Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LaLight]

who is pps sheeping?

[LaLight]

and where exactly was our Jailkeeper?

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

and where exactly was our Jailkeeper?

I would like to know that

[faust]

The claims and stuff:

faust - 1, 2-shot Vig (Slot 1)

Jimmmmm - 3, Masonic Lover (Slot 6)
mcmc - 4, Hammer Hero (Slot 9)
LaLight - 5, VT
e - 6, 1-shot Bus Driver (Slot 13)
sudgy - 7, VT (Slot 6)
Dylan32 - 8, VT (Slot 13)
Eevee - 9, VT turned into Masonic Lover (Slot 6)
Awaclus - 10, VT
iguanaiguana - 11, VT
ashersky - 12, non-VT

JReggie - 14, VT
pingpongsam - 15, Restless Sheeper (Slot 2)

JaketheBaseballGod22 - 17, Tracker (Slot 12)
SpaceAnemone - 18, VT

Galzria - 20, Jailkeeper (Slot 11)
O - 21, VT

2.71828..... - ?, VT
pingpongsam - ?, Restless Sheeper
RoadRunner - ?, VT
The_Wine_Merchant - ?, Hider (Slot 10)

Dead and unclaimed:

AndrewisFTTW - ?, VT
gkrieg - ?, VT
Calamitas - ?, Mafia Goon
Eevee - ?, Masonic Lover or VT
Cuzz - ?, VT

I think we're still missing some claims? Not sure though. Feel free to update this list.

[faust]

who is pps sheeping?

TWM. So noone.

[faust]

Ah, forgot to include RR.

[LaLight]

who is pps sheeping?

TWM. So noone.

ugh, my computer near exploded when I was looking for it opening the whole thread

yeah, confirmed, TWM

PPE: 1

[SpaceAnemone]

who is pps sheeping?

I was just wondering that. I'm on my work server, so I don't have my game notes with me, and I'm not very free to look at this stuff till early on.

If TWM died from hiding then it points to me or iguana as scum, since mcmc is now conf!town. I can tell you for sure that that would mean that iguana is scum, assuming TWM didn't deviate from his plan. However, it's also possible that he didn't hide, or that he was hiding behind mcmc when mcmc died.

It's also possible that we have three kills because scum has the vig, their faction kill, and maybe an inventor to give them more kills or something? I recall a post early in the game where someone enumerated all the possible kill mechanisms that might be in play-- could someone repost that if they find it?

PPE: 5 (Sorry.. busy at work!)

[LaLight]

that's what I am thinking, 2nd slot has not claimed. That might be gkrieg, yeah, but maybe it's scum with a PR and the real scum took Calamitas' slot.

@faust, how did the thing with "who might choose M19 as favorite" ended?

[faust]

Anyway, top suspects:

- ash for refusing to claim
- Space/iguana because TWM hid behind one of them
- Galzria because mcmc died

The Galzria thing is sort of weak because the chance of scum having either Roleblocker or Strongman are relatively high.

[LaLight]

The claims and stuff:

faust - 1, 2-shot Vig (Slot 1)

Jimmmmm - 3, Masonic Lover (Slot 6)
mcmc - 4, Hammer Hero (Slot 9)
LaLight - 5, VT
e - 6, 1-shot Bus Driver (Slot 13)
sudgy - 7, VT (Slot 6)
Dylan32 - 8, VT (Slot 13)
Eevee - 9, VT turned into Masonic Lover (Slot 6)
Awaclus - 10, VT
iguanaiguana - 11, VT
ashersky - 12, non-VT

JReggie - 14, VT
pingpongsam - 15, Restless Sheeper (Slot 2)

JaketheBaseballGod22 - 17, Tracker (Slot 12)
SpaceAnemone - 18, VT
RoadRunner - 19, VT
Galzria - 20, Jailkeeper (Slot 11)
O - 21, VT

pingpongsam - ?, Restless Sheeper

The_Wine_Merchant - ?, Hider (Slot 10)

Dead and unclaimed:

AndrewisFTTW - ?, VT
gkrieg - ?, VT
Calamitas - ?, Mafia Goon
Eevee - ?, Masonic Lover or VT
Cuzz - ?, VT

I think we're still missing some claims? Not sure though. Feel free to update this list.

