Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mcmcsalot]

Back to Vote: mcmc

I don't want to tunnel, I specifically remember a game where I found liopoil(someone I was scum with his first time) scummy early day one and I confirmation biased everything from them on and he turned out to be town.

But man this looks like you gave up pushing me because it wasn't going to work out for you(the votes didn't come for me and they stayed on you). Your reason for unvoting me was because I told people to write stuff down with is as you pointed out pro-town but not towny. Now I explain why setup speculation is really bad for town on day 1 which is also pro-town but not towny and you decide to vote me again.

Can you give me your reasoning for re voting me, like what exactly you found scummy about my recent posts?

[mcmcsalot]

also mcmc, why do you vote O and then remove all the teeth from that vote by talking about how you're likely to remove it?

Because I'm open to the possibility that O is going to change his behavior

How is that indicative of his alignment?

Because as pointed out early on, ozzle has a relatively stubborn personality. He also hasn't played in a long time and I think we have developed as players a lot since then. So there is a chance he's town legitimately wanting to talk about he setup because he thinks it's he best way for him to find scum. I'm voting him because currently I think he's scum trying to sabotage town.

[Roadrunner7671]

I'm definitely not against O. I don't feel like he has been anti town, and he's been contributing stuff.

[mcmcsalot]

Eevee, 2.7, Gkrieg, Jim. What do you guys think about my recent thoughts on ozzle? Do you think he is pushing people to speculate so scum knows what townies may or may not have high draft slots. Or do you think he is just trying to find scum the best way he knows how?

[O]

I can't really say I'm going to change me behavior.

At the same time, so far the overwhelming majority of people have shown no interest in following my line so the discussion changes regardless.

Voting for me seems pretty townie tho, to insert my own pseudo-random bullshit reads into this. It wasn't necessary to stop the conversation since the conversation was pretty dead anyways regardless of my will, and so far a disturbingly large number of people have town reads on me so I'm a pretty bad wagon choice.

To spur conversation, which is kinda still lacking IMO despite complaints about having to read to much, I would be willing to lynch Awaclus, Faust, Gkrieg, Roadrunner, Ashersky, and Robz, for a variety of lurkish or distant behavior.

I would be unwilling to lynch TWM, LaLight, Sudgy, e, and probably not Cuzz, because those people have made interesting contributions to discussion/"scumhunting", or, in cuzz's case, sheer volume of conversation.

I'm not going to hide behind a pretense of "scummy" and "not scummy" when I haven't played with the vast majority of the people on that list. At best it's anti-town and pro-town, but more likely it's anti-fun and pro-fun

Part of the problem with these massive setups is that even this isn't good conversation starter since my opinions are really quite irrelevant at this point.

[O]

Eevee, 2.7, Gkrieg, Jim. What do you guys think about my recent thoughts on ozzle? Do you think he is pushing people to speculate so scum knows what townies may or may not have high draft slots. Or do you think he is just trying to find scum the best way he knows how?

Please do note that Ozle is an entirely different and far more wonderful human being than I.

[Cuzz]

To spur conversation, which is kinda still lacking IMO despite complaints about having to read to much, I would be willing to lynch Awaclus, Faust, Gkrieg, Roadrunner, Ashersky, and Robz, for a variety of lurkish or distant behavior.

This I can get behind.

[mcmcsalot]

Please do note that Ozle is an entirely different and far more wonderful human being than I.

Waaaait really...

[LaLight]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

[LaLight]

To spur conversation, which is kinda still lacking IMO despite complaints about having to read to much, I would be willing to lynch Awaclus, Faust, Gkrieg, Roadrunner, Ashersky, and Robz, for a variety of lurkish or distant behavior.

This I can get behind.

i don't get PPEs for some reason

[LaLight]

I can't really get who's more scummier, mcmc or TWM

[LaLight]

oh god

more scummy*

[O]

I always did enjoy the scene in Into The Woods where they break the fourth wall and kill the narrator.

Please do note that Ozle is an entirely different and far more wonderful human being than I.

Waaaait really...

Yea. He was a terrifying mafia player because regardless of alignment he always felt completely innocent child to me. Also for mafia VI he spent the whole day communicating in ridiculous flavor text, which pissed the hell out of all the other players but was hilarious to me, the mod 

[Cuzz]

To spur conversation, which is kinda still lacking IMO despite complaints about having to read to much, I would be willing to lynch Awaclus, Faust, Gkrieg, Roadrunner, Ashersky, and Robz, for a variety of lurkish or distant behavior.

This I can get behind.

For serious, though, not sure I can get behind faust or gkrieg at the moment, at least not for lurking. Faust seemed to hang out here for a little bit and caught up on about 10 pages and gave some opinions. gkrieg has been involved too, though I sure don't have any kind of townread.

In my opinion, Space, Calamitas, Andrew, Jimmmmm, Dylan, Awaclus, ashersky are the lurkiest so far.

Calamitas and Dylan in particular I have the nothingest of nothing reads on.

[mcmcsalot]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

We are averaging a page an hour, stop this even though it's fun. I'm counting every post like this from now on as scummy seriously. You want a 60 page day 1 because this is how you get it.

Ppe 2: you've seen me as scum a lot, together and as a mod. Do you think I'm playing like then or like m96?

[Roadrunner7671]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

We are averaging a page an hour, stop this even though it's fun. I'm counting every post like this from now on as scummy seriously. You want a 60 page day 1 because this is how you get it.

And everyone was biting my head off for not wanting to read the first 14 pages because I thought it was all fluff. But now gumming up the thread is scummy.

[Cuzz]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

We are averaging a page an hour, stop this even though it's fun. I'm counting every post like this from now on as scummy seriously. You want a 60 page day 1 because this is how you get it.

Ppe 2: you've seen me as scum a lot, together and as a mod. Do you think I'm playing like then or like m96?

You get it by having 23 players. Discouraging conversation is anti-town. If people have such a huge problem with a lot to read D1 they shouldn't have signed up for a 23 person game.

I already pointed out 7 people who are seriously lurking. Too much content is not our problem.

[LaLight]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

We are averaging a page an hour, stop this even though it's fun. I'm counting every post like this from now on as scummy seriously. You want a 60 page day 1 because this is how you get it.

Ppe 2: you've seen me as scum a lot, together and as a mod. Do you think I'm playing like then or like m96?

Ok, boring guy. Well, to be serious, you're right.

I wouldn't take M96 into account, you were playing a whole different game there being a Virgin. (God it's hard, but I am not joking, not... joking...)

I mostly take your posts from this game independently of your meta, which is very explainable. You point me at meta => You are aware of your meta => You may imitate it well. I mostly wouldn't take meta arguments

PPE

[O]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

We are averaging a page an hour, stop this even though it's fun. I'm counting every post like this from now on as scummy seriously. You want a 60 page day 1 because this is how you get it.

Ppe 2: you've seen me as scum a lot, together and as a mod. Do you think I'm playing like then or like m96?

You see, there's the horrific problem with my mafia personality: I'm pro-fun before I'm pro-faction, which yes in this case is in fact town.

[LaLight]

I would be willing to lynch Robz

We may try that!

We are averaging a page an hour, stop this even though it's fun. I'm counting every post like this from now on as scummy seriously. You want a 60 page day 1 because this is how you get it.

Ppe 2: you've seen me as scum a lot, together and as a mod. Do you think I'm playing like then or like m96?

You get it by having 23 players. Discouraging conversation is anti-town. If people have such a huge problem with a lot to read D1 they shouldn't have signed up for a 23 person game.

I already pointed out 7 people who are seriously lurking. Too much content is not our problem.

I don't agree with red one. If the whole post is a meaningless joke, it's bad. I mean, do we need to encourage a conversation about lynching Robz? O_o

PPE

[J Reggie]

I'm still perfectly happy with my vote on TWM.

Also as LaLight said, pointing out you're playing into your own town meta is unhelpful at best.

[Awaclus]

Lynching on the basis of lurking is retarded.

[mcmcsalot]

I'm still perfectly happy with my vote on TWM.

Also as LaLight said, pointing out you're playing into your own town meta is unhelpful at best.

I would happily go back to twm he didn't answer my question.

[Robz888]

Vote Count 1.6

LaLight (1): SpaceAnemone,
mcmcsalot (3): 2.71828..., gkrieg, The_Wine_Merchant
2.71828 (2): AndrewisFTTW, Awaclus
ashersky (2): LaLight, iguanaiguana
Cuzz (1): Eevee
J Reggie (2): JaketheBaseballGod22, Galzria
The_Wine_Merchant (4): J Reggie, ashersky, Dylan32, sudgy
RoadRunner (1): O
sudgy (1): faust
O (1): mcmcsalot
iguanaiguana (1): Cuzz

Not Voting (4): Calamitas, pingpongsam, RoadRunner, Jimmmm,

With 23 alive it takes just 10 to lynch. Day 1 ends on Tuesday, May 23, at 10:00 AM Forum Time.

[Cuzz]

Lynching on the basis of lurking is retarded.

I was under the impression that there was a civility pledge in this community. If I am mistaken about that let me know now and I'll replace out.