Okay, surprised to see no one suspecting me. Have I been so lurky you don't even remember I'm playing or what is it?
Anyways, now that I'm here, my thoughts on everyone. If I don't remember someone, it probably means he hasn't said anything memorable and should post more / more content.
Morgrim: I agree he has played very scummy, but in my re-read way back I concluded it doesn't look like the mafia kind of scummy. Wouldn't vote today.
Galzria: Dsell's case is the kind we should pursue more often day 1, I think. I would be ok with a Galz lynch, I'm not overly joyous about it because I think he could be a big town asset later.
Dsell: Town read, general good feeling. Possibly subconsciously rewarding him for the Galzria-case I like. Wouldn't vote.
eHalcyon: Looks different than the eHalcyon I know, but I don't have anything concrete. I disagree with him a lot which is new, but doesn't mean we can't be from the same faction.
ehunt: Again very different than the ehunt I know. My usual "wouldn't want to draw this much attention as town" doesn't apply here imo, because he didn't really want to be this active, he sort of got sucked into it because he got suspected so early.
Volt/sparky: I don't think subbing out or promising a case but never delivering are scum- or towntells, so pretty much a noread, maybe slight town bias. I think I read sparky better than Volt, so hopefully this will change.
Glooble: Much like the scum-Glooble I know. Would vote today.
Grujah: Is currently lurky in other games as well, but so was Frisk when he was scum in multiple games at the same time. I still have the same scum read I had earlier.
Axxle: Also a scum read, not because of the doublevoter business, but because I felt the reasons for voting ehunt were sort of flimsy and felt fabricated. Feels he made it seem like I was more sure of my vote on ehunt than I actually was, might be a misunderstanding though. Would vote.
yuma: Town read, but again I might be rewarding him for his work on the deadline-ideas. Wouldn't vote.
Frisk: Slight scum read maybe, hasn't done anything particularly towny and generally avoids the attention much like scum Frisk always does.
ftl: Is somehow always a no-read for me. Would vote I guess, but I should work on remembering you better.
Watno: Looks sort of scummy, but I wonder if it's too much of the "obvious kind" of scummy. He feels much like our usual day 1 lynch target. Would vote though, but not overly happy about it.
TheMunch: Got grilled more than he deserved I think (or rather for wrong reasons). I generally don't have a town read on him, but I think he came out okay from the eHalc and Watno - incidents. Would maybe be willing to vote for him, but can't quite put my finger on why.
ashersky: Hasn't said much anything, suspicious like all other lurkers.
Insomniac: I can't help but always see Ins scummy, so don't really know. Maybe more vocal than he would be if scum?
O: Opposite of Ins, I seem to have a town-bias on O. Wouldn't vote today.
Jotheonah: With that level of activity, should be signaling more town to me I think. Don't really know, KACEOY.
shraeye: Not like the shraeye I was expecting, and I didn't like the attitude much, especially earlier (who likes to be called stupid repeatedly), but faced some pressure and didn't crack or anything like that.
cayvie: Posts a lot without ever saying anything. I have a huge town bias on her, but here I actually think she looks rather scummy. The thing about not wanting to be a part of town wagons reads towny to me though.
Young_Nick: Slight scum read fornot being helpful. Doesn't seem paranoid about appearing lazy/useless though. And I know there is a lot to read, but we have excellent summaries.
Voltaire: Plays like I would expect scum Volt to. Slight scum read.
igbtennis: I don't know how much slack I'm supposed to cut him for being new. Would support his lynch for staying in the back and not contributing but it's got to be pretty hard to keep track of stuff in a town this big when you don't know anyone in advance.
Cuzz: I suspected him some in MX for this same playstyle, so he is definitely one of the guys that always seem scummy to me. That being said, would vote.
Before anyone attacks me for being vague and making a long useless list, it's very hard to come back to this thread after not being around when you guys produce 7 pages, I felt this was the best way to do it. It's very vague because so are my opinions atm, I feel day1 doesn't have much to offer to us anymore and quite frankly am happy it's coming to and end.
Oh, and I've been wondering if I should say this or not since cayvie's post but no I will. My role has a thing about being on wagons too (and the reason cayvie's reads towny to me is that I know I'm town and I too have one). Mine is that it's very good to me to be a part of scum lynch wagon, so expect to see me participate in the lynch even if it's on a town read of mine, especially if it seems to be happening anyways.
Vote: Axxle
2nd would be Grujah
3rd Glooble.
ehunt vote was maybe outdated. But yeah, I'll be somehow making sure I end up on the lynch wagon in the end, just a heads up. It won't be an O-like quickhammer though, don't worry.
Author
Topic: Mafia XI: Find Yourself in the Courtyard Masquerade -- GAME OVER, TOWN WINS (Read 321046 times)