Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Dylan32]

I'll have a reply with my answers typed up in another tab. Let me know when you have yours and we'll set a time then

[sudgy]

Alright, how about at 9:05 forum time?  Is that too fast?

And if others want to join us, that should be fine (except maybe O and Galzria).

[Dylan32]

Alright, how about at 9:05 forum time?  Is that too fast?

And if others want to join us, that should be fine (except maybe O and Galzria).

Let me finish this game first so I won't miss it

[Dylan32]

Alright, how about at 9:05 forum time?  Is that too fast?

And if others want to join us, that should be fine (except maybe O and Galzria).

Let me finish this game first so I won't miss it

Almost out on piles. 9:10 should be good, but I'll confirm before then

[Galzria]

I gave M-2 (M-II) as my favorite. It was my first ever game of Mafia (and I WAS Mafia!). Robz and I communicated via PM at night.

I guessed M-87 after looking at the signup list here and trying to find a big game with a large number of people from this one in it. Don't think I put much more thought into it than that. I might've read some post game? I don't remember.

My "5 scariest Mafia team" was Eevee (can never read him as anything but town), Jimmm (flies way under the radar), Sudgy (a mini-Eevee) and two randoms because I didn't know how to read them (J Reggie & Calamitas).

I guessed the 5 most common choices to be Eevee, Jimmm, Faust, Ashersky, LaLight (my top 2, the two I think are most respected, and one random).

For town receiving powers I picked: mcmc, Jimmm, O, Eevee, Faust

My guess at most popular choices were: Ashersky, Eevee, Faust, mcmc, LaLight, Sudgy, Space, Galzria, e, O

You'll notice a pattern between the big names from my day being about 75% of my choices, mixed with about 25% new faces.

I don't think this exercise helps us any however. Not enough people to put any weight in choices, and if scum is lying about their draft spot I expect they'll have these results to back them up anyway.

[Dylan32]

I'm good. I could bump it up a couple minutes to 9:08 ish if that would work.

[Galzria]

Sorry, was mobile posting and didn't PPE.

[Galzria]

Still doubt it matters though.

[Dylan32]

I gave M-2 (M-II) as my favorite. It was my first ever game of Mafia (and I WAS Mafia!). Robz and I communicated via PM at night.

I guessed M-87 after looking at the signup list here and trying to find a big game with a large number of people from this one in it. Don't think I put much more thought into it than that. I might've read some post game? I don't remember.

My "5 scariest Mafia team" was Eevee (can never read him as anything but town), Jimmm (flies way under the radar), Sudgy (a mini-Eevee) and two randoms because I didn't know how to read them (J Reggie & Calamitas).

I guessed the 5 most common choices to be Eevee, Jimmm, Faust, Ashersky, LaLight (my top 2, the two I think are most respected, and one random).

For town receiving powers I picked: mcmc, Jimmm, O, Eevee, Faust

My guess at most popular choices were: Ashersky, Eevee, Faust, mcmc, LaLight, Sudgy, Space, Galzria, e, O

You'll notice a pattern between the big names from my day being about 75% of my choices, mixed with about 25% new faces.

I don't think this exercise helps us any however. Not enough people to put any weight in choices, and if scum is lying about their draft spot I expect they'll have these results to back them up anyway.

I doubt scum shared the exact answers, and with sudgy and I one spot away in the order, if the other person has way different answers, they will be conf scum to the other one who is town.

[sudgy]

I'm ready for 9:08.

[sudgy]

What I said:

Scum: ashersky, Awaclus, Galzria, Jimmmmm, LaLight
Town: gkrieg, faust, Galzria, 2.71828....., Eevee

What I guessed:

Scum: ashersky, pingpongsam, gkrieg, Galzria, Eevee
Town: Eevee, LaLight, Galzria, faust, 2.71828....., Calamitas, gkrieg, ashersky, Jimmmmm, iguanaiguana

Just so you know, I was not confident in most of these.  I was shocked when I got #7.

[Dylan32]

1) faust, ash, awaclus, gkrieg, Calamitas

2) faust, gkrieg, ash, eevee, pps, Space, e, Calamitas, awaclus, Jimmmmm

3) 80

[Galzria]

I gave M-2 (M-II) as my favorite. It was my first ever game of Mafia (and I WAS Mafia!). Robz and I communicated via PM at night.

I guessed M-87 after looking at the signup list here and trying to find a big game with a large number of people from this one in it. Don't think I put much more thought into it than that. I might've read some post game? I don't remember.

My "5 scariest Mafia team" was Eevee (can never read him as anything but town), Jimmm (flies way under the radar), Sudgy (a mini-Eevee) and two randoms because I didn't know how to read them (J Reggie & Calamitas).

I guessed the 5 most common choices to be Eevee, Jimmm, Faust, Ashersky, LaLight (my top 2, the two I think are most respected, and one random).

For town receiving powers I picked: mcmc, Jimmm, O, Eevee, Faust

My guess at most popular choices were: Ashersky, Eevee, Faust, mcmc, LaLight, Sudgy, Space, Galzria, e, O

You'll notice a pattern between the big names from my day being about 75% of my choices, mixed with about 25% new faces.

I don't think this exercise helps us any however. Not enough people to put any weight in choices, and if scum is lying about their draft spot I expect they'll have these results to back them up anyway.

I doubt scum shared the exact answers, and with sudgy and I one spot away in the order, if the other person has way different answers, they will be conf scum to the other one who is town.

It is literally the first thing I would've done if I was scum. There would be decent likelihood that it was brought up in game and would help give all sorts of information if trying to PR hunt.

[Dylan32]

I didn't see your confirmation come through until like 3 seconds before and hit it as soon as I could... Sorry PPE 1

[sudgy]

I didn't see your confirmation come through until like 3 seconds before and hit it as soon as I could... Sorry PPE 1

No worries, I didn't realize that confirmation was so close.

Anyway, we're kind of close, so I'm not sure what that means...

[Dylan32]

And yeah those were only my guesses, not what I said.

[sudgy]

Yeah, we probably should have done this sooner.

[Dylan32]

So we had 2 the same but both different order for scum and 7 similar with fairly different spots in the order. Idk what to make of this

[Dylan32]

So I'm pretty dang sure faust, ash, and gkrieg were all on #1, and pps probably was there unless people tended to think he was mislynched too often to really be scary.

[O]

apparently I'm a dirty liar? Or halfway so. I answered my personal questions differently than I suggested, but not the "for everyone" questions.

Personal:

1) Most Feared Mafia Team: Galzria, Faust, Gkrieg, Roadrunner, MCMC

2)  Most hoped town PRs: Eevee, PPS, Ashersky, LaLight, Faust

3) Favorite Game: M8

Guesses for Everyone:

1) LaLight, Faust, E, Ashersky, Awaclus

2) same 5 plus Gkrieg, Sudgy, Andrew, TWM, Calamitas

3) Mafia 86

[sudgy]

Well, both of yours seem to match up pretty well.

But some of yours seem to be kind of similar to mine too?

[O]

Well, both of yours seem to match up pretty well.

But some of yours seem to be kind of similar to mine too?

i think literally everyone put Ashersky LaLight Faust? it's really surprising that I got 22nd with these similarities.

[sudgy]

Where's Space to analyze this stuff when you need her?

[O]

i wonder if it would have been legitimate meta for me to lie as town about these rankings, because i sure feel scummier claiming #22 with so many matches.

[O]

21*