Here are my overnight thoughts:
So I took some notes over the night on D1 and I am going to paraphrase.
1) I found
226 by Ash scummy for deflecting from the PPS lynch. My theory is that mafia would initially deflect from the PPS lynch because they have reason to think he is more likely to be telling the truth.
2) I found
227 by Haddock scummy for the same reason. But moreso.
3) Then I saw a post (which I didn't mark) that made me think scum on WW for the same reason. Then I started to think maybe I was zero-ing in too much on one thing, and I should reconsider which of those three I'm most likely to be wrong about.
4) Saw some towny stuff from WW and scummy stuff from Datswan and scummy stuff from silver and ended up with a scum list of: Datswan, haddock, Ash, silver, in that order. Today I think ash and silver look less scummy for a) being frozen and b) thinking they could block the mafia NK.
5) Realized that Awaclus' only contributions have been in relation to talking about his miller T-shirt and how he thought bidding worked. He even framed himself to be able to do that in his first post about claiming. Seems scummy - like he created something for him to talk about in the game. Added him to the scum list.
6) Got mixed reactions from Ash's late day posts. I noted that I agree with
454 that we should look back at silver's PPS stuff because it's all a bit weird.
Haddock and Datswan are still my best leads for scum I think.
I'm fine claiming item draft order.