Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Swowl]

also in the world where I am just dead wrong, quickhammer potential - did not think about that... we only need 4 to lynch here.

How likely does it seem that scum used the flip to cancel V powers last night? Otherwise we don't have to work about quickhammers

I have an opinion on this, and just the switch concept in general... and I stand by it... being prettyyyyy sure I have thought it through all the way... not just now, but like back in pre game.

Is this really something you want people to speculate about currently... out loud... before we know what roles we have at our disposal?

[Swowl]

Hi friends!!

So, e is scum, yeah?

Nope

there he is!
I have been waiting 2 days to ask you this...

Who is skum, E!?

[2.71828.....]

But I don't see how any other Lynch happens.

Scum won this game lurking and bussing.

Dylan was active, and in his activity did things I picked out as scummy
Mail-mi was active, same thing.

LaLight was just as absent as I was D1, except instead of showing up to hammer, they just...existed on the wagon
Then D2/D3 they just hang out and sheep reads.

Say what you want about my D2/D3 reads that ended going horribly wrong, but they do not happen when I am scum.

Which will probably take a flip for everyone to see, likely just GG scum

[2.71828.....]

Hi friends!!

So, e is scum, yeah?

Nope

there he is!
I have been waiting 2 days to ask you this...

Who is skum, E!?

Did you even read day 2?

[2.71828.....]

Sorry, day 3

[2.71828.....]

OK so in the world where you are town, pretend for a moment that MM is town. So you are both town. So no teams allowed that include yourself of MM. Where is skum at?

This means there are two scum in:
Swowl
ADK
WCD
Yuma
LaLight
Calamitas

I take ADK off the table right away. Unchallenged UB claim is IC. Even if converted to a restless spirit the UB is not notified of that, so they still think they are the UB until proven otherwise.

Which leaves us with two scum in:
Swowl
Yuma
Calamitas
WCD
LaLight

- Calamitas has had their name thrown around as scum a lot, but nothing has really stuck. Scum partner protecting? Or just when people look at their whole game they read town? I fall in the second category. There were a few knee-jerk things that made me think scum, but their whole game has been town. In a large amount of posts, something will hit you the wrong way. Bound to happen. But looking past that, I think there game points to very strong town, especially the integral part in lynching Joseph.

- WCD has not had her best game, but I don't think that implies scum. Her most recent post that attracted criticism I think kind of sums up her game: she is either "lazy" (for lack of a better word) town, or lurking scum. She has had a few posts with an AtE element (see D1 reaction), and really the decision is if it was faked or real. Could go either way, coin flip. 1 is scum, 2 is town. This dice roll may have been tampered with!
Rolled 1d2 : 2, total 2

Yuma - bursts of energy in posting, then silence. Different question than WCD here - are those bursts town trying to catch up, or scum trying to appear "helpful." Again, flip a coin This dice roll may have been tampered with!
Rolled 1d2 : 2, total 2

LaLight is the only one that I went through earlier and landed on as scum. You can see the case above. If I take out mail-mi, I think PoE even more than before lands me on scum!LaLight

Swowl - when I did my reread earlier I landed town here. I will keep it there. Reference reply #710

So if mail-mi isn't scum, I think it is likely LaLight, {Yuma, WCD} as scum.

The choice between Yuma and WCD should be put off until more flips + claims happen.

[2.71828.....]

Remember this big long post? Or did you miss it?

[2.71828.....]

Also, if the whole UB conversion stuff doesn't happen like I thought it did, I am calling it now: townslip

[2.71828.....]

For me

[Swowl]

ADK - care to set a claim order?

Like not that we need to do it right now... but you know, as long as you are still around and all. Probably the best way to establish one in case it happens.

[Swowl]

Also, if the whole UB conversion stuff doesn't happen like I thought it did, I am calling it now: townslip

I think LL is right. It makes the most sense. How did you think it happened?

[2.71828.....]

And, at this point, Yuma is my choice for scum over WCD by a lot

[Swowl]

Remember this big long post? Or did you miss it?

remember indeed. just making sure nothing had changed.

