modflake.  I'm sure I can win that one.  (unless it's mafia only)

[eHalcyon]

More threads I didn't know about!  The forum split has shaken some things loose...

[cayvie]

Except for best in game moment, which is a close one between eHunt kickball and something that can't be discussed yet.

can it be discussed yet?

[Ozle]

Will sort out the topic and accept nominations for each one this coming weekend.

[cayvie]

can we do public talking about nominations for categories?

[cayvie]

to be clear, i'm not asking permission, i'm suggesting that as the default method.

[Ozle]

can we do public talking about nominations for categories?

Not really, I want to keep that for the voting stage really.

I dont want the voting stage to be a foregone conclusion.


(clicked modify instead of quote first time round, didnt realise I was a mod!)

[jotheonah]

Ozle's a mod now whut

[Eevee]

World just got so much scarier. Please don't punish me, Ozle!

[shraeye]

blah

[Captain_Frisk]

This is where we can self vote and not be anti-town, right?

[shraeye]

This is where we can self vote and not be anti-town, right?

Wait, I thought self-voting was a strong town strategy.  You mean to say that it isn't??

[Insomniac]

Scumhunter of the Year (Player and game)

[Axxle]

Nominate: eHalcyon for Most Effective Use of a Power Role as Jailkeeper in Mafia III

(or are we not doing these yet?)

[Galzria]

Nominate: eHalcyon for Most Effective Use of a Power Role as Jailkeeper in Mafia III

(or are we not doing these yet?)

Not yet. And when we do, they are privately sent to Ozle who will compile them and place the top X number in a poll for that category. At that point we'll all vote.

[cayvie]

Nominate: eHalcyon for Most Effective Use of a Power Role as Jailkeeper in Mafia III

(or are we not doing these yet?)

hehe

mafiascum

[eHalcyon]

Nominate: eHalcyon for Most Effective Use of a Power Role as Jailkeeper in Mafia III

(or are we not doing these yet?)

Flattered! I think there was also some good doctoring or something by PPS in the second game I played, modded by O? But I wasn't paying as much attention by the end there.

[Dsell]

Nominate: eHalcyon for Most Effective Use of a Power Role as Jailkeeper in Mafia III

(or are we not doing these yet?)

Flattered! I think there was also some good doctoring or something by PPS in the second game I played, modded by O? But I wasn't paying as much attention by the end there.

Yeah that was definitely impressive, also impressive was Timchen using his 1-shot seer on the last remaining werewolf.

[yuma]

bump

[Ozle]

Bumping a sticky thread?

[yuma]

Bumping a sticky thread?

so it goes to my e-mail

[Insomniac]

Anticipation.