FTFY. there was E twice

[LaLight]

@Robz, how is the scenario with Roleblocker/Jailkeeper targeting each other an killing resolved?

[faust]

that's what I am thinking, 2nd slot has not claimed. That might be gkrieg, yeah, but maybe it's scum with a PR and the real scum took Calamitas' slot.

@faust, how did the thing with "who might choose M19 as favorite" ended?

We know that someone did because Jimmmm chose it.

Galzria, sudgy, Cuzz were in that game. It could be Cuzz getting unlucky. Galzria does not make too much sense given that his claim mostly fits. So that would leave sudgy.

[LaLight]

If TWM died from hiding then it points to me or iguana as scum, since mcmc is now conf!town. I can tell you for sure that that would mean that iguana is scum, assuming TWM didn't deviate from his plan. However, it's also possible that he didn't hide, or that he was hiding behind mcmc when mcmc died.

That's very townie to remember and recall. I, um, forgot this

[faust]

If TWM died from hiding then it points to me or iguana as scum, since mcmc is now conf!town. I can tell you for sure that that would mean that iguana is scum, assuming TWM didn't deviate from his plan. However, it's also possible that he didn't hide, or that he was hiding behind mcmc when mcmc died.

That's very townie to remember and recall. I, um, forgot this

Dunno. It's very likely that TWM died from hiding. He certainly wouldn't hide behind mcmc. Space should be voting for iguana and the reason that they aren't is they need a way out after iguana flips town.

[LaLight]

that's what I am thinking, 2nd slot has not claimed. That might be gkrieg, yeah, but maybe it's scum with a PR and the real scum took Calamitas' slot.

@faust, how did the thing with "who might choose M19 as favorite" ended?

We know that someone did because Jimmmm chose it.

Galzria, sudgy, Cuzz were in that game. It could be Cuzz getting unlucky. Galzria does not make too much sense given that his claim mostly fits. So that would leave sudgy.

sudgy claimed after it was known there masons, and he claimed to take slot 6 and he was one of the first people to claim. Well, well, well.

vote: sudgy

[Robz888]

@Robz, how is the scenario with Roleblocker/Jailkeeper targeting each other an killing resolved?

In the order of operations post on page 1, it says roleblocker blocks jk, jk blocks no one, if their orders conflict.

[LaLight]

@Robz, how is the scenario with Roleblocker/Jailkeeper targeting each other an killing resolved?

In the order of operations post on page 1, it says roleblocker blocks jk, jk blocks no one, if their orders conflict.

I am sorry, thanks.

[Roadrunner7671]

I'm town again. Thanks for doubting me guys

[faust]

that's what I am thinking, 2nd slot has not claimed. That might be gkrieg, yeah, but maybe it's scum with a PR and the real scum took Calamitas' slot.

@faust, how did the thing with "who might choose M19 as favorite" ended?

We know that someone did because Jimmmm chose it.

Galzria, sudgy, Cuzz were in that game. It could be Cuzz getting unlucky. Galzria does not make too much sense given that his claim mostly fits. So that would leave sudgy.

sudgy claimed after it was known there masons, and he claimed to take slot 6 and he was one of the first people to claim. Well, well, well.

vote: sudgy

There is much stronger evidence than this.

Oh, and I missed this, but ashersky was also in that game.

[faust]

Grmph, more double-checking reveals sudgy wasn't even in it. Sorry for my laziness.

[LaLight]

I am willing to lynch ash, but i really want to listen to what he will say

Ppe: i will look at it myself

[LaLight]

vote: ashersky

I just don't see anyone else vote for M19

[faust]

I mean, voting for M10 was not that hard. All you needed to do was check the mafia game awards winners and see how many from each game were playing, and then make some educated guesses as tiebreaker.

I really want to see ashersky dead, but it is probably better to resolve the Space/iguana situation first.

[faust]

Unfortunately I have no time right now for excessive rereads of a 3400-post game. Should happen some time later.