[2.71828.....]

Remember this big long post? Or did you miss it?

remember indeed. just making sure nothing had changed.

I mean, it does warrant looking at again. Like, I think scum was on mail-mi pretty early with me and didn't leave. (Or left and went back (LaLight, anyone)

[2.71828.....]

But really, we were working mislynch vs. mislynch vs. mislynch all of D2/D3.

Scum could sit back and relax.  Looking for acti-lurkers here (Yuma, anyone)

[Swowl]

Remember this big long post? Or did you miss it?

remember indeed. just making sure nothing had changed.

I mean, it does warrant looking at again. Like, I think scum was on mail-mi pretty early with me and didn't leave. (Or left and went back (LaLight, anyone)

so you are gonna have to bear with me here because I still think you are skum... but i will play for a minute...

If you are town, and MM flipped town... why does skum have to be early on MM with you? those are split "town wagons" in that scenario. If I thought you were town, I would be more inclined to look at flippy-floppy players as opposed to ones that came on with you and didn't leave.

[Swowl]

But really, we were working mislynch vs. mislynch vs. mislynch all of D2/D3.

Scum could sit back and relax.  Looking for acti-lurkers here (Yuma, anyone)

I mean that means there was a HELL of a day 1 bus. Do you really think that is that likely? Considering you hammered right? so If you are town that means they all went there or sat there knowing all these town players could just hammer for the day 1 lynch. how does that like... make sense?

[2.71828.....]

But really, we were working mislynch vs. mislynch vs. mislynch all of D2/D3.

Scum could sit back and relax.  Looking for acti-lurkers here (Yuma, anyone)

I mean that means there was a HELL of a day 1 bus. Do you really think that is that likely? Considering you hammered right? so If you are town that means they all went there or sat there knowing all these town players could just hammer for the day 1 lynch. how does that like... make sense?

Look at LaLight's last post for D1. Look at how many votes were on Joseph at the time.

They never meant to bus like they did, but will take the town cred for it

[2.71828.....]

But really, we were working mislynch vs. mislynch vs. mislynch all of D2/D3.

Scum could sit back and relax.  Looking for acti-lurkers here (Yuma, anyone)

I mean that means there was a HELL of a day 1 bus. Do you really think that is that likely? Considering you hammered right? so If you are town that means they all went there or sat there knowing all these town players could just hammer for the day 1 lynch. how does that like... make sense?

I think my vote and Yuma's vote both make sense for scum.

But not for us if we are scum together

[2.71828.....]

But really, we were working mislynch vs. mislynch vs. mislynch all of D2/D3.

Scum could sit back and relax.  Looking for acti-lurkers here (Yuma, anyone)

I mean that means there was a HELL of a day 1 bus. Do you really think that is that likely? Considering you hammered right? so If you are town that means they all went there or sat there knowing all these town players could just hammer for the day 1 lynch. how does that like... make sense?

It doesn't back then. But it sure does now

[2.71828.....]

And if we are looking for evil scum geniuses ....

LaLight and Yuma, anyone?

[Swowl]

so your current working theory is ... LL got stuck, took the cred, and then Yuma decided to L1 Joseph ... also for cred?

[2.71828.....]

so your current working theory is ... LL got stuck, took the cred, and then Yuma decided to L1 Joseph ... also for cred?

Yeah, sounds right

[2.71828.....]

Day 1 Final Vote Count

Joseph2302 (7): A Drowned Kernel, LaLight, WestCoastDidds, Calamitas, scolapasta, yuma, 2.71828.....
scolapasta (3): Dylan32, mail-mi, Swowl
2.71828..... (1): SpaceAnemone
WestCoastDidds (1): Joseph2302

Not Voting (0):

With 12 alive, it took 7 to lynch. Twilight begins now and lasts until May 24, 2020, 03:30:00 pm.

Or swowl is scum

[2.71828.....]

So I don't get why you seem to be pressing back in the idea