Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LaLight]

ok then. I have no slightest idea what's going on, but scum wins this one I guess.

[LaLight]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

[LaLight]

vote: Hydrad

[LaLight]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

usually I just claim stuff asap and people see I am town, this is impossible with this role

[Galzria]

Can't really work your way out of this one, sorry LaLight.

Robz and I can't be scum together, because the game would be over.

A) I would have my sword, stolen from Mcmc, and there would've been extra kills.

B) 2v2, even with a Spirit, would be endgame - unless I'm wrong and EFHW counts as a person in a 1v1 end game scenario - which would be weird, as there are very clearly 4 alive, not 5. Even if we were scum and you lynched one of us, one of you would then die at night (well, both, because again - sword), thus leaving 1v1 at best for you.

C) I can't be scum solo, because the day Robz told me in our QT that he was a traitor I would've said "Hey great, I'm scum bro!". No scenario where scum!me lets scum!Robz turn himself town.

D) If I can't be scum with Robz (game over already), and I can't be scum solo (see above), then I can't be scum. Plus, also, you know, duh

 

A) I totally forgot about sword. But wait, if you fakeclaim, you can't use the sword and there won't be extrakills.

B) I don't know why you think game would be over, EFHW has her vote.

C) Who knows what you told him? If you're both scum, you're both scum.

A) You're not going to reasonably argue that I've fake claimed flavor at this point. Not to mention your argument would hinge on the item, which clearly belongs to me, that I knew existed on D1, would serve no purpose this game as Mcmc couldn't use it, and no other player has claimed or flipped Samurai.

B) It's very clear why this would be assumed. She's not a living player, and thus can only vote while the game is ongoing. Put another way - assume she's scum - if all other scum are lynched and there are 2 town left, would the game continue? They could still vote each other and she could hammer. No, of course not. That's silly. Dead players are dead. Just because she can vote doesn't make her a factor in this.

C) Again, can't both be scum - the game would be over.

[LaLight]

Mod Question: if a person puts up disguise and gets lunched, do we see a disguise or his/her actual role?

[LaLight]

lunched

Dinnered obviously

[Galzria]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

Your result for N1, while correct, was arbitrary. If nobody had claimed to target Robz, you easily could've suggested that scum (Gkrieg here) must've stolen from Robz N1 or targeted him in some fashion (RB, RC, JK, anything).

N3 I'm guessing you stole from Mcmc for two reasons:

A) To get the sword. Definitely the right play here. Don't want that falling into hands that can use it.

B) To safely check whether I commuted without wasting your kill on the possibility that I could/did.

[Galzria]

lunched

I'm more of a second breakfast type person.
Dinnered obviously

[Galzria]

lunched

Dinnered obviously

I'm more of a second breakfast type person.

And I'm obviously very bad at quoting.

[LaLight]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

Your result for N1, while correct, was arbitrary. If nobody had claimed to target Robz, you easily could've suggested that scum (Gkrieg here) must've stolen from Robz N1 or targeted him in some fashion (RB, RC, JK, anything).

N3 I'm guessing you stole from Mcmc for two reasons:

A) To get the sword. Definitely the right play here. Don't want that falling into hands that can use it.

B) To safely check whether I commuted without wasting your kill on the possibility that I could/did.

question is why nothing was stolen before N3.

Also explain, how all my targets made sense from scum!perspective? I md'ed Robz then Haddock, then mcmc, then faust then Hydrad. Those were my scumreads.

[Galzria]

ok then. I have no slightest idea what's going on, but scum wins this one I guess.

If that's the case, then that's unfortunate. Although well played. Things will have needed to play out quite well for them though, and I'll be quite excited to see all the post game stuff.

[LaLight]

ok then. I have no slightest idea what's going on, but scum wins this one I guess.

Things will have needed to play out quite well for them though

yeah, just people voting for me :/

[LaLight]

I mean can you just believe me? Hydrad claimed he has no abilities whatsoever other than 1-shot Bulletproof Item, can this even be the case in RMM?

[Galzria]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

Your result for N1, while correct, was arbitrary. If nobody had claimed to target Robz, you easily could've suggested that scum (Gkrieg here) must've stolen from Robz N1 or targeted him in some fashion (RB, RC, JK, anything).

N3 I'm guessing you stole from Mcmc for two reasons:

A) To get the sword. Definitely the right play here. Don't want that falling into hands that can use it.

B) To safely check whether I commuted without wasting your kill on the possibility that I could/did.

question is why nothing was stolen before N3.

Also explain, how all my targets made sense from scum!perspective? I md'ed Robz then Haddock, then mcmc, then faust then Hydrad. Those were my scumreads.

Robz & Haddock didn't have items. N1, N2. Mcmc had his items stolen. N3. Faust had his items stolen. N4.

Your claimed MD targets match perfectly with potential thievery. And you're never wrong about Motion around said players.

[LaLight]

he can be a ninja stealer

[LaLight]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

Your result for N1, while correct, was arbitrary. If nobody had claimed to target Robz, you easily could've suggested that scum (Gkrieg here) must've stolen from Robz N1 or targeted him in some fashion (RB, RC, JK, anything).

N3 I'm guessing you stole from Mcmc for two reasons:

A) To get the sword. Definitely the right play here. Don't want that falling into hands that can use it.

B) To safely check whether I commuted without wasting your kill on the possibility that I could/did.

question is why nothing was stolen before N3.

Also explain, how all my targets made sense from scum!perspective? I md'ed Robz then Haddock, then mcmc, then faust then Hydrad. Those were my scumreads.

Robz & Haddock didn't have items. N1, N2. Mcmc had his items stolen. N3. Faust had his items stolen. N4.

Your claimed MD targets match perfectly with potential thievery. And you're never wrong about Motion around said players.

Of course I am never wrong, this is my role, mod doesn't lie.

How exactly dumb should I be to claim my own stealing targets if I am the stealer?

[Galzria]

I mean can you just believe me? Hydrad claimed he has no abilities whatsoever other than 1-shot Bulletproof Item, can this even be the case in RMM?

He's claimed Miller. Not exactly a great defense for him, but still. It's a role.

[LaLight]

I mean sometimes I really didn't want to claim my targets because I thought that would put me into the scummy light :/ but i never lied

[LaLight]

I mean can you just believe me? Hydrad claimed he has no abilities whatsoever other than 1-shot Bulletproof Item, can this even be the case in RMM?

He's claimed Miller. Not exactly a great defense for him, but still. It's a role.

We don't have a cop.

[LaLight]

you want to tell me the only usage of his role would be if IDPTG targeted him? Really?

[Galzria]

no result was also because of anything that can go on in this game. who steals stuff and why on N3? How did my result be exact on N1?

Your result for N1, while correct, was arbitrary. If nobody had claimed to target Robz, you easily could've suggested that scum (Gkrieg here) must've stolen from Robz N1 or targeted him in some fashion (RB, RC, JK, anything).

N3 I'm guessing you stole from Mcmc for two reasons:

A) To get the sword. Definitely the right play here. Don't want that falling into hands that can use it.

B) To safely check whether I commuted without wasting your kill on the possibility that I could/did.

question is why nothing was stolen before N3.

Also explain, how all my targets made sense from scum!perspective? I md'ed Robz then Haddock, then mcmc, then faust then Hydrad. Those were my scumreads.

Robz & Haddock didn't have items. N1, N2. Mcmc had his items stolen. N3. Faust had his items stolen. N4.

Your claimed MD targets match perfectly with potential thievery. And you're never wrong about Motion around said players.

Of course I am never wrong, this is my role, mod doesn't lie.

How exactly dumb should I be to claim my own stealing targets if I am the stealer?

Only kind of. Had you claimed motion elsewhere (or none), you ran the risk of being called out ("Actually, I DID take an action last night" or "That's weird, how can there be motion when nobody targeted said player")

Also, it's hard to really argue those were your scum reads. Look at your voting history through D4:

Hydrad, Mcmc, faust, faust, Gkrieg, faust, Robz, PPS, faust, IDPTG, faust, faust, Gkrieg, faust, Gkrieg

No votes Robz D1, or Haddock D1 or D2. And while you had a single vote on Mcmc D1, it would've been silly to MD him as a scum read D3 when you knew he was IC'ing himself (or not) D4. I mean, why would you target someone to check for motion that you knew was going to be using an item and creating motion? Like, what did you hope to learn here?

Whereas it makes sense that you were stealing the sword...

[Galzria]

you want to tell me the only usage of his role would be if IDPTG targeted him? Really?

Swan.

[Galzria]

I mean sometimes I really didn't want to claim my targets because I thought that would put me into the scummy light :/ but i never lied

I don't believe that you've lied even s single time about your targets, or there being motion.

[Hydrad]

like I don't feel like I'm going to change my mind about lalight. I'm pretty sure I'm voting him no matter what. should I wait or does it really matter.