Throughout the game LaLight had very few interactions with joth and Dylan. He expressed scumread on various people (mcmc, ash, ss, faust off the top of my head). Here are the grand total of interactions from LaLight's perspective that I could find:
Just LaLight responding to their posts. I don't think they are meaningful one way or another. Only included for completeness.
LaLight's posts about joth:
for some reasons I can't put my finger on Joth. He reads townie, but I don't know, can't feel him
I think it’s mcmc and joth.
when you'll see mcmc/joth team you'll be like "LaLight told us but we were not listening!"
I am all in for voting joth
vote: mcmc
---snip---
this is just a last minute bussing
vote: joth L-1 is my input
There is a single short post on joth for the entire game until Day 4 when he developed a scum read on him for no explained reason. Granted it was early in the Day, but I think the writing was very much on the wall that after they failed to lynch me joth was going to be next. LaLight was already their last hope so he had to bus.
About Dylan:
Looking at what seem to have been the major lynch candidates, I think mcmc and Dylan are scummyish and DatSwan is Towny.
Is it possible it is a partner call? Jimmmmm/mcmc//Jimmmmm/Dylan?
...
Given that Jimmmmm never lynched both as soon as I can see
I am null on Dylan, and I don't like the two votes on him. Let's sheep faust, vote: silverspawn
The game started on December 13. Between then and January 4, the grand total of reads LaLight had expressed on joth or Dylan were "for some reasons I can't put my finger on Joth. He reads townie, but I don't know, can't feel him", "I am null on Dylan, and I don't like the two votes on him." and "Is it possible it is a partner call? Jimmmmm/mcmc//Jimmmmm/Dylan?".
vote: no lynch
I don’t really believe Dylan, but i still would not put beyond faust and DS the gambit they would play. As much as i believe they are masons i would like to see the confirmation. I’ve been fooled like this all too many times.
This post was about 24 hours after Dylan's claim, so the closest to a reaction we've got.
mcmc, LL, UoS: What was your first instinct/reaction to Dylan's claim?
Well, my initial reaction was I believed it but then nothing really came together so I didn't in the end
Now, about a week and a new Game Day after the claim, his story has changed. Despite a claimed Cop result, the rest of LaLight's posts that Day are about whether or not to believe the Masons. His total contribution to the Dylan/me situation was "I don’t really believe Dylan (but let's talk about the Masons instead)".
But all you did was vote no vote. You never expressed any interest in either Dylan or Jimm. And you were the only person sitting on the no lynch train all day
Yes. I would vote Dylan after a no lynch day. I see why you didn't want to no lynch, I had it in me that I didn't believe you 100%
vote: no lynch
I don’t really believe Dylan, but i still would not put beyond faust and DS the gambit they would play. As much as i believe they are masons i would like to see the confirmation. I’ve been fooled like this all too many times.
This. I didn't really believe Dylan.
After that voting for him would be hammering and it wasn't late in the day. I was unavailable then, we had state holidays till 8th
Now, after saying he initially believed Dylan, he goes back to saying he didn't believe him. Again, this is after the Dylan flip, and of course it's important given how close Dylan and joth were to distance himself from them.
mcmc, LL, UoS: What was your first instinct/reaction to Dylan's claim?
Mine was that it was statistically extremely unlikely that Dylan and Faust and swan were all town, and that what made the most sense was Dylan being scum however no lynching and seeing faust flip mason would have made me more comfortable.
Exactly
Now he agrees exactly with mcmc (his biggest scumread) to help explain how he supposedly felt about the Dylan claim. And yet, he himself said "Well, my initial reaction was I believed it."