I still like Haddock.
Could also do Space.
Not really sure how Mafia would react here. I would assume they didn't know Schadd was Mafia, but might have suspected. Probably best play would be to go after him regardless, as it's a reasonable argument even if he were town, but also might get towncred if he's scum.
Oh... maybe Mafia just shot him last night. There wasn't a traditional kill.
I guess that means Galzria doesn't get quite so much towncred for spearheading the Schadd thing.
Well, my original thought was if Mafia knew Schadd was with them, and they realized the hammer thing was a blunder, then it's likely at least one of them would want to get out ahead of it, so one of the people more eager to lynch Schadd is more likely scum.
Also, DatSwan looks seemingly better, because if Schadd ....... actually scratch that. I was going to say that DatSwan could have done all the town fakeclaims that fit in the scum QT, but Schadd would not have joined it until after night actions resolved, so they wouldn't have had time to talk about it.
Okay, so regardless no discussion between Schadd and Mafia team. I suppose I need to go back and look at whether the discussions around alignments of Priests look natural or premeditated.