Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ashersky]

I don't think I'm gonna read all this. I also think that posting a whole bunch is very scummy.

FOS: RR. Scum Is less likely to want to read the whole thread because they have fewer real reads to make.

I only need to make 6 reads.

SK slip?  How do you know the covert things didn't happen?

[Dylan32]

It isn't scummy from RR, it is just silly.

its perhaps not scummy (i think it is), but it definitely is anti-town.

I don't think it is quite scummy, literally for no other reason than RR consistently gets mislynched for saying things that are only anti-town as opposed to scummy.

PPE a bunch

[J Reggie]

I don't think RR chooses jailkeeper as town.

What the hell?

It's possible he didn't read the setup. But he's claiming there are only 6 scum.

And I didn't even think about converting SK to VT. So there's no way he can know there are 6 scum without being scum himself.

[Cuzz]

It isn't scummy from RR, it is just silly.

its perhaps not scummy (i think it is), but it definitely is anti-town.

I don't think it is quite scummy, literally for no other reason than RR consistently gets mislynched for saying things that are only anti-town as opposed to scummy.

PPE a bunch

I am 100% behind lynching anti-Town play D1.

[mcmcsalot]

Hey so I highest doubt we are going to lynch someone based on the following:

1) the roles they think are strong
2) the roles they think have or haven't been taken
3) the possibility that they are high or low in the draft order (okay I can see a little reason to lynch here but it would be more of a claim draft position instead of role when you hit l-1/2 ect.)

So we should stop talking about those things and scumhunt.

Ppe:5

[Cuzz]

I don't think RR chooses jailkeeper as town.

What the hell?

It's possible he didn't read the setup. But he's claiming there are only 6 scum.

And I didn't even think about converting SK to VT. So there's no way he can know there are 6 scum without being scum himself.

meh, he could also just not be thinking that hard and assuming 6 scum by default.

[J Reggie]

Hey so I highest doubt we are going to lynch someone based on the following:

1) the roles they think are strong
2) the roles they think have or haven't been taken
3) the possibility that they are high or low in the draft order (okay I can see a little reason to lynch here but it would be more of a claim draft position instead of role when you hit l-1/2 ect.)

So we should stop talking about those things and scumhunt.

Ppe:5

I think we were done talking about those things until you brought it up again.

[Cuzz]

Hey so I highest doubt we are going to lynch someone based on the following:

1) the roles they think are strong
2) the roles they think have or haven't been taken
3) the possibility that they are high or low in the draft order (okay I can see a little reason to lynch here but it would be more of a claim draft position instead of role when you hit l-1/2 ect.)

So we should stop talking about those things and scumhunt.

Ppe:5

boo. D1 discussion has utility beyond the D1 lynch.

[Cuzz]

mcmc do some scumhunting and give us your top scumreads right now.

[mcmcsalot]

Hey so I highest doubt we are going to lynch someone based on the following:

1) the roles they think are strong
2) the roles they think have or haven't been taken
3) the possibility that they are high or low in the draft order (okay I can see a little reason to lynch here but it would be more of a claim draft position instead of role when you hit l-1/2 ect.)

So we should stop talking about those things and scumhunt.

Ppe:5

I think we were done talking about those things until you brought it up again.

Are you kidding me...

I don't think RR chooses jailkeeper as town.

That's 7 posts befor mine.

[ashersky]

Let's random lynch the first 10 to get this game to a manageable size.





Not really.






Except maybe.

[J Reggie]

Hey so I highest doubt we are going to lynch someone based on the following:

1) the roles they think are strong
2) the roles they think have or haven't been taken
3) the possibility that they are high or low in the draft order (okay I can see a little reason to lynch here but it would be more of a claim draft position instead of role when you hit l-1/2 ect.)

So we should stop talking about those things and scumhunt.

Ppe:5

I think we were done talking about those things until you brought it up again.

Are you kidding me...

I don't think RR chooses jailkeeper as town.

That's 7 posts befor mine.

I was saying that because it was one of the only ways he could be sure of the number of scum as town. But I was wrong even then. So nevermind.

[O]

what even is day 1 "scumhunting"

is it you all pretending that him saying "i only need 6" reads is a scumslip because there could be a 5-2 split instead of 5-1?

because that's some unhelpful crap that runs in circles.

I guess I'm just not seeing this amazingly productive "scumhunting" yall keep talking about that somehow more effective than the interesting role/draft discussions.

[gkrieg13]

Let's random lynch the first 10 to get this game to a manageable size.





Not really.






Except maybe.

uh, that is like LYLO then...

[ashersky]

what even is day 1 "scumhunting"

is it you all pretending that him saying "i only need 6" reads is a scumslip because there could be a 5-2 split instead of 5-1?

because that's some unhelpful crap that runs in circles.

I guess I'm just not seeing this amazingly productive "scumhunting" yall keep talking about that somehow more effective than the interesting role/draft discussions.

It could also be 5-0.  Or 5-survivor.

[mcmcsalot]

mcmc do some scumhunting and give us your top scumreads right now.

Someone mentioned Voltaire style early game poe's I think that's the better way to scumhunt this early in a game this big otherwise it's a lot to handle. So sorry not a lot of scumreads but town on galz/ash/cuzz/2.7/O

[J Reggie]

what even is day 1 "scumhunting"

is it you all pretending that him saying "i only need 6" reads is a scumslip because there could be a 5-2 split instead of 5-1?

because that's some unhelpful crap that runs in circles.

I guess I'm just not seeing this amazingly productive "scumhunting" yall keep talking about that somehow more effective than the interesting role/draft discussions.

Sorry, I'm just overly attentive for scumslips D1.

[ashersky]

Actually, someone said survivor earlier.  Breadcrumb?

[Cuzz]

Let's random lynch the first 10 to get this game to a manageable size.





Not really.






Except maybe.

There could be up to 4 NKs. Game could be at a reasonable size with town in awful shape by D3 or so. We should be more cautious than one might think.

ppe lots

[ashersky]

And for the love of all we must lynch the survivor, if they claim.  Every game ever stands as proof.

[Cuzz]

Actually, someone said survivor earlier.  Breadcrumb?

ughhghghh

[Cuzz]

What is a poe?

[LaLight]

to make my point more clearly:

vote:LaLight


reasoning:

we have no Innocent child. Investigation Immune and 2-shot Vig are both higher utility for the Scumteam than the town. LaLight is the most likely in my eyes to have the #1 draft slot and claim the #1 role, having read every mafia game. 

I'm fully open to arguments that we shouldn't be lynching a likely vig, that LaLight doesn't understand you all very well, or just general scumminess arguments later on.

So your argument is that if I would be #1 to choose a role I should've chosen IC at all costs? I don't think this argument is legit

[Cuzz]

to make my point more clearly:

vote:LaLight


reasoning:

we have no Innocent child. Investigation Immune and 2-shot Vig are both higher utility for the Scumteam than the town. LaLight is the most likely in my eyes to have the #1 draft slot and claim the #1 role, having read every mafia game. 

I'm fully open to arguments that we shouldn't be lynching a likely vig, that LaLight doesn't understand you all very well, or just general scumminess arguments later on.

So your argument is that if I would be #1 to choose a role I should've chosen IC at all costs? I don't think this argument is legit

I don't think that's exactly O's point

[LaLight]

What is a poe?

Process of elimination