Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LaLight]

vote: Eevee

[gkrieg13]

so SM didn't kill or was blocked!  Also I'm glad WW is dead.  He is one of the hardest people for me to read!

Oh yes, maybe he was blocked

I don't see any reason why they wouldn't shoot, so I think it is very likely they were blocked.

PPE vote: Eevee

Oh yes, I know. i also know who i blocked

I don't think anyone would take doctor, so it was either 1-shot killproof or RB or JK I would guess.

[gkrieg13]

My PPE vote: Eevee got eaten by quotes

[LaLight]

I think i know why ww was killed. He didn't care who to lynch

[LaLight]

And also now do you realize i behave weirdely when I am a pr? That happened every other game. I really didn't want to claim

[LaLight]

My PPE vote: Eevee got eaten by quotes

Early bus, huh?

[gkrieg13]

Is it just me or Eevee and gkrieg behaved like they knew for sure alignments of both of me and idptg and craved for some town cred knowing the lynch will nevertheless happen?

I was gunning for you way before EoD, so I don't think this argument holds.

[gkrieg13]

My PPE vote: Eevee got eaten by quotes

Early bus, huh?

I figured you had blocked Eevee. 

[gkrieg13]

And also now do you realize i behave weirdely when I am a pr? That happened every other game. I really didn't want to claim

But when you act weirdly, it increases the likelihood that you will have to claim...

[LaLight]

Is it just me or Eevee and gkrieg behaved like they knew for sure alignments of both of me and idptg and craved for some town cred knowing the lynch will nevertheless happen?

I was gunning for you way before EoD, so I don't think this argument holds.

But "no lynch or LaLight lynch"? Really? Can you, please, explain it? Idptg was "townie somewhere? Why hopping off the wagon of RVS is town!trait?

[gkrieg13]

I think i know why ww was killed. He didn't care who to lynch

?

[LaLight]

And also now do you realize i behave weirdely when I am a pr? That happened every other game. I really didn't want to claim

But when you act weirdly, it increases the likelihood that you will have to claim...

I am not that good. When I'm a pr, a good pr even, I always act very different from when I'm a vt... i can't do anything. I try, but eventually nothing works and people read me as scum

[LaLight]

My PPE vote: Eevee got eaten by quotes

I almost see the argument in scum qt: "i will probably go down D2 so feel free to bus me"

[LaLight]

I think i know why ww was killed. He didn't care who to lynch

?

I think only one role/alignment doesn't care who to lynch

[gkrieg13]

Is it just me or Eevee and gkrieg behaved like they knew for sure alignments of both of me and idptg and craved for some town cred knowing the lynch will nevertheless happen?

I was gunning for you way before EoD, so I don't think this argument holds.

But "no lynch or LaLight lynch"? Really? Can you, please, explain it? Idptg was "townie somewhere? Why hopping off the wagon of RVS is town!trait?

Well for starters, I was right.  IDPTG was town, so everything he did came from a town perspective.  I was saying that for IDPTG, who is relatively new and still timid about lynching people, jumping off an early RVS wagon that is getting kind of close to lynch is townie.

You did some legitimately scummy things D1, and the fact that people were choosing to lynch a lurker with no case on them, and the way the wagon popped up was clearly not going to lead to a scum lynch.

[2.71828.....]

I really need to reread. I had a terrible D1, I will try to do better today.

That betting said, I believe LaLight. But a jailkeeper target does not do anything at all to convict someone as scum.

[gkrieg13]

My PPE vote: Eevee got eaten by quotes

I almost see the argument in scum qt: "i will probably go down D2 so feel free to bus me"

I guess I have a different view of this game.  I don't think Eevee is the de facto lynch today.  What makes you think that?  Like especially to the point that you think Eevee's scum partners would bus him because it is unsalvageable?

[Galzria]

It is unlikely, although not impossible, for LL to be telling the truth about his bid.

At the same time, while unlikely, I don't see why he would lie either.

This is as true now as it was yesterday.

[2.71828.....]

It is unlikely, although not impossible, for LL to be telling the truth about his bid.

At the same time, while unlikely, I don't see why he would lie either.

This is as true now as it was yesterday.

I am very interested in this

[LaLight]

Is it just me or Eevee and gkrieg behaved like they knew for sure alignments of both of me and idptg and craved for some town cred knowing the lynch will nevertheless happen?

I was gunning for you way before EoD, so I don't think this argument holds.

But "no lynch or LaLight lynch"? Really? Can you, please, explain it? Idptg was "townie somewhere? Why hopping off the wagon of RVS is town!trait?

Well for starters, I was right.  IDPTG was town, so everything he did came from a town perspective.  I was saying that for IDPTG, who is relatively new and still timid about lynching people, jumping off an early RVS wagon that is getting kind of close to lynch is townie.

You did some legitimately scummy things D1, and the fact that people were choosing to lynch a lurker with no case on them, and the way the wagon popped up was clearly not going to lead to a scum lynch.

Look. The only question I have is why would scum not hop off. They would, cause staying on rvs wagon is scummy. Idptg was town, that's true. I am questioning you. Whether you knew for sure he was town or not.

[2.71828.....]

So.... draft positions 11-17 claim now?

[Galzria]

My PPE vote: Eevee got eaten by quotes

I almost see the argument in scum qt: "i will probably go down D2 so feel free to bus me"

I guess I have a different view of this game.  I don't think Eevee is the de facto lynch today.  What makes you think that?  Like especially to the point that you think Eevee's scum partners would bus him because it is unsalvageable?

His logic also fails because if he were correct in that he blocked a kill by targeting Eevee then Eevee couldn't have "scum partners" - as the mafia kill went through last night. The only kill he could've blocked was the SM. There could be a Mother, but that's it.

[gkrieg13]

I really need to reread. I had a terrible D1, I will try to do better today.

That betting said, I believe LaLight. But a jailkeeper target does not do anything at all to convict someone as scum.

It does help narrow down who the SM is.  They HAD to be blocked or their target chose 1-shot deathproof or was jailed.  1-shot deathproof isn't very useful for finding SM, and they definitely shouldn't claim.

RB and JK should consider claiming their targets though.

[gkrieg13]

It is unlikely, although not impossible, for LL to be telling the truth about his bid.

At the same time, while unlikely, I don't see why he would lie either.

This is as true now as it was yesterday.

I agree with you, but could you spell it out for me?

[Teproc]

So, LL, just to be clear: you are claiming to have targete Eevee last night, correct ?

If so, I'd like to know the thought process here.

WW kill seemed weird to me at first, but I suppose mafia went SK-hunting.

PPE: